Nanoscale profiling of evolving intermolecular interactions in ageing FUS condensates

Alyssa Miller, Zenon Toprakcioglu, Seema Qamar, Peter St George‐Hyslop, Francesco Simone Ruggeri, Tuomas P. J. Knowles, Michele VendruscolobioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a microfluidic spray deposition technique to study the aging of FUS protein condensates at the nanoscale. They reveal that these initially fluid-like condensates transition to a more solid-like state over time, driven by changes in intermolecular interactions and the formation of non-amyloid β-sheets, offering insights into neurodegenerative diseases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proteins can self-assemble into dynamic structures called biomolecular condensates, which are crucial for cellular functions. However, aberrant transitions from a fluid-like to a solid-like state are implicated in neurodegenerative diseases like ALS. Understanding the molecular basis of these transitions and how condensates change over time (ageing) is challenging due to their sensitivity to their environment and the difficulty in preparing them for detailed analysis. This paper aims to address this by developing a method to study the nanoscale changes in FUS condensates as they age.

Methods

The core innovation here is a microfluidic spray deposition method. This technique allows for the precise deposition of picoliter-sized droplets of FUS condensates onto surfaces. The ultra-fast drying (millisecond timescale) of these droplets is key to preserving the native structure and heterogeneity of the condensates, minimizing surface-induced artifacts.

Following deposition, the researchers employed a combination of techniques for characterization:

  • Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): Used for high-resolution imaging of condensate morphology and for nanomechanical mapping to measure the elastic properties (Young's modulus) of individual condensates.
  • Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) Spectroscopy: Utilized for bulk measurements of secondary structure and for hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) experiments. HDX probes the lability of backbone hydrogens, providing insights into whether the protein is in a dynamic, fluid-like state (rapid exchange) or a more rigid, solid-like state (slow exchange due to hydrogen bonding).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Preserving Condensate Integrity: The microfluidic spray deposition method is shown to effectively preserve the structural features and heterogeneity of FUS condensates, overcoming limitations of traditional deposition techniques.
  • Age-Driven Solidification: FUS condensates transition from a fluid-like to a more solid-like state over time, characterized by an increase in elastic response.
  • Interface-Driven Transition: Solid-like structures, specifically non-amyloid β-sheets, first form at the condensate-solvent interface and then propagate inwards.
  • Role of Cation-π Interactions: An increase in cation-π interactions within the condensate core contributes to the enhanced elastic response as the condensates age.
  • Distinct Solid Structures: The observed solid structures are heterogeneous, non-amyloid β-sheets, stabilized by hydrogen bonds, and distinct from typical amyloid fibrils.
  • Tyrosine Residue Involvement: Tyrosine residues, known to be important for FUS function, adopt different conformations in solid assemblies, suggesting altered interaction networks.

Key Results

  • Morphology Changes: Initially, condensates are small and spherical. Over time (up to 4 hours), their size increases, consistent with fusion events typical of fluid assemblies. After 4 hours, size increase plateaus.
  • Mechanical Properties: Young's modulus increases dramatically with ageing. From ~9-21 kPa at 2-4 hours, it rises to ~37 kPa at 8 hours, and a staggering ~1.1 MPa at 24 hours, indicating a significant stiffening.
  • Secondary Structure: Early-stage condensates (0-4h) are dominated by random coil/α-helical structures, indicating high conformational flexibility. As they age (8-24h), intermolecular β-sheets and β-turns emerge, alongside a decrease in random coil structure, signifying a transition towards more ordered, solid-like states.
  • Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange (HDX): Early-aged condensates show rapid hydrogen exchange, indicative of a fluid state. Late-aged condensates exhibit significantly slower exchange, consistent with the formation of hydrogen-bonded, solid-like structures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Surface Effects: The authors acknowledge that deposition on surfaces, even with their optimized method, can introduce some artifacts, particularly for very dynamic condensates. They note that the measured elastic moduli might be higher than in solution due to surface interactions.
  • Amyloid Formation: While FUS is known to form amyloid fibrils, this study did not observe these structures with full-length FUS. They attribute potential fiber-like structures observed with manual deposition to shear forces from pipetting, suggesting their method avoids this.
  • Future Directions: The paper establishes a platform for studying FUS condensates and their ageing. The authors suggest that this approach can be used to understand how modulators (biological or chemical) affect phase transitions, and to gain a deeper understanding of the role of phase behavior in cellular function and dysfunction. They also highlight the potential for this method to study other complex biomolecular assemblies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract In addition to the native state, proteins can form liquid-like condensates, viscoelastic condensates, such as gels, as well as solid-like condensates, such as amyloid fibrils, crystals and amorphous materials. The material properties of these condensates play important roles in their cellular functions, with aberrant liquid-to-solid phase transitions having been implicated in neurodegenerative diseases. However, the molecular changes and resultant material properties across the whole phase space of condensates are complex and yet to be fully understood. The extreme sensitivity to their environment, which enables their biological function, is also what makes protein condensates particularly challenging experimental targets. Here, we provide a characterisation of the ageing behaviour of the full-length fused in sarcoma (FUS) protein. We achieve this goal by using a microfluidic sample deposition technology to enable the application of surface-based techniques to the study of biological condensates. We first demonstrate that we maintain relevant structural features of condensates in physiologically-relevant conditions on surfaces. Then, using a combination of atomic force microscopy and vibrational spectroscopy, we characterise the spatio-temporal changes in the structure and mechanical properties of the condensates to reveal local phase transitions in individual condensates. We observe that initially dynamic, fluid-like condensates undergo a global increase in elastic response conferred by an increase in the density of cation-π intermolecular interactions. Solid-like structures form first at condensate-solvent interfaces, before heterogeneously propagating throughout the aged fluid core. These solid structures are composed of heterogenous, non-amyloid β-sheets, which are stabilised by hydrogen-bonding interactions not observed in the fluid state. Overall, this study identifies the molecular conformations associated with different physical states of FUS condensates, establishing a technology platform to understand the role of phase behaviour in condensate function and dysfunction.
BibTeX
@misc{miller2023nanoscale,
  author = {Alyssa Miller and Zenon Toprakcioglu and Seema Qamar and Peter St George‐Hyslop and Francesco Simone Ruggeri and Tuomas P. J. Knowles and Michele Vendruscolo},
  title = {{Nanoscale profiling of evolving intermolecular interactions in ageing FUS condensates}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.12.21.572955},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure