Nanoscale Dewetting Transition in Protein Complex Folding

Lan Hua, Xuhui Huang, Pu Liu, Ruhong Zhou, B. J. BerneThe Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether the "dewetting transition" – the expulsion of water from nanoscale hydrophobic interfaces – observed in the protein melittin tetramer is a unique phenomenon or a more general feature of protein complex folding. By developing a novel hydrophobic scoring function and performing extensive molecular dynamics simulations, the researchers identified several other protein complexes (dimers, tetramers, and two-domain proteins) that exhibit this nanoscale water drying, suggesting it may play a significant role in the final stages of protein folding.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The hydrophobic effect is a cornerstone of protein folding and self-assembly, driving nonpolar regions of proteins to associate and minimize contact with water. While this effect is well-understood at larger scales, the behavior of water at nanoscale hydrophobic interfaces within protein complexes is more complex. Previous work by the authors revealed a surprising "dewetting transition" in the melittin tetramer, where water was expelled from a nanoscale hydrophobic channel, leading to a strong attraction between protein subunits. This raised a critical question: is this dewetting phenomenon specific to melittin, or is it a more widespread mechanism that contributes to protein complex formation and folding? Addressing this requires identifying other protein systems that exhibit similar behavior and understanding the structural features that promote it.

Methods

The core of this study involves a two-pronged approach:

  1. Hydrophobic Scoring Function: To efficiently screen the vast protein data bank (PDB), the authors developed a novel "hydrophobic scoring function." This function quantifies two key features believed to be necessary for dewetting:
  2. Large aligned (matched) hydrophobic areas: The degree to which hydrophobic surfaces on two interacting protein domains or oligomers complement each other.
  3. Large connected hydrophobic areas: The extent of contiguous hydrophobic patches on a single protein surface. This function was used to identify promising candidates from the PDB.

  4. Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: For the top candidates identified by the scoring function, extensive MD simulations were performed. These simulations model the behavior of water molecules and protein atoms over time, allowing researchers to directly observe and quantify the presence or absence of dewetting transitions. The simulations explored various protein complex types (tetramers, dimers, two-domain proteins) and investigated the influence of different water models (SPC, TIP3P, SPC/E) and electrostatic treatments (cutoff vs. PME) to assess the robustness of the observed phenomena.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is the Protein Data Bank (PDB). The researchers screened this database for protein tetramers, dimers, and two-domain proteins. They specifically focused on complexes with less than 30% sequence identity to avoid redundancy. The PDB IDs of the identified candidates exhibiting dewetting are listed in Tables 1, 2, and 3.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dewetting is not unique to melittin: The most significant finding is the identification of multiple protein complexes beyond melittin tetramer that exhibit nanoscale dewetting transitions. This suggests that dewetting is a more general phenomenon in protein complex folding.
  • Structural prerequisites for dewetting: The study highlights that dewetting is strongly correlated with specific structural features: large, well-matched hydrophobic interfaces between interacting protein surfaces, and also large, contiguous hydrophobic patches on those surfaces.
  • Scoring function as a useful filter: While not sufficient on its own, the developed hydrophobic scoring function proved to be a valuable tool for pre-screening and identifying potential dewetting candidates from a large database, significantly reducing the computational burden.
  • Robustness of dewetting: The observed dewetting transitions were found to be largely independent of the specific water model used (SPC, TIP3P, SPC/E) and the method for handling long-range electrostatics (cutoff vs. PME), indicating the phenomenon is robust.
  • Potential role in folding kinetics: The study suggests that dewetting-induced hydrophobic collapse could be a significant driving force in the final stages of protein folding, potentially influencing the speed and pathway of complex formation.

Key Results

The study identified:

  • Three protein tetramers exhibiting dewetting transitions.
  • Six protein dimers showing dewetting.
  • Two two-domain proteins displaying dewetting.

These findings were based on MD simulations of candidates selected by the hydrophobic scoring function. For example, the protein dimer 1j3q showed a strong drying transition at a monomer-monomer distance of 4 Å, with water density dropping significantly within 2500 ps. The protein tetramer 1j2w also exhibited dewetting at a dimer-dimer separation of 4 Å, with complete drying occurring in less than 100 ps. The robustness of these transitions was confirmed across different water models and electrostatic treatments.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scoring function limitations: The authors acknowledge that their hydrophobic scoring function, while useful, is "necessary but not sufficient" for identifying dewetting candidates. A high score does not guarantee dewetting, and other factors likely play a role.
  • Experimental validation: The paper presents computational findings and explicitly states that these results are intended to guide "further experimental studies of the role of dewetting in the end stages of protein folding." Direct experimental verification of these predicted dewetting transitions in the identified proteins is the logical next step.
  • Ligand binding: Preliminary results suggest dewetting might also be relevant in ligand-binding pockets. Further investigation into protein-ligand interactions and their potential for dewetting is proposed.
  • Folding kinetics: While some folding simulations were performed, a more comprehensive study of the time scales and kinetics of dewetting-induced collapse across various systems could provide deeper insights into its role in protein folding pathways.

Summary updated

Abstract

In a previous study, a surprising drying transition was observed to take place inside the nanoscale hydrophobic channel in the tetramer of the protein melittin. The goal of this paper is to determine if there are other protein complexes capable of displaying a dewetting transition during their final stage of folding. We searched the entire protein data bank (PDB) for all possible candidates, including protein tetramers, dimers, and two-domain proteins, and then performed the molecular dynamics (MD) simulations on the top candidates identified by a simple hydrophobic scoring function based on aligned hydrophobic surface areas. Our large scale MD simulations found several more proteins, including three tetramers, six dimers, and two two-domain proteins, which display a nanoscale dewetting transition in their final stage of folding. Even though the scoring function alone is not sufficient (i.e., a high score is necessary but not sufficient) in identifying the dewetting candidates, it does provide useful insights into the features of complex interfaces needed for dewetting. All top candidates have two features in common: (1) large aligned (matched) hydrophobic areas between two corresponding surfaces, and (2) large connected hydrophobic areas on the same surface. We have also studied the effect on dewetting of different water models and different treatments of the long-range electrostatic interactions (cutoff vs PME), and found the dewetting phenomena is fairly robust. This work presents a few proteins other than melittin tetramer for further experimental studies of the role of dewetting in the end stages of protein folding.
BibTeX
@article{hua2007nanoscale,
  author = {Lan Hua and Xuhui Huang and Pu Liu and Ruhong Zhou and B. J. Berne},
  title = {{Nanoscale Dewetting Transition in Protein Complex Folding}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry B},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1021/jp0704923},
}
Figure