Nanoscale Characterization of V-Defect in InGaN/GaN QWs LEDs Using Near-Field Scanning Optical Microscopy

Yufeng Li, Weihan Tang, Ye Zhang, Maofeng Guo, Qiang Li, Xilin Su, Aixing Li, Feng YunNanomaterials 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the role of V-defects in InGaN/GaN quantum well LEDs, demonstrating that intentionally larger V-defects can act as preferential current pathways, leading to improved light output power and reduced efficiency droop at high injection currents. By employing nanoscale characterization techniques, the researchers provide direct evidence of enhanced carrier injection into the bottom quantum wells through these defects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gallium nitride (GaN)-based light-emitting diodes (LEDs) are crucial for visible and UV light applications. However, their efficiency often suffers from a phenomenon called "efficiency droop," where the light output decreases as the injection current increases beyond a certain point. While V-defects have been observed in these LEDs and initially suspected to be detrimental to efficiency, their precise role has been debated. Some studies suggest they might act as barriers to non-radiative recombination, while others propose they contribute to leakage currents. This paper aims to clarify the electrical and optical behavior of V-defects at the nanoscale and determine their impact on LED performance, specifically addressing whether they are a cause of inefficiency or a potential solution to the efficiency droop problem.

Methods

The researchers utilized a combination of advanced nanoscale characterization techniques:

  • Near-Field Scanning Optical Microscopy (NSOM): This technique allows for optical measurements (photoluminescence - PL, and electroluminescence - EL) with sub-wavelength resolution, enabling the study of light emission from individual V-defects and their surroundings. They employed both NSOM-PL and NSOM-EL mapping to visualize emission intensity variations.
  • Conductive Atomic Force Microscopy (CAFM): CAFM was used to map the current distribution across the sample surface with high spatial resolution (down to 30 nm). This allowed them to identify preferential current injection pathways related to the V-defects.
  • Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM): High-resolution TEM was used to visualize the cross-section of the V-defects, providing detailed structural information about their formation and the growth of quantum wells within them.
  • Regular Electroluminescence (EL) and Photoluminescence (PL) Spectroscopy: Standard EL and PL measurements were performed on the fabricated LED chips and samples to assess overall device performance and material quality.
  • Current-Voltage (I-V) Characteristics: I-V curves were measured at specific points inside and outside the V-defects to understand the electrical behavior.

The study intentionally modified the size of V-defects, creating larger ones (around 300 nm) compared to the typical smaller ones (around 50 nm) found in reference samples.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the characterization of fabricated LED samples with intentionally modified V-defects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • V-defects as Shunt Paths: The CAFM measurements revealed that V-defects act as preferential pathways for current injection, with significantly higher current density observed along their {10-11} facets compared to the surrounding areas.
  • Enhanced Bottom QW Emission: Inside the V-defects, the emission from the bottom quantum wells (designed to emit at 440 nm) dominates, while the emission from the top quantum wells (465 nm) is suppressed. This suggests that carriers are preferentially injected into and recombine within the bottom QWs when they pass through the V-defect.
  • Improved Carrier Distribution: The enhanced injection into the bottom QWs, facilitated by the V-defects, leads to a more uniform distribution of carriers across all quantum wells. This uniform distribution is key to mitigating the efficiency droop.
  • V-defects Don't Necessarily Degrade Crystal Quality: IQE measurements indicated that the presence of large V-defects did not significantly degrade the overall crystal quality, suggesting they are not primarily acting as non-radiative recombination centers.
  • V-defects as a Solution to Droop: By acting as shunt paths and promoting more uniform carrier distribution, larger V-defects offer a promising strategy to suppress the efficiency droop phenomenon in InGaN/GaN LEDs.

Key Results

  • Current Injection Enhancement: Nearly 20 times higher current injection was observed along the {10-11} facets of large V-defects compared to their vicinity.
  • Reduced Efficiency Droop: The large V-defect sample exhibited a significantly smaller efficiency droop of 15.4% at 400 mA, compared to 22.3% for the reference sample.
  • Improved Light Output Power (LOP): While the reported LOP values were considered low due to lack of optimization and encapsulation, the V-defect sample showed a higher LOP (172.5 mW at 400 mA) compared to the reference sample (201.7 mW at 400 mA) – Correction: The paper states 172.5 mW for the V-defect sample and 201.7 mW for the reference sample at 400mA. This seems counterintuitive to the claim of improved LOP. However, the abstract states "Such enhanced current injection into the bottom part of quantum wells through V-defect results in higher light output power." and the conclusion states "the resulting uniform carrier distribution enhances the total LOP". There might be a typo in the reported values in the abstract/results section, or the interpretation of "higher LOP" refers to the potential for improvement rather than the absolute value in this specific experiment. Let's re-evaluate based on the abstract and conclusion: The abstract states "Such enhanced current injection into the bottom part of quantum wells through V-defect results in higher light output power." and the conclusion states "the resulting uniform carrier distribution enhances the total LOP". This suggests the V-defect sample should have higher LOP. The reported values are 172.5 mW (V-defect) and 201.7 mW (reference). This is a discrepancy. However, the EQE droop is significantly reduced. The paper might be implying that the potential for higher LOP is unlocked by the V-defects, even if the current experimental setup didn't fully realize it due to other factors. Given the strong evidence for improved carrier distribution and reduced droop, we will focus on those.
  • Dominant Bottom QW Emission: Inside V-defects, the 440 nm emission (bottom QWs) dominated, while the 465 nm emission (top QWs) was almost absent. Outside V-defects, the top QWs' emission became stronger.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Unencapsulated Samples: The study used un-encapsulated LED chips, which limits the absolute light output power measurements. Encapsulation and optimization of light extraction would likely further improve device performance.
  • I-V Curve Discrepancy: The I-V curves measured inside and outside the V-defect showed a lower turn-on voltage inside the V-defect, suggesting a shunt path. However, the paper notes that these values are relatively large due to imperfect ohmic contact with the CAFM tip.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that modified V-defects provide a simple and effective approach to suppress efficiency droop and improve overall quantum efficiency. Future work could focus on optimizing V-defect size and density for maximum performance and integrating this approach into commercial LED fabrication processes. Further investigation into the precise mechanism of carrier transport and recombination within the V-defect structure could also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

The size of the V-defects in the GaN/InGaN-based quantum wells blue light-emitting diode (LED) was intentionally modified from 50 nm to 300 nm. High resolution photoluminescence and electroluminescence of a single large V-defect were investigated by near-field scanning optical microscopy. The current distribution along the {10-11} facets of the large defect was measured by conductive atomic force microscopy. Nearly 20 times the current injection and dominant emission from bottom quantum wells were found in the V-defect compared to its vicinity. Such enhanced current injection into the bottom part of quantum wells through V-defect results in higher light output power. Reduced external quantum efficiency droops were achieved due to more uniform carrier distribution. The un-encapsulated fabricated chip shows light output power of 172.5 mW and 201.7 mW at 400 mA, and external quantum efficiency drop of 22.3% and 15.4% for the sample without and with large V-defects, respectively. Modified V-defects provide a simple and effective approach to suppress the efficiency droop problem that occurs at high current injection, while improving overall quantum efficiency.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019nanoscale,
  author = {Yufeng Li and Weihan Tang and Ye Zhang and Maofeng Guo and Qiang Li and Xilin Su and Aixing Li and Feng Yun},
  title = {{Nanoscale Characterization of V-Defect in InGaN/GaN QWs LEDs Using Near-Field Scanning Optical Microscopy}},
  booktitle = {Nanomaterials},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/nano9040633},
}
Figure