Abstract
We present the use of Multi-angle Dynamic Light Scattering (MADLS®) for the measurement of nanoparticle concentration. We describe the theory of the method and its application to nanoparticles made of gold, silica and polystyrene, with diameters ranging from 30 to 400 nm, and demonstrate some of the limitations with particles of sizes 500 nm and above. We evaluate the method accuracy, linearity and reproducibility, as well as the operational nanoparticle concentration and size range. We show that the concentration working range depends on the material’s optical properties, size and concentration. Here it is shown that the level of accuracy that can be expected for the concentration of particles is typically within 50% of the nominal value across a range of materials and sizes and, for some samples, within 20%. The repeatability of the measurements, in terms of relative standard deviation, is typically below 30%. A linearity of within 40% across a concentration range of $3 \cdot 10^8$ to $2 \cdot 10^{11}$ mL⁻¹ for concentration measurements was also demonstrated by using gold nanoparticles and gravimetric dilutions for method validation. Overall, we show that MADLS® is a rapid and straightforward method for the reproducible measurement of particle concentration, as well as size, requiring minimal sample preparation, without the need to calibrate using a pre-determined concentration series, and applicable to a broad range of materials.
Introduction: The Challenge of Nanoparticle Counting
Measuring the number concentration of nanoparticles—the exact count of particles per milliliter—is a critical requirement for industrial quality control, environmental safety assessments, and pharmaceutical dosing. Despite its importance, current methodologies often face significant hurdles.
Techniques like UV-Vis spectroscopy are highly material-specific, primarily effective for gold or silver. Single Particle ICP-MS requires complex sample preparation and is limited to specific elemental compositions. Particle Tracking Analysis (PTA) struggles with high concentrations. Most notably, these methods typically require time-consuming calibration curves using standard reference materials, which may not exist for many nanoparticle types. This study validates Multi-angle Dynamic Light Scattering (MADLS®) as a robust, "one-stop-shop" solution that provides absolute concentration and size simultaneously without the need for a pre-determined calibration series.
Methodology
The core innovation of this approach lies in extending standard Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS). While traditional DLS analyzes the temporal fluctuations of scattered light to determine particle size, MADLS records scattering data from three distinct angles: back-scatter, side-scatter, and forward-scatter.
To derive number concentration from scattering intensity, the system integrates three key components:
- Mie Theory: This is used to calculate the theoretical scattering cross-section of a particle based on its size and specific optical properties, namely the refractive index ($n$) and absorption ($k$).
- Reference Calibration: Instrument sensitivity is calibrated using a known molecular scatterer—liquid toluene—which has a well-documented Rayleigh ratio.
- Deconvolution: A non-linear method inverts the multi-angle measurements into a size distribution. This distribution is then transformed into an absolute concentration distribution using the calibrated photon count rates.
Key Insights: Material-Dependent Performance
A significant advantage of MADLS is its calibration-free nature. Once the instrument's sensitivity is established using toluene, it can calculate the concentration of any material, provided its refractive index is known.
Furthermore, the use of multiple angles overcomes a major limitation of single-angle DLS, which can be "blinded" by a few large particles or aggregates because scattering intensity scales with the 6th power of diameter ($d^6$) in the Rayleigh regime. MADLS provides a more robust size distribution, forming a reliable foundation for concentration calculations.
The "working range" of the instrument is not a fixed value but depends heavily on the material's optical properties. For instance, gold nanoparticles, which are strong scatterers, can be measured at significantly lower concentrations than silica particles of the same size.
Experimental Results
The method was evaluated using gold (30 nm, 80 nm), silica (44 nm to 105 nm), and polystyrene (60 nm to 700 nm) nanoparticles. Validation was performed against established reference methods including UV-Vis, Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), and gravimetric analysis.
- Accuracy: Concentration measurements were typically within 50% of nominal values, with some samples achieving accuracy within 20%.
- Linearity: The method demonstrated excellent linearity (within 40%) across a wide concentration range of $3 \cdot 10^8$ to $2 \cdot 10^{11}$ mL⁻¹ for 30 nm gold particles.
- Repeatability and Precision: The relative standard deviation (RSD) for repeated measurements was generally below 30%. Intermediate precision (testing the same stock over 5 days) was approximately 10%, highlighting its suitability for routine quality control.
Limitations and Future Directions
The primary constraint of the current MADLS method is particle size. Accuracy begins to degrade as particles approach and exceed 500 nm. Large particles can cause "multiple scattering"—where a photon interacts with multiple particles before reaching the detector—and increased turbidity. These effects violate the underlying physical models of the measurement.
Additionally, the method requires accurate knowledge of the material's refractive index and absorption. If these values are unknown or if the sample is heavily agglomerated, the concentration will be underestimated. Future research may focus on refining models for non-spherical particles or complex core-shell structures to further expand the utility of MADLS.
Summary updated