Nano-confinement induced nucleation of ice-VII at room temperature

Jonggeun Hwang, Dongha Shin, Brendan T. Deveney, Manhee Lee, Xingcai Zhang, Wonho JhearXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The hydrogen bond (HB) network of water under confinement has been predicted to have distinct structures from that of bulk water. However, direct measurement of the structure has not been achieved. Here, we present experimental evidence of confinement-induced ice formation in water. We directly probe the HB network of a water nano-meniscus formed and confined between a mica substrate and a precisely-controlled-plasmonically active silver tip. By employing tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS), we observe a novel double donor-double acceptor (DDAA) peak that emerges in the OH stretching band of water molecules at room temperature and at sub-nanometer confinement. This Raman peak indicates the presence of a solid phase of water, namely ice-VII with the body-centered cubic (bcc) unit. Interestingly, we observe a structural transition from bcc DDAA (ice-VII) to tetrahedral DDAA as the confinement is weakened. Moreover, by identifying the spatial distribution of the HB network, we find that the bcc DDAA network of ice-VII is predominantly present within the interior of the confined water, rather than at air/water or at solid/water interfaces. This suggests the possibility that the appearance of ice-VII in the strongly confined space could be a general characteristic of water under extreme confinement.

Introduction

Water is often called the "universal solvent," but its fundamental behavior changes dramatically when it is squeezed into spaces only a few molecules wide, such as inside biological cells or geological nanopores. While theoretical models and simulations have long predicted that confined water forms unique hydrogen-bond (HB) networks, directly observing these structures has been an experimental challenge. Conventional methods like Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) can measure the mechanical stiffness of confined water but lack the molecular specificity to determine structural arrangements. Conversely, standard Raman spectroscopy lacks the sensitivity to probe the minute volume of a single nano-meniscus. This study bridges this gap, providing the first direct experimental evidence of how sub-nanometer confinement dictates the molecular architecture of water.

Methods

The researchers developed a sophisticated hybrid platform combining AFM-based Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy (TERS) to probe the water nano-meniscus with sub-nanometer precision.

Schematic of the AFM-TERS setup (a) and the water nano-meniscus geometry (b) formed between the silver tip and mica substrate.

A water nano-meniscus was formed between a flat mica substrate and a sharp silver tip. The silver tip serves as a "plasmonic antenna," focusing light into a "hotspot" that enhances the Raman signal by a factor of over $10^5$. To control the gap distance ($d$) with sub-nanometer precision, a quartz tuning-fork (QTF) was employed as a force sensor. This allowed the team to simultaneously measure mechanical properties (like damping and stiffness) and molecular vibrations. The structural fingerprinting focused on the OH stretching band, specifically looking for the "double donor-double acceptor" (DDAA) peak, which serves as a signature for different ice phases.

Key Results and Insights

In the "strong-confinement" regime ($d < 2$ nm), a new Raman peak emerged at 3316 cm⁻¹. This peak does not exist in bulk water but closely matches the signature of ice-VII, which has a body-centered cubic (bcc) structure.

Experimental data showing (a) Raman spectra evolution with gap distance, (b) mechanical response, and (e) the phase diagram comparing nanoconfined water to bulk ice phases.

A primary insight of this work is that physical confinement acts as a proxy for pressure. In bulk water, ice-VII typically forms only at pressures above 2.02 GPa. However, the authors found that under extreme confinement, it nucleates at just 0.19 GPa—a reduction by a factor of ten. This suggests that the reduction in entropy caused by the narrow walls facilitates the phase transition. Mechanical validation supported this; as the ice-VII peak emerged, the mechanical relaxation time ($\tau_r$) increased significantly, confirming that the water was behaving like a solid.

Through spatial distribution analysis, the researchers discovered that ice-VII forms primarily in the interior of the confined water, while the interfaces (air/water and solid/water) maintain different, less-ordered hydrogen-bond networks. They also observed a clear structural transition: as the gap widens, the water shifts from the bcc DDAA structure (ice-VII) to a tetrahedral DDAA structure (resembling supercooled water) over a narrow window of approximately 1 nm.

Limitations and Future Work

The study notes that wall characteristics like wettability likely play a significant role; for instance, hydrophobic walls might induce even stronger confinement effects. Additionally, the experiments had to account for atmospheric carbon contaminants that appear in the same spectral region, requiring careful subtraction. This work opens the door to studying how "nano-ice" affects friction in nanomachines or molecular transport in biological channels. Exploring different substrate materials will be essential to determine if this room-temperature ice-VII is a universal feature of nanoconfined water.

Summary updated

Abstract

The hydrogen bond (HB) network of water under confinement has been predicted to have distinct structures from that of bulk water. However, direct measurement of the structure has not been achieved. Here, we present experimental evidence of confinement-induced ice formation in water. We directly probe the HB network of a water nano-meniscus formed and confined between a mica substrate and a precisely-controlled-plasmonically active silver tip. By employing tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS), we observe a novel double donor-double acceptor (DDAA) peak that emerges in the OH stretching band of water molecules at room temperature and at sub-nanometer confinement. This Raman peak indicates the presence of a solid phase of water, namely ice-VII with the body-centered cubic (bcc) unit. Interestingly, we observe a structural transition from bcc DDAA (ice-VII) to tetrahedral DDAA as the confinement is weakened. Moreover, by identifying the spatial distribution of the HB network, we find that the bcc DDAA network of ice-VII is predominantly present within the interior of the confined water, rather than at air/water or at solid/water interfaces. This suggest the possibility that the appearance of ice-VII in the strongly confined space could be a general characteristic of water under extreme confinement.
BibTeX
@misc{hwang2024nano,
  author = {Jonggeun Hwang and Dongha Shin and Brendan T. Deveney and Manhee Lee and Xingcai Zhang and Wonho Jhe},
  title = {{Nano-confinement induced nucleation of ice-VII at room temperature}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2411.12975},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.12975},
}

Loading related content...

Figure