Myonuclear content regulates cell size with similar scaling properties in mice and humans

Kenth‐Arne Hansson, Einar Eftestøl, Jo C. Bruusgaard, Inga Solgård Juvkam, A. Cramer, Anders Malthe‐Sørenssen, Douglas P. Millay, Kristian GundersenNature Communications 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Muscle fibers are the largest cells in the body and exist as syncytia, containing hundreds to thousands of nuclei. While individual cell sizes are highly adaptable, the principles governing their size have remained elusive. This study demonstrates that muscle fibers are inherently DNA-scarce compared to other cell types. By analyzing the relationship between nuclear number ($N$) and cytoplasmic volume ($V$), researchers found that $N$ scales sublinearly to $V$ ($N = aV^b$, where $b < 1$). This scaling law is remarkably consistent across species (mice and humans) and developmental stages, suggesting that DNA content acts as a fundamental limiter of muscle cell size.

Introduction: The Syncytial Giant

Unlike most cells, muscle fibers are biological giants. As syncytia, they house a multitude of nuclei within a single membrane. For decades, the "myonuclear domain theory" posited that each nucleus manages a fixed volume of cytoplasm, implying a linear relationship where doubling the cell size requires doubling the number of nuclei. However, muscle size is incredibly plastic, growing with exercise and shrinking with disuse. This study sought to determine if a more complex mathematical scaling law governs this relationship and defines the limits of muscular hypertrophy.

Methodology: Mapping the 3D Architecture

To move beyond traditional 2D cross-sections, the researchers employed high-resolution 3D confocal reconstruction. By using in vivo fluorescent labeling, they created precise models of individual muscle fiber segments from both mice (EDL muscle) and humans (vastus lateralis).

3D confocal reconstruction of muscle fibers showing individual myonuclei (blue spheres) distributed along the fiber.

This 3D approach allowed for accurate measurements of volume and surface area, which were then analyzed using power-law equations to identify the scaling exponent ($b$). A value of $b=1$ would indicate a constant domain size, while $b < 1$ indicates sublinear scaling, where larger cells become increasingly DNA-scarce.

The Universal Law of DNA Scarcity

The most significant finding is that muscle fibers follow a sublinear scaling law. As a fiber grows, it does not add nuclei at a proportional rate. Instead, each nucleus is forced to "oversee" a progressively larger volume of cytoplasm.

Log-log plot showing the sublinear scaling relationship between nuclear number and cell volume in mice, with an exponent of b=0.73.

In mice, the scaling exponent for volume was found to be $b = 0.73$, while in humans, it was $b = 0.66$. Despite the vast difference in absolute size between mouse and human fibers, the exponents are nearly identical. This suggests a fundamental biological constraint shared across mammals. Interestingly, while the relationship with volume is sublinear, the relationship between nuclear number and cell surface area is nearly linear ($b \approx 1$). This implies that nuclei are added primarily to support the demands of the cell membrane—such as transport and signaling—rather than the 3D bulk of the cytoplasm.

Biological Implications and "Muscle Memory"

The study also explored conditions where this law is challenged:

  • Growth Failure: In "myomaker" knockout mice ($\Delta 2w$), which cannot add new nuclei, cells grew normally at first by stretching existing domains. However, once they reached a critical "ceiling" of DNA scarcity in adulthood, growth ceased entirely.
  • Muscle Memory: In cases of denervation-atrophy, volume drops but nuclei are preserved. This break in the scaling law provides a structural basis for muscle memory, allowing previously trained muscles to regrow faster because the necessary DNA infrastructure remains in place.

Conclusion

The consistency of these scaling exponents across species and experimental conditions suggests an underlying biological law: DNA content functions as a primary limiter of muscle cell size. Larger fibers are not just bigger; they are fundamentally different in their nuclear density, operating at the edge of DNA scarcity to maintain their massive dimensions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Muscle fibers are the largest cells in the body, and one of its few syncytia. Individual cell sizes are variable and adaptable, but what governs cell size has been unclear. We find that muscle fibers are DNA scarce compared to other cells, and that the nuclear number (N) adheres to the relationship N = aV<sup>b</sup> where V is the cytoplasmic volume. N invariably scales sublinearly to V (b < 1), making larger cells even more DNA scarce. N scales linearly to cell surface in adult humans, in adult and developing mice, and in mice with genetically reduced N, but in the latter the relationship eventually fails when they reach adulthood with extremely large myonuclear domains. Another exception is denervation-atrophy where nuclei are not eliminated. In conclusion, scaling exponents are remarkably similar across species, developmental stages and experimental conditions, suggesting an underlying scaling law where DNA-content functions as a limiter of muscle cell size.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hansson2020myonuclear,
  author = {Kenth‐Arne Hansson and Einar Eftestøl and Jo C. Bruusgaard and Inga Solgård Juvkam and A. Cramer and Anders Malthe‐Sørenssen and Douglas P. Millay and Kristian Gundersen},
  title = {{Myonuclear content regulates cell size with similar scaling properties in mice and humans}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-20057-8},
}
Figure