MycoKey Round Table Discussions of Future Directions in Research on Chemical Detection Methods, Genetics and Biodiversity of Mycotoxins

John F. Leslie, Veronica M. T. Lattanzio, Kris Audenaert, Paola Battilani, Jeffrey W. Cary, S. Chulze, Sarah De Saeger, Annamaria Gerardino, Petr Karlovský, Yu-Cai Liao, Chris M. Maragos, Giuseppe Meca, Ángel Medina, Antonio Moretti, Gary P. Munkvold, Giuseppina Mulè, Patrick Berka Njobeh, Ivan Pecorelli, Giancarlo Perrone, Amedeo Pietri, Juan Manuel Palazzini, Robert H. Proctor, Endang Sutriswati Rahayu, María Laura Ramirez, Robert A. Samson, Jörg Stroka, Michael Sulyok, Mark W. Sumarah, Cees Waalwijk, Qi Zhang, Hao Zhang, Antonio LogriecoToxins 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper summarizes the outcomes of expert "Roundtable Discussions" aimed at charting the future of mycotoxin research, focusing on chemical detection and the genetics/biodiversity of mycotoxin production. The discussions highlight the need for improved, standardized multi-mycotoxin detection methods and a deeper understanding of fungal genetics and microbial communities to develop effective control and remediation strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mycotoxins, toxic secondary metabolites produced by fungi, pose significant risks to human and animal health, as well as substantial economic losses in the food and feed industries. Effectively managing these risks requires continuous advancement in detecting and understanding the biological factors that drive mycotoxin production. However, the field of mycotoxicology is complex and interdisciplinary, making it challenging to identify and prioritize future research directions. This paper addresses this challenge by synthesizing the collective expertise of leading researchers to map out the most promising avenues for future research in chemical detection and the genetic/biodiversity aspects of mycotoxin production.

Methods

The core methodology employed in this study was the Nominal Group Technique (NGT). This structured discussion technique was used to facilitate "Roundtable Discussions" among experts. The NGT involves several stages: silent idea generation, sharing and recording of ideas, idea explanation and clarification, and finally, voting and ranking of the generated ideas. This process ensures equal input from all participants and systematically identifies and prioritizes key research areas. Two roundtables were conducted: one on Chemical Detection and Monitoring (CDM) and another on Genetics and Biodiversity (GB). Each roundtable addressed four discipline-specific questions, and both groups also answered two common questions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper focuses on expert opinion and consensus-building rather than empirical data analysis or the introduction of new datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Antibody-based diagnostics are a current standard but need improvement: While widely accepted for their speed and ease of use, there's a strong call for enhancing their specificity, reliability, and quantitative capabilities, especially for broader applications.
  • The future of detection lies in sophisticated multi-mycotoxin protocols: As regulatory lists expand, highly sophisticated multi-mycotoxin detection methods are crucial. These require significant standardization and inter-laboratory validation to ensure reliability across different settings.
  • Microbiome research is key but currently descriptive: Understanding the role of microbiomes in mycotoxin production and impact is a major trend, but current research is largely descriptive, highlighting a need for more mechanistic studies.
  • Genetics and biodiversity offer diverse control strategies: Knowledge of fungal gene regulation and biodiversity can be leveraged for mycotoxin reduction and remediation, with approaches ranging from biocontrol agents to genetic manipulation.
  • Communication is paramount: Effectively communicating the risks associated with mycotoxins to the public and stakeholders is recognized as an essential step to gain support for research and implement effective food safety measures.

Key Results

The discussions generated a comprehensive list of prioritized research needs and future directions.

For Chemical Detection and Monitoring: * Top priorities include: Improved extraction methods (especially using non-organic solvents), development of new lateral-flow devices and antibody replacements, and enhanced general kit improvements (specificity, reliability, quantitative detection). * Significant focus on multi-mycotoxin detection: This area received the highest priority score, emphasizing the need for improved sensitivity, robustness, and standardization of Mass Spectrometry (MS) techniques, along with the development of reliable databases for emerging mycotoxins. * Developing countries require specific solutions: Methods need to be simple, validated, inexpensive, ready-to-use, and require minimal infrastructure (e.g., solar power, water-based solvents). On-site support and training are critical. * Official control requires robust QC: Emphasis on certified reference materials, inter-laboratory ring trials, measurement uncertainty protocols, and standardized sampling protocols.

For Genetics and Biodiversity: * Understanding regulators: Identifying regulators not directly encoded in biosynthetic pathways is crucial, with comparative studies under various stress conditions being a leading approach. * Microbiome impact: Research needs to move beyond descriptive studies to understand the impact of microbiomes on mycotoxin production and health, with a focus on intentional experimental manipulation. * Plant-fungal interactions: Transcriptomic studies of plant-fungal interactions, particularly focusing on plant defense mechanisms and gene regulation, are highlighted as important. * Application of knowledge: Implementing biocontrol practices, utilizing RNAi in GMO host plants, and identifying microbes/enzymes for mycotoxin degradation are key strategies for reduction and remediation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Descriptive nature of some research: For areas like microbiome studies, current research questions are primarily descriptive, indicating a need for more mechanistic and experimental approaches.
  • Complexity of interactions: Understanding the intricate interactions between fungi, plants, and their environment requires multiple analytical approaches and experimental designs.
  • Communication gap: A significant challenge identified is communicating the complex risks of mycotoxins to the general public without causing undue alarm. Future work needs to focus on developing effective communication strategies and forging partnerships with communication experts.
  • Remediation in developing countries: Developing inexpensive and technically simple remediation methods is a critical challenge, especially in regions where food security necessitates the use of contaminated foodstuffs.
  • Future research directions: The paper explicitly points to the need for continued research in areas such as metabolomics, microbiome manipulation, advanced detection technologies, and effective communication strategies to enhance food safety and security. The MycoKey project itself is a step towards addressing these future needs.

Summary updated

Abstract

MycoKey, an EU-funded Horizon 2020 project, includes a series of "Roundtable Discussions" to gather information on trending research areas in the field of mycotoxicology. This paper includes summaries of the Roundtable Discussions on Chemical Detection and Monitoring of mycotoxins and on the role of genetics and biodiversity in mycotoxin production. Discussions were managed by using the nominal group discussion technique, which generates numerous ideas and provides a ranking for those identified as the most important. Four questions were posed for each research area, as well as two questions that were common to both discussions. Test kits, usually antibody based, were one major focus of the discussions at the Chemical Detection and Monitoring roundtable because of their many favorable features, e.g., cost, speed and ease of use. The second area of focus for this roundtable was multi-mycotoxin detection protocols and the challenges still to be met to enable these protocols to become methods of choice for regulated mycotoxins. For the genetic and biodiversity group, both the depth and the breadth of trending research areas were notable. For some areas, e.g., microbiome studies, the suggested research questions were primarily of a descriptive nature. In other areas, multiple experimental approaches, e.g., transcriptomics, proteomics, RNAi and gene deletions, are needed to understand the regulation of toxin production and mechanisms underlying successful biological controls. Answers to the research questions will provide starting points for developing acceptable prevention and remediation processes. Forging a partnership between scientists and appropriately-placed communications experts was recognized by both groups as an essential step to communicating risks, while retaining overall confidence in the safety of the food supply and the integrity of the food production chain.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{leslie2018mycokey,
  author = {John F. Leslie and Veronica M. T. Lattanzio and Kris Audenaert and Paola Battilani and Jeffrey W. Cary and S. Chulze and Sarah De Saeger and Annamaria Gerardino and Petr Karlovský and Yu-Cai Liao and Chris M. Maragos and Giuseppe Meca and Ángel Medina and Antonio Moretti and Gary P. Munkvold and Giuseppina Mulè and Patrick Berka Njobeh and Ivan Pecorelli and Giancarlo Perrone and Amedeo Pietri and Juan Manuel Palazzini and Robert H. Proctor and Endang Sutriswati Rahayu and María Laura Ramirez and Robert A. Samson and Jörg Stroka and Michael Sulyok and Mark W. Sumarah and Cees Waalwijk and Qi Zhang and Hao Zhang and Antonio Logrieco},
  title = {{MycoKey Round Table Discussions of Future Directions in Research on Chemical Detection Methods, Genetics and Biodiversity of Mycotoxins}},
  booktitle = {Toxins},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/toxins10030109},
}
Figure