TL;DR
This study reveals that changes in cannabis use predict changes in binge drinking frequency during emerging adulthood, with this relationship varying by age. Specifically, increased cannabis use in younger emerging adults (18-21) predicts future increases in binge drinking, while in older emerging adults (24-25), it predicts future decreases. This suggests that interventions targeting both substances concurrently, especially in early emerging adulthood, could be more effective.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Emerging adulthood (ages 18-25) is a critical period characterized by high rates of binge drinking and increasing cannabis use. While previous research has shown correlations between these two behaviors, much of it has been cross-sectional or focused on general alcohol use rather than binge drinking. A key gap in understanding is how within-person changes in cannabis use influence subsequent changes in binge drinking, and vice versa, over time and how these dynamics might differ across this developmental stage. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining the reciprocal, age-varying influences of binge drinking and cannabis use frequency during emerging adulthood.
Methods
The researchers employed a parallel-process state-trait mixed effect growth model. This advanced statistical technique allows for the simultaneous modeling of two longitudinal processes (binge drinking frequency and cannabis use frequency) and disentangles:
- Between-person variability: Stable, trait-like differences between individuals in their average levels and growth rates of substance use.
- Within-person variability: Dynamic, day-to-day or year-to-year fluctuations in substance use within an individual.
Specifically, the model examined:
- Correlations between intercepts: Whether individuals with higher average binge drinking also had higher average cannabis use.
- Correlations between slopes: Whether individuals who increased their binge drinking more rapidly also increased their cannabis use more rapidly.
- Reciprocal prospective effects: Whether within-person changes in one substance predicted subsequent within-person changes in the other substance one year later.
- Age as a moderator: How the prospective relationships between binge drinking and cannabis use varied across different ages within the emerging adulthood period.
This approach is novel in its ability to capture both stable individual differences and dynamic, age-specific within-person processes in the context of substance use trajectories.
Datasets
The study utilized data from the National Consortium on Alcohol and Neurodevelopment in Adolescence (NCANDA) cohort. This is a longitudinal study that collected annual data from participants over 9 years, starting from ages 12-21. For this specific study, data from ages 18-25 were used, with a subsample of 526 participants who reported using both alcohol and cannabis at least once during this period. The data included annual assessments of past-year binge drinking frequency and past-year cannabis use frequency.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Complementarity, not just correlation: The findings suggest that binge drinking and cannabis use are not just correlated but often complementary, especially at the within-person level. When one substance's use fluctuates, the other tends to follow suit.
- Age matters significantly: The influence of cannabis use on binge drinking is not static. It shifts from being a predictor of increased binge drinking in younger emerging adults to a predictor of decreased binge drinking in older emerging adults. This highlights the need for age-tailored interventions.
- Timing is crucial for intervention: The predictive power of cannabis use on binge drinking is strongest in the earlier years of emerging adulthood (18-21). This suggests that early intervention targeting both substances concurrently might be most impactful.
- Within-person dynamics are key: While between-person correlations are important, the within-person analyses reveal more nuanced, dynamic relationships that are critical for understanding how substance use patterns evolve and how interventions might work.
Key Results
- Between-person: Higher average binge drinking frequency was correlated with higher average cannabis use frequency. Similarly, steeper growth in binge drinking frequency was correlated with steeper growth in cannabis use frequency across emerging adulthood.
- Within-person (contemporaneous): Fluctuations in binge drinking frequency were associated with concurrent fluctuations in cannabis use frequency at the same age.
- Within-person (prospective):
- Increases in cannabis use frequency predicted subsequent increases in binge drinking frequency from ages 18 to 21.
- Increases in cannabis use frequency predicted subsequent decreases in binge drinking frequency at ages 24-25.
- Changes in binge drinking frequency did not predict subsequent changes in cannabis use frequency.
- Covariates: Male sex was associated with higher baseline levels of both binge drinking and cannabis use. Other covariates like SES and study site were not significant predictors.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Focus on Binge Drinking: The study focused on binge drinking frequency as the alcohol outcome. Future research could explore relationships with other indices of heavier cannabis use (e.g., potency).
- Co-use Overlap: The study did not explicitly examine simultaneous or alternating co-use patterns, which could provide further insight.
- Limited Post-Emerging Adulthood Data: The study did not extend beyond age 25, missing potential long-term trajectories into adulthood.
- Frequency of Assessment: Annual assessments might miss more dynamic, shorter-term changes (e.g., monthly or quarterly).
- Contextual Factors: The role of specific contextual factors like collegiate status was not examined, despite its relevance during emerging adulthood.
Future research should incorporate broader age ranges, more frequent assessments, and investigate the impact of specific contextual factors like college life. Additionally, exploring the mechanisms behind the age-varying prospective effects of cannabis on binge drinking is warranted.
Summary updated