TL;DR
This study maps the "mutational fitness landscape" of the influenza H3N2 neuraminidase (NA) protein using deep mutational scanning. The findings reveal that while some regions are highly tolerant to mutations, others are surprisingly intolerant, and protein stability is a key factor influencing mutation tolerance. This work provides crucial insights for designing more effective NA-based vaccines.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Influenza neuraminidase (NA) is an increasingly important target for vaccines, offering potential for broader protection against different influenza strains. However, our understanding of how NA evolves and its tolerance to mutations has been limited. This lack of knowledge hinders the development of vaccines that can effectively target NA and overcome viral escape mechanisms. The paper aims to address this gap by comprehensively characterizing the mutational landscape of H3N2 NA, identifying regions that are critical for its function and stability, and understanding how these factors influence its evolutionary trajectory.
Methods
The core technique employed is deep mutational scanning (DMS). This involves creating a library of influenza H3N2 NA variants, each with a single amino acid substitution at nearly every position in the head domain. These variants are then subjected to selection (in this case, viral replication in cells), and their relative fitness is measured using next-generation sequencing. By analyzing the abundance of each mutant before and after selection, researchers can quantify the "fitness effect" of each mutation – essentially, how well that specific change allows the virus to replicate.
To further understand the biophysical constraints, the researchers used FoldX, a computational tool, to predict the change in protein stability (ΔΔG) for each mutation. They also employed MSA transformer, a protein language model, to infer mutational fitness from naturally occurring influenza sequences, allowing for a comparison between experimental and evolutionary data. Structural analysis using X-ray crystallography provided a detailed view of the NA protein.
Datasets
The study utilized a large dataset of over 6,000 single amino acid mutations in the H3N2 NA head domain generated through deep mutational scanning. For comparison with natural evolution, they analyzed 66,562 full-length human H3N2 NA sequences collected between 1968 and 2020, sourced from the GISAID database.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Antigenic regions are surprisingly tolerant: Contrary to what might be expected, regions targeted by antibodies (antigenic regions) show high mutational tolerance. This suggests that the virus can readily evolve to evade antibody responses in these areas.
- Hidden intolerant regions: The study identified specific solvent-exposed regions with low mutational tolerance. These regions are likely critical for protein structure and function, making them less amenable to change and thus potentially better targets for broadly protective vaccines.
- Protein stability is paramount: The research strongly indicates that protein stability is a major determinant of NA's mutational fitness. Mutations that destabilize the protein significantly reduce viral fitness, highlighting the importance of maintaining structural integrity.
- In vitro DMS correlates with in vivo evolution: A key finding is the strong correlation between the fitness measured in the laboratory (in vitro DMS) and the fitness inferred from naturally circulating viruses (in vivo evolution). This validates the use of DMS as a powerful tool for predicting evolutionary trajectories.
- NA is far from evolutionary saturation: Despite over 50 years of evolution in humans, the study suggests that H3N2 NA still has a significant unexplored mutational space, meaning it has not yet "run out" of ways to evolve.
Key Results
- The study measured the fitness effects of over 6,000 single amino acid mutations in the H3N2 NA head domain.
- Antigenic regions and solvent-exposed regions showed significantly higher mutational tolerance compared to buried or interface residues.
- A cluster of five solvent-exposed residues at the membrane-proximal side of the NA head domain exhibited low mutational tolerance, suggesting their critical role in protein stability.
- A Spearman's rank correlation of -0.61 was observed between predicted protein stability (ΔΔG) and mutational fitness, confirming stability as a major determinant.
- The correlation between DMS results and fitness inferred from natural sequences was 0.59 (Spearman's rank correlation), increasing to 0.69 when considering only naturally observed mutations.
- Out of the 4,963 mutations not observed in nature, 251 showed a fitness greater than 0, indicating potential for future evolution.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that their DMS experiment used a chimeric influenza virus (internal segments from H1N1, HA from H3N2) and that the functional interaction between HA and NA could influence the results. They suggest that future studies should ideally use the same strain for both HA and NA to fully capture these interactions.
The study's findings on low-tolerance regions, particularly the cluster at the membrane-proximal side, are highlighted as promising targets for broadly protective NA-based vaccine design. Future work could focus on developing immunogens that elicit antibodies against these conserved, intolerant regions, which would present a higher genetic barrier for viral escape. The dataset generated also provides a valuable resource for further investigations into NA evolution and vaccine development.
Summary updated