Mutation rates and adaptive variation among the clinically dominant clusters of Mycobacterium abscessus

Terrance Shea, Mark R. Sullivan, Kerry McGowen, Evan Koch, Eric J. Rubin, Maha FarhatResearch Square 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study challenges the prevailing view that patient-to-patient transmission is the primary driver of Mycobacterium abscessus (Mab) clustering. Instead, it presents compelling evidence that a slower mutation rate, linked to adaptations in DNA repair genes during host adaptation, is the key factor driving the observed phylogenetic clustering. This finding has significant implications for understanding the evolution and spread of this important pathogen.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mycobacterium abscessus (Mab) is a challenging, multi-drug resistant bacterium causing severe pulmonary infections, particularly in individuals with underlying lung conditions like cystic fibrosis. Recent genomic analyses have revealed dense genetic clustering of clinical Mab isolates from diverse geographic locations. This clustering has often been interpreted as evidence of widespread patient-to-patient transmission. However, epidemiological studies have largely failed to support this hypothesis, creating a significant disconnect between genomic observations and epidemiological realities. This paper aims to reconcile this discrepancy by investigating alternative explanations for Mab's phylogenetic structure, specifically focusing on evolutionary rates and adaptive variation.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Whole Genome Sequencing (WGS) Analysis: They analyzed a large dataset of publicly available WGS data from M. abscessus isolates.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: They constructed phylogenetic trees to visualize the evolutionary relationships between isolates, using maximum likelihood (ML) methods and focusing on core genomes.
  • Molecular Clock Analysis: They used coalescent analysis (BEAST) to estimate molecular clock rates, inferring evolutionary rates over time. This involved pruning trees to better capture temporal signals.
  • Simulation Studies: They conducted coalescent simulations to test hypotheses about population size and mutation rate changes as drivers of clustering.
  • Variant Enrichment Analysis: They identified genetic variants (SNPs) that were significantly enriched in dominant clusters (DCs) compared to other parts of the phylogeny, looking for evidence of positive selection.
  • Fluctuation Assays: They experimentally measured spontaneous mutation rates in vitro for different strains to directly assess the link between genetic variation and mutation rate.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available whole genome sequencing (WGS) data for Mycobacterium abscessus isolates. The dataset comprised 1,629 isolates with associated collection dates, originating from nine countries and collected between 1998 and 2017. Additional data was downloaded from the NCBI Sequence Read Archive (SRA).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mutation Rate as a Driver of Clustering: The most striking insight is the shift in focus from transmission to mutation rate. The study strongly suggests that a slower mutation rate in clustered isolates, rather than rapid spread, is responsible for their genetic similarity.
  • Host Adaptation and DNA Repair: The research links this slower mutation rate to genetic changes in DNA repair machinery (specifically UvrD/Rep family helicases). This implies that adaptation to the human host environment might involve altering DNA repair mechanisms, which in turn affects the organism's overall mutation rate.
  • Challenging Transmission Models: The findings directly challenge the dominant paradigm that dense phylogenetic clustering in Mab is primarily driven by person-to-person transmission. This necessitates a re-evaluation of how we understand the spread and evolution of this pathogen.
  • Niche Switching and Facultative Pathogens: The study offers a new perspective on niche switching in facultative pathogens, suggesting that adaptive changes in mutation rate can be a key mechanism for adapting to new environments, such as the human host.

Key Results

  • Slower Molecular Clock in Clusters: Molecular clock rate estimates revealed a significantly slower evolutionary rate within dominant clusters (DCs) compared to the long internal branches of the phylogeny.
  • Enrichment of DNA Repair Genes: Genes involved in DNA repair, particularly UvrD/Rep family helicases, were found to be significantly enriched in clustered isolates.
  • Lower Spontaneous Mutation Rates: Isolates from dominant clusters exhibited lower spontaneous mutation rates in vitro compared to non-clustered isolates. This effect was consistent across M. a. abscessus and M. a. massiliense.
  • Simulation Support: Coalescent simulations demonstrated that a 10- to 20-fold decrease in mutation rate could recapitulate the observed phylogenetic clustering, whereas large population size differences (suggesting transmission) were less effective in explaining the data.
  • Temporal Signal in Pruned Trees: While the full subspecies trees lacked clear temporal signal, pruning them to preserve diversity revealed evidence of temporal signal, supporting the molecular clock analyses.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Distinguishing Mutation Rate vs. Generation Time: The study acknowledges that it's difficult to definitively distinguish between changes in spontaneous mutation rate and changes in generation time as drivers of the slower evolutionary rate. Differences in growth conditions across environments (natural vs. human host) could influence generation time.
  • Causality of Variants: While variants in DNA repair genes are associated with clustering and lower mutation rates, establishing direct causality for all observed clustering remains challenging. Hitchhiking with other adaptive variants could also play a role.
  • Recombination Effects: While efforts were made to account for recombination, the authors note that unpurged recombination events could potentially affect clock rate estimates.
  • Geographic Distribution: The study's findings do not fully explain the geographic distribution of Mab within clusters, suggesting that factors beyond mutation rate might be involved.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest future work should focus on:
  • Investigating environmental isolates to understand the origins of Mab and its adaptation.
  • Comparing genotypes and mutation rates in environmental versus clinical samples.
  • Further examining differences in mutation rates and phenotypes between clinical and environmental strains to understand host adaptation.
  • Continuing genomic surveillance to track Mab's adaptation to human infection and transmission risks.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Mycobacterium abscessus (Mab) is a multi-drug resistant pathogen increasingly responsible for severe pulmonary infections. Analysis of whole genome sequences (WGS) of Mab demonstrates dense genetic clustering of clinical isolates collected from¬ disparate geographic locations. This has been interpreted as supporting patient-to-patient transmission, but epidemiological studies have contradicted this interpretation. Here we present evidence for a slowing of the Mab molecular clock rate coincident with the emergence of phylogenetic clusters. We find that clustered isolates are enriched in mutations affecting DNA repair machinery and have lower spontaneous mutation rates in vitro. We propose that Mab adaptation to the host environment through variation in DNA repair genes affects the organism’s mutation rate and that this manifests as phylogenetic clustering. These results inform our understanding of niche switching for facultative pathogens, and challenge the model of transmission as the major mode of dissemination of clinically dominant Mab clusters.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shea2022mutation,
  author = {Terrance Shea and Mark R. Sullivan and Kerry McGowen and Evan Koch and Eric J. Rubin and Maha Farhat},
  title = {{Mutation rates and adaptive variation among the clinically dominant clusters of Mycobacterium abscessus}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-1620528/v1},
}
Figure