Musical Imagery Involves the Wernicke’s Area in Bilateral and Anti-Correlated Network Interactions in Musicians

Yizhen Zhang, Gang Chen, Haiguang Wen, Kun‐Han Lu, Zhongming LiubioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that imagining music (musical imagery) engages Wernicke's area in a complex, bilateral network, distinct from how it processes perceived music. This challenges the traditional view of music and language processing being strictly segregated and lateralized, suggesting Wernicke's area plays a crucial role in the rich, internal experience of music for musicians.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While we know that imagining music without hearing it (musical imagery) is a real phenomenon, especially for trained musicians, the underlying neural mechanisms are not well understood. Previous research has primarily focused on visual and motor imagery, leaving auditory imagery, particularly complex musical imagery, less explored. A key question is whether musical imagery and actual music perception share similar neural pathways or if they involve distinct processes. Furthermore, the traditional understanding of brain function often separates music processing from language processing, with Wernicke's area typically associated with language. This paper aims to clarify the neural basis of musical imagery, specifically investigating how Wernicke's area is involved and whether it challenges existing models of music and language lateralization.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel method to induce and study sustained musical imagery using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Instead of relying on simple, short auditory tasks, they presented participants with a visualized version of an 8-minute symphony. This "music visualization" acted as a real-time cue, guiding musicians to continuously imagine the music. This allowed for:

  • Sustained and Complex Imagery: Unlike previous studies using short, simple tasks, this approach enabled the study of prolonged, intricate musical imagery.
  • Intra-subject Reproducibility: By repeating the imagery task multiple times within the same fMRI session, the researchers could assess the reliability of brain activity, ensuring the observed patterns were task-specific and not random.
  • Comparison with Perception: The same musical piece was also presented auditorily for direct perception, allowing for a direct comparison of brain activity between imagining and hearing music.
  • Network Analysis: Beyond just identifying activated areas, the study employed seed-based functional connectivity analysis to map how different brain regions interacted during both imagery and perception. This included comparing task-evoked networks with intrinsic functional networks observed during resting-state fMRI.
  • Auditory Feature Analysis: They specifically examined how the brain encoded musical features, like spectral flux (changes in sound over time), during imagery and perception.

Datasets

The study utilized data from three healthy volunteers who all had extensive musical training. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; instead, the researchers collected novel fMRI data using their specifically designed musical imagery paradigm.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wernicke's Area: More Than Just Language: The study found that Wernicke's area, typically linked to language, is actively involved in musical imagery, not just music perception. This suggests a more integrated role for this region in auditory processing, extending beyond spoken language.
  • Distinct Network Interactions: While both musical imagery and perception activate similar core areas (like secondary auditory cortex and Wernicke's), the way these areas interact differs significantly. Musical imagery involves a broader, more complex network, including attention and default mode networks, whereas perception is more confined to the auditory system.
  • Anti-correlated Networks: A key finding is the involvement of anti-correlated networks during musical imagery. Wernicke's area showed positive correlations with auditory and attention networks but negative correlations with the default mode network, suggesting a dynamic interplay of brain states during internal music generation.
  • Challenging Lateralization: The observed bilateral activation and network engagement for both musical imagery and perception contradict the older view of music processing being primarily right-hemisphere dominant. This suggests that extensive musical training can lead to a breakdown of strict lateralization, promoting more bilateral processing.
  • Visual Cues for Internal Experience: The use of music visualization as a cue was effective in guiding sustained musical imagery, demonstrating a novel way to study internal cognitive states with controlled timing.

Key Results

  • Widespread Activation: Sustained musical imagery evoked widespread cortical activation, including visual areas (due to the visual cues), attention networks, secondary auditory cortex, and Wernicke's areas.
  • Shared Substrates: Both musical imagery and perception activated common cortical areas, notably the bilateral Wernicke's areas and secondary auditory cortex.
  • Spectral Flux Encoding: Wernicke's areas were consistently correlated with the spectral flux of the music, both when imagined and perceived, indicating their role in encoding dynamic musical features.
  • Distinct Networks: Task-evoked functional connectivity patterns were highly distinct between musical imagery and perception. Musical imagery recruited broader networks (attention, default mode) compared to the more unimodal auditory network for perception.
  • Primary Auditory Cortex Difference: The primary auditory cortex showed responses correlated with spectral flux during perception but not during imagery, suggesting it primarily encodes external auditory input.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Sample Size: The study involved only three participants. While their consistency across tasks is noted, a larger sample size would increase the generalizability of the findings.
  • Musician-Specific Findings: The unique involvement of Wernicke's area in musical imagery might be specific to musicians due to their extensive training. Further research could explore this in non-musicians.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this visually-cued imagery paradigm could be valuable for studying neural coding and developing brain decoding models for imagery, potentially extending to more complex cognitive processes like dreams. They also highlight the ongoing debate regarding the role of the primary auditory cortex in musical imagery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Musical imagery is a human experience of imagining music without actually hearing it. The neural basis of such a mental ability is unclear, especially for musicians capable of accurate and vivid musical imagery due to their musical training. Here, we visualized an 8-min symphony as a silent movie, and used it as real-time cues for musicians to continuously imagine the music for multiple synchronized sessions during functional magnetic resonance imaging. The activations and networks evoked by musical imagery were compared with those when the subjects directly listened to the same music. The musical imagery and perception shared similar responses at bilateral secondary auditory areas and Wernicke’s area for encoding the musical feature. But the Wernicke’s area was involved in highly distinct network interactions during musical imagery vs. perception. The former involved positive correlations with a subset of the auditory network and the attention network, but negative correlations with the default mode network; the latter was confined to the intrinsic auditory network in the resting state. Our results highlight the important role of the Wernicke’s area in forming vivid musical imagery through bilateral and anti-correlated network interactions, challenging the conventional view of segregated and lateralized processing of music vs. language.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2017musical,
  author = {Yizhen Zhang and Gang Chen and Haiguang Wen and Kun‐Han Lu and Zhongming Liu},
  title = {{Musical Imagery Involves the Wernicke’s Area in Bilateral and Anti-Correlated Network Interactions in Musicians}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/142950},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure