Music-evoked reactivation during continuous perception is associated with enhanced subsequent recall of naturalistic events

Jamal A. Williams, Elizabeth Hellmuth Margulis, Christopher Baldassano, Uri Hasson, Janice Chen, Kenneth A. NormanbioRxiv 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that music can trigger the reactivation of memories for previously experienced events, and this reactivation is linked to better recall of those events. Using fMRI and a film with recurring musical themes, researchers found that music-evoked neural activity in the default mode network predicted improved memory, even after accounting for initial memory strength.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While it's widely known that music can evoke strong memories, the underlying neural mechanisms are not well understood. Specifically, how music might reactivate specific past experiences and whether this reactivation actually helps us remember those experiences better remains an open question. Previous studies on music-evoked autobiographical memories often rely on self-reports of memories formed outside the lab, making it difficult to measure the neural processes of reactivation directly. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how music, within a controlled experimental setting, reactivates neural patterns associated with specific events and how this reactivation relates to subsequent memory recall.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-group fMRI study design. Participants watched the film "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind," which features recurring musical themes. One group watched the film with the original soundtrack (music condition), while the other watched a version with the music removed (no-music condition).

The core of their method involved measuring "music-evoked reactivation." This was done by comparing the neural activity patterns associated with scenes containing a specific musical theme in the music group to the neural activity patterns of earlier scenes with the same theme in the no-music group. This comparison allowed them to isolate the effect of the music cue on neural reactivation, controlling for general scene similarity.

To assess the relationship between reactivation and memory, they sorted scenes into "remembered" and "forgotten" categories based on a subsequent recall test. They then compared reactivation scores for these two categories. To address the possibility that initial encoding strength might explain the observed relationship, they used spatial intersubject correlation (ISC) as a proxy for encoding strength and regressed it out from the reactivation scores.

Datasets

The study used the full-length film "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind" as the stimulus material. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Music as a Neural Replay Button: The study provides compelling evidence that music can act as a trigger for the brain to "replay" neural patterns associated with past experiences. This isn't just a vague feeling; it's a measurable neural phenomenon.
  • Default Mode Network (DMN) is Key: The Default Mode Network, known for its role in self-referential thought and memory retrieval, appears to be a crucial hub for music-evoked memory reactivation.
  • Reactivation Enhances Memory: The degree of neural reactivation triggered by music is directly linked to how well participants remember the associated events. This suggests that music doesn't just bring memories to mind; it actively strengthens them.
  • Beyond Initial Encoding: The findings suggest that music-evoked reactivation contributes to memory consolidation in a way that is distinct from, and potentially additive to, the initial encoding process. This implies that music can help memories "stick" even if they were initially encoded weakly.
  • Specificity of Music's Role: The observed relationship between reactivation and recall was specific to the music condition, highlighting music's unique ability to act as a retrieval cue for complex naturalistic events.

Key Results

  • Music-evoked reactivation of neural patterns in the DMN (specifically in the left inferior parietal lobule and left posterior medial cortex) was significantly higher for remembered scenes compared to forgotten scenes.
  • This relationship between reactivation and subsequent recall remained significant even after controlling for initial encoding strength (measured by spatial intersubject correlation). In some regions, this relationship was even numerically larger after controlling for ISC.
  • The effect of music-evoked reactivation on subsequent recall was significantly larger in the music condition compared to the no-music condition across DMN parcels.
  • Exploratory analyses showed that the DMN and the visual peripheral network were the only brain networks exhibiting this association between music-evoked reactivation and subsequent recall.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the observed relationship between reactivation and subsequent recall might not be strictly causal. While their ISC analysis helps to disentangle this, it's not definitive. Future work could experimentally manipulate reactivation by selectively presenting or omitting repeated musical themes to directly test causality. Additionally, future research could explore the specific features of music (e.g., emotional intensity, pulse) that make it a more effective retrieval cue and investigate the role of the hippocampus in these reactivation processes. The study also notes that while the music condition showed a trend towards better recall, the overall behavioral recall advantage was not always statistically significant, suggesting variability across scenes and the need for further investigation into what makes music a more effective cue in certain circumstances.

Summary updated

Abstract

Music is a potent cue for recalling personal experiences, yet the neural basis of music-evoked memory remains elusive. We address this question by using the full-length film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind to examine how repeated musical themes reactivate previously encoded events in cortex and shape next-day recall. Participants in an fMRI study viewed either the original film (with repeated musical themes) or a no-music version. By comparing neural activity patterns between these groups, we found that music-evoked reactivation of neural patterns linked to earlier scenes in the default mode network was associated with improved subsequent recall. This relationship was specific to the music condition and persisted when we controlled for a proxy measure of initial encoding strength (spatial intersubject correlation), suggesting that music-evoked reactivation may play a role in making event memories stick that is distinct from what happens at initial encoding.
BibTeX
@misc{williams2025music,
  author = {Jamal A. Williams and Elizabeth Hellmuth Margulis and Christopher Baldassano and Uri Hasson and Janice Chen and Kenneth A. Norman},
  title = {{Music-evoked reactivation during continuous perception is associated with enhanced subsequent recall of naturalistic events}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1101/2025.07.05.663273},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure