Muons in air showers at the Pierre Auger Observatory: Measurement of atmospheric production depth

A. Aab, P. Abreu, M. Aglietta, M. Ahlers, E. J. Ahn, I. Al Samarai, I. F. M. Albuquerque, I. Allekotte, J. Allen, P. Allison, A. Almela, J. Alvarez Castillo, Jaime Álvarez-Muñiz, Rafael Alves Batista, M. Ambrosio, A. Aminaei, Luis A. Anchordoqui, S. Andringa, C. Aramo, F. Arqueros, H. Asorey, P. Assis, J. Aublin, M. Ave, M. Avenier, G. Ávila, Alina Mihaela Badescu, K. B. Barber, J. Bäuml, C. Baus, J. J. Beatty, K. Becker, Jose A. Bellido, C. Bérat, X. Bertou, Peter L. Biermann, P. Billoir, F. Blanco, C. Bleve, H. Blümer, Teresa Bister, Denise Boncioli, C. Bonifazi, R. Bonino, Nataliia Borodai, J. Brack, I. M. Brancus, P. Brogueira, W. C. Brown, P. Buchholz, A. Bueno, Mario Buscemi, K. S. Caballero‐Mora, B. Caccianiga, Lorenzo Caccianiga, M. Candusso, L. Caramete, R. Caruso, A. Castellina, G. Cataldi, Lorenzo Cazon, R. Cester, A. G. Chavez, S. H. Cheng, A. Chiavassa, J. A. Chinellato, J. Chudoba, M. Cilmo, R. W. Clay, G. Cocciolo, Roberta Colalillo, L. Collica, M. R. Coluccia, R. Conceição, F. Contreras, M. J. Cooper, S. Coutu, C. E. Covault, A. Criss, J. Cronin, A. Curutiu, R. Dallier, B. Daniel, S. Dasso, K. Daumiller, B. R. Dawson, R. M. de Almeida, Manlio De Domenico, S. J. de Jong, A. De Roeck, I. De Mitri, Jaime de Oliveira, V. de Souza, L. del Peral, O. Deligny, H.-p. Dembinski, N. Dhital, C. Di Giulio, Armando di MatteoPhysical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel method to reconstruct the muon production depth distribution in extensive air showers using the Pierre Auger Observatory's surface detector. This allows for a more precise measurement of $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$, a key parameter sensitive to the mass composition of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays and a powerful tool for constraining hadronic interaction models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the origin and nature of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) is a major challenge in astrophysics. A crucial aspect of this is determining the mass composition of these particles, which is currently uncertain. While the electromagnetic component of air showers has been studied to infer mass composition, its analysis is limited by detector acceptance and analysis approaches. This paper tackles this by proposing a new method using the muonic component of air showers, which offers a larger statistical sample and potentially different systematic uncertainties. Specifically, the paper aims to reconstruct the muon production depth distribution ($X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$) and explore its utility in determining UHECR mass composition and probing hadronic interactions at extreme energies.

Methods

The core of this work lies in reconstructing the muon production depth distribution ($X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$) from data collected by the Pierre Auger Observatory's surface detector (SD). The method leverages the timing information from flash analog-to-digital converter (FADC) traces of surface detectors located far from the shower core. The key idea is that muons, unlike electromagnetic particles, travel in relatively straight lines, retaining a "memory" of their production point. By analyzing the arrival times of muons at the ground, the paper reconstructs their geometrical production heights along the shower axis. This involves:

  • Geometric Delay Calculation: Using the arrival times and positions of muons, the geometric delay is calculated, which accounts for the deviation of muon trajectories from the shower axis.
  • Kinematic and Other Delays: Corrections are applied for kinematic delays (due to energy loss), muon decay, and geomagnetic effects.
  • Muon Production Depth (MPD) Reconstruction: A mapping is established between muon arrival times and their production depths using a set of equations derived from the physics of air showers.
  • Gaisser-Hillas Fit: The reconstructed MPD distribution for each event is fitted with the Gaisser-Hillas function to extract the parameter $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$, representing the depth of maximum muon production.
  • Selection Criteria: To ensure reliable measurements, events are selected based on energy (above 20 EeV) and the uncertainty in $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$ (below a certain threshold that depends on energy). Zenith angles are restricted to [55°, 65°] to minimize electromagnetic contamination.

Datasets

The study utilizes data collected by the Pierre Auger Observatory's surface detector (SD) between January 2004 and December 2012. This dataset comprises approximately 500 events that meet initial criteria, reduced to 481 after quality cuts. For validation and understanding systematic uncertainties, Monte Carlo simulations are extensively used, employing hadronic interaction models like QGSJETII-04 and EPOS-LHC for both proton and iron primary cosmic rays.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Muons as Probes of Hadronic Interactions: The paper highlights that the muon production depth distribution ($X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$) is a powerful observable that complements information from the electromagnetic component of air showers. It directly probes the longitudinal development of the hadronic cascade.
  • $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$ as a Composition Indicator: The study demonstrates that the $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$ distribution is sensitive to the mass of the primary cosmic ray. Heavier nuclei tend to produce showers with smaller $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$ values and narrower distributions, as seen in simulations.
  • Constraining Hadronic Models: By comparing measured $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$ values with predictions from different hadronic interaction models, the paper shows the potential to constrain these models, especially at energies beyond accelerator reach.
  • Zenith Angle Dependence: The paper quantifies the dependence of $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$ on the zenith angle, attributing it to differences in atmospheric density and muon decay probability.
  • Systematic Uncertainty Analysis: A thorough analysis of systematic uncertainties is performed, identifying key contributors such as reconstruction effects, hadronic models, primary mass, seasonal effects, and time variance models.

Key Results

  • The paper successfully reconstructs muon production depth distributions for individual air shower events using the Pierre Auger SD.
  • The analysis shows that the measured mean $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$ evolves with energy, and this evolution is sensitive to the mass composition of cosmic rays.
  • Comparisons with hadronic interaction models (QGSJETII-04 and EPOS-LHC) reveal discrepancies, suggesting that current models may not fully describe the observed phenomena. Specifically, the data falls between the predictions for proton and iron primaries, and the models struggle to consistently describe the observed $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$ evolution.
  • The overall systematic uncertainty in the measurement of $\langle X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu} \rangle$ is estimated to be around 17 g/cm², which represents approximately 25% of the proton-iron separation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Systematic Uncertainties: While significant effort has been made to quantify systematic uncertainties, they still limit the ability to make definitive statements about mass composition. The paper acknowledges that the current level of uncertainty prevents conclusive statements.
  • Model Dependence: The interpretation of $X_{\mathrm{max}}^{\mu}$ in terms of mass composition and hadronic interactions is dependent on the accuracy of the hadronic interaction models used. The study highlights that current models do not provide a fully consistent description of the data.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this novel approach to studying the longitudinal development of the hadronic component of EASs opens up new avenues for UHECR research. Future work will likely focus on refining the analysis to reduce systematic uncertainties, improving hadronic interaction models, and potentially combining this muonic information with other observables to gain a more comprehensive understanding of UHECRs. The complementarity of EM and muonic profiles is emphasized as a crucial direction for future investigations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The surface detector array of the Pierre Auger Observatory provides information about the longitudinal development of the muonic component of extensive air showers. Using the timing information from the flash analog-to-digital converter traces of surface detectors far from the shower core, it is possible to reconstruct a muon production depth distribution. We characterize the goodness of this reconstruction for zenith angles around 60\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{} and different energies of the primary particle. From these distributions, we define ${X}_{\mathrm{max}}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ as the depth along the shower axis where the production of muons reaches maximum. We explore the potentiality of ${X}_{\mathrm{max}}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ as a useful observable to infer the mass composition of ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays. Likewise, we assess its ability to constrain hadronic interaction models.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aab2014muons,
  author = {A. Aab and P. Abreu and M. Aglietta and M. Ahlers and E. J. Ahn and I. Al Samarai and I. F. M. Albuquerque and I. Allekotte and J. Allen and P. Allison and A. Almela and J. Alvarez Castillo and Jaime Álvarez-Muñiz and Rafael Alves Batista and M. Ambrosio and A. Aminaei and Luis A. Anchordoqui and S. Andringa and C. Aramo and F. Arqueros and H. Asorey and P. Assis and J. Aublin and M. Ave and M. Avenier and G. Ávila and Alina Mihaela Badescu and K. B. Barber and J. Bäuml and C. Baus and J. J. Beatty and K. Becker and Jose A. Bellido and C. Bérat and X. Bertou and Peter L. Biermann and P. Billoir and F. Blanco and F. Blanco and C. Bleve and H. Blümer and Teresa Bister and Denise Boncioli and C. Bonifazi and R. Bonino and Nataliia Borodai and J. Brack and I. M. Brancus and P. Brogueira and W. C. Brown and P. Buchholz and A. Bueno and Mario Buscemi and K. S. Caballero‐Mora and B. Caccianiga and Lorenzo Caccianiga and M. Candusso and L. Caramete and R. Caruso and A. Castellina and G. Cataldi and Lorenzo Cazon and R. Cester and A. G. Chavez and S. H. Cheng and A. Chiavassa and J. A. Chinellato and J. Chudoba and M. Cilmo and R. W. Clay and G. Cocciolo and Roberta Colalillo and L. Collica and M. R. Coluccia and R. Conceição and F. Contreras and M. J. Cooper and S. Coutu and C. E. Covault and A. Criss and J. Cronin and A. Curutiu and R. Dallier and B. Daniel and S. Dasso and K. Daumiller and B. R. Dawson and R. M. de Almeida and Manlio De Domenico and S. J. de Jong and A. De Roeck and I. De Mitri and Jaime de Oliveira and V. de Souza and L. del Peral and O. Deligny and H.-P. Dembinski and N. Dhital and C. Di Giulio and Armando di Matteo},
  title = {{Muons in air showers at the Pierre Auger Observatory: Measurement of atmospheric production depth}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.90.012012},
}
Figure