Muon-decay medium-baseline neutrino beam facility

Jun Cao, Miao He, Z. L. Hou, Hantao Jing, Yufeng Li, Zhihui Li, Yingpeng Song, Jingyu Tang, Y. F. Wang, Q. K. Wu, Ye Yuan, Y. ZhengPhysical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes MOMENT, a novel neutrino beam facility designed to measure CP violation by utilizing muon decays. By employing a high-power continuous-wave proton linac and a long muon decay channel, MOMENT aims to deliver an intense, low-energy neutrino beam with reduced background, offering a complementary approach to future, more complex neutrino factories.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The precise measurement of neutrino oscillation parameters, particularly the CP-violating phase, is a key goal in modern particle physics. While future facilities like the Neutrino Factory are envisioned for this purpose, they face significant technical challenges. Existing accelerator-based neutrino beams, often relying on pion decays, suffer from backgrounds that complicate precise measurements. This paper addresses the need for a dedicated, medium-baseline facility that can provide a clean neutrino beam for CP violation studies, specifically by leveraging the advantages of muon decays over pion decays. The proposed MOMENT facility aims to fill this gap by offering a high-flux, low-energy neutrino beam with a well-defined energy spectrum and reduced backgrounds, making it feasible to measure CP violation before the full realization of more ambitious projects.

Methods

The MOMENT facility design is built around several key technological components:

  • Proton Driver: A 15 MW continuous-wave (CW) superconducting proton linac operating at 1.5 GeV is proposed. This linac is inspired by the China Accelerator-Driven System (China-ADS) project, leveraging its development in CW technology. The design emphasizes a simplified structure compared to ADS for research facility requirements, aiming for reduced technical difficulties and cost.
  • Target Station: A mercury-jet target is chosen for pion production, similar to designs for the Neutrino Factory. This choice is driven by the need to withstand a high-power proton beam and facilitate pion emission. The target is placed within a high-field superconducting (SC) solenoid to efficiently collect the produced pions.
  • Pion/Muon Transport: A pion decay channel of approximately 50 meters is designed to convert a significant fraction of pions into muons. This is followed by a section to select either positive or negative muons, and then a bending section to remove high-momentum pions and select the desired muon momentum range.
  • Muon Decay Channel: A crucial element is a long (600 m) muon decay channel. This design avoids the complex muon cooling and acceleration required for a Neutrino Factory, instead relying on a long drift to achieve a sufficient muon decay rate.
  • Detector Concept: A large-volume, Gd-doped water Cherenkov detector is proposed. This type of detector is well-suited for distinguishing lepton charges and flavors, crucial for identifying the different neutrino species produced by muon decays and rejecting backgrounds.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the design and simulation of a proposed facility, rather than experimental data analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Muon Decays for Clean Neutrino Beams: The core insight is that neutrinos from muon decays (μ → e + νμ + ν̄e or μ⁺ → e⁺ + ν̄μ + νe) offer a cleaner signal for oscillation experiments compared to pion decays. This is because they produce only two neutrino flavors (νμ and νe, or ν̄μ and ν̄e) and have a more constrained energy spectrum, significantly reducing backgrounds from other neutrino types.
  • Medium Baseline Advantage: A medium baseline (100-150 km) is identified as optimal for CP violation measurements with the ~300 MeV neutrino energies produced by muon decays. This baseline maximizes the sensitivity to the oscillation phase.
  • CW Linac for High Power: The adoption of a CW superconducting linac is critical for achieving the high beam power (15 MW) necessary for an intense neutrino flux. This technology, while challenging, is being actively developed in China.
  • Long Muon Decay Channel as an Alternative: Instead of complex muon cooling and storage rings, a long (600 m) decay channel is proposed. This approach leverages the lower muon energy and avoids some of the most technically demanding aspects of a full Neutrino Factory.
  • Gd-doped Water Cherenkov Detector: This detector concept is highlighted for its ability to distinguish lepton charges and flavors, essential for the specific neutrino signatures from muon decays and for rejecting neutral current backgrounds.

Key Results

  • Facility Design: A comprehensive schematic design for the MOMENT facility is presented, detailing the proton driver, target station, beam transport lines, and detector concept.
  • Proton Driver Parameters: A 15 MW CW superconducting linac with a proton energy of 1.5 GeV is specified, capable of delivering 1.1×10²⁴ protons on target per year.
  • Muon Decay Channel Performance: A 600 m muon decay channel is designed to achieve a decay probability of about 33% for muons with an average momentum of 300 MeV/c.
  • Neutrino Flux: The facility is projected to produce a neutrino flux of approximately 4.7×10¹¹ ν/m²/y at the detector, with an average muon anti-neutrino energy of around 240 MeV. This flux is noted to be more than twice that of the Neutrino Factory.
  • Technical Challenges Identified: The paper clearly outlines significant technical challenges, particularly in the proton driver (RFQ, SC cavities, cryomodules) and the target station (mercury jet, high-field solenoids, shielding, radiation dose).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Preliminary Design: The authors acknowledge that the presented study is preliminary, and more detailed studies and optimizations are required.
  • Technical Challenges: The paper extensively discusses the numerous technical challenges that need to be overcome, especially for the proton driver and target station. These require significant R&D efforts.
  • Detector R&D: While a Gd-doped water Cherenkov detector is proposed, the authors note that its specific application to MOMENT is still under initial investigation, and further technical issues need to be identified.
  • Alternative Designs: The paper mentions alternative design considerations, such as different cavity types for the linac and exploring fluidized tungsten powder as a target material, indicating ongoing exploration.
  • Muon Beam Utilization: The paper suggests that the intense muon beam produced could be utilized for other muon-based research, opening up additional avenues for the facility.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neutrino beam with about 300 MeV in energy, high-flux and medium baseline is considered a rational choice for measuring CP violation before the more powerful Neutrino Factory is to be built. Following this concept, a unique neutrino beam facility based on muon-decayed neutrinos is proposed. The facility adopts a continuous-wave proton linac of 1.5 GeV and 10 mA as the proton driver, which can deliver an extremely high beam power of 15 MW. Instead of pion-decayed neutrinos, unprecedentedly intense muon-decayed neutrinos are used for better background discrimination. The schematic design for the facility is presented here, including the proton driver, the assembly of a mercury-jet target and capture superconducting solenoids, a $\mathrm{pion}/\mathrm{muon}$ beam transport line, a long muon decay channel of about 600 m and the detector concept. The physics prospects and the technical challenges are also discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cao2014muon,
  author = {Jun Cao and Miao He and Z. L. Hou and Hantao Jing and Yufeng Li and Zhihui Li and Yingpeng Song and Jingyu Tang and Y. F. Wang and Q. K. Wu and Ye Yuan and Y. Zheng},
  title = {{Muon-decay medium-baseline neutrino beam facility}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevstab.17.090101},
}
Figure