Multiway Graph Signal Processing on Tensors: Integrative Analysis of Irregular Geometries

Jay S. Stanley Iii, Eric C. Chi, Gal MishneIEEE Signal Process. Mag 2020 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces Multi-way Graph Signal Processing (MWGSP), a framework that extends traditional Graph Signal Processing (GSP) to handle multi-dimensional data (tensors) with graph structures on each dimension. It unifies various signal processing techniques and offers a powerful way to analyze complex, irregularly structured data across multiple domains simultaneously.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional signal processing often assumes data lies on regular grids (like time or space). GSP extends this to irregular structures (like networks) but typically handles one graph at a time. However, many real-world datasets are inherently multi-dimensional (tensors) and possess complex relationships across these dimensions, which are often ignored by single-way GSP or standard tensor analysis. For example, a video can be seen as a tensor where each mode represents spatial dimensions and time, and each mode might have an underlying graph structure (e.g., pixel neighborhood, temporal sequence). This paper addresses the need for a unified framework to leverage these multi-dimensional graph structures for more effective data analysis, modeling, and processing.

Methods

The core of the paper is the Multi-way Graph Signal Processing (MWGSP) framework. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Tensor Representation: Tensors are used as the fundamental data structure, generalizing vectors and matrices to higher dimensions.
  • Product Graphs: To handle multi-way data with multiple graph structures, the concept of product graphs (specifically the Cartesian product) is introduced. This allows for a unified graph representation of multi-dimensional data, where each mode of the tensor corresponds to a factor graph.
  • Multi-Way Graph Fourier Transform (MWGFT): Analogous to the classical Fourier Transform and the single-way GFT, the MWGFT is defined for multi-way graph signals. It leverages the Kronecker product of factor graph Fourier bases to provide a spectral representation across all modes.
  • Efficient Algorithms: The paper highlights how the Kronecker product structure enables efficient algorithms for MWGSP operations, often by decomposing them into a sequence of operations on smaller factor matrices. This is crucial for handling the computational complexity of high-order tensors.
  • Multi-way Filtering: The framework extends the concept of graph filters to multiple dimensions, allowing for separable and non-separable filters that operate across all modes of the tensor.

Datasets

The paper discusses applications and illustrates concepts using various datasets, including:

  • Dancer mesh: A dynamic mesh dataset representing temporal evolution of 3D coordinates.
  • Molene weather dataset: Spatially determined graph of weather stations with temporal scales (hours, days).
  • Time-lapse video: A 2D spatial grid with a temporal axis.
  • Hyperspectral dataset: A 2D spatial grid with spectral bandwidths.
  • ORL dataset: A dataset of face images used for matrix completion experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Framework: MWGSP provides a single, coherent framework to analyze data with complex, multi-modal irregular structures, unifying classical signal processing, GSP, and tensor analysis.
  • Power of Product Graphs: The Cartesian product graph elegantly captures the joint geometry of multi-way data, enabling the application of graph-based signal processing tools across all dimensions simultaneously.
  • Computational Efficiency: Leveraging the Kronecker product structure of multi-way operators is key to developing computationally feasible algorithms for high-dimensional data, avoiding the storage and computation of massive product graph operators.
  • Beyond Regular Grids: Treating classical domains like time and space as graphs themselves within the MWGSP framework leads to more compact representations and potentially better performance in data compression and analysis.
  • Regularization for Robustness: Graph structures can be used as powerful regularizers in multi-way settings, leading to more robust methods for tasks like denoising, matrix completion, and imputation, especially in the presence of missing data.

Key Results

  • Energy Compactness: MWGFT consistently achieved better energy compactness across various datasets (Dancer mesh, Molene weather, time-lapse video, hyperspectral cube) compared to single-way transforms (GFT, DFT, JFT, 2D-DFT, 3D-DFT). This indicates that MWGFT can represent signals more efficiently by capturing multi-modal dependencies.
  • Matrix Completion Performance: Multi-way graph regularization approaches (e.g., FRPCAG, MCG) consistently outperformed their single-way counterparts on the ORL dataset for matrix completion, especially when a significant portion of data was missing.
  • Algorithmic Efficiency: The paper demonstrates that algorithms based on factor graph operations can significantly reduce computational costs compared to direct computation on product graphs, especially for higher-order tensors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Directed Graphs: The paper notes that extending MWGSP to directed graphs would significantly broaden its versatility.
  • Graph Learning: Developing methods to learn mode-specific or coupled graphs from data, especially in dynamic settings, remains an open challenge.
  • Low-Rank vs. High-Rank: Understanding whether tensor datasets are typically low-rank or high-rank is crucial for choosing appropriate decomposition and processing methods.
  • Nonlinear Generative Models: Processing data whose generative model is nonlinear across different modes is a significant open question.
  • Online and Distributed Processing: Developing online and distributed versions of MWGSP is essential for handling large-scale data that doesn't fit in memory.
  • New Optimization Techniques: There is a need for new optimization techniques to efficiently solve problems combining tensors with graph-based penalties.
  • Deep Learning Integration: Exploring how deep learning can be used to learn wavelet-type filterbanks and joint multiscale decompositions in graph and multi-way settings is a promising direction.
  • Inter-disciplinary Collaboration: Continued collaboration with domain experts is vital for defining relevant problems and demonstrating the utility of MWGSP in real-world applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Graph signal processing (GSP) is an important methodology for studying data residing on irregular structures. Because acquired data are increasingly taking the form of multiway tensors, new signal processing tools are needed to maximally utilize the multiway structure within the data. In this article, we review modern signal processing frameworks that generalize GSP to multiway data, starting from graph signals coupled to familiar regular axes, such as time in sensor networks, and then extending to general graphs across all tensor modes. This widely applicable paradigm motivates reformulating and improving classical problems and approaches to creatively address the challenges in tensor-based data. We synthesize common themes arising from current efforts to combine GSP with tensor analysis and highlight future directions in extending GSP to the multiway paradigm.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{iii2020multiway,
  author = {Jay S. Stanley III and Eric C. Chi and Gal Mishne},
  title = {{Multiway Graph Signal Processing on Tensors: Integrative Analysis of Irregular Geometries}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Signal Process. Mag},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=mCigfDBhpqk},
}
Figure