Multistep catalytic abiotic CO 2 conversion to sugars through C 1 intermediates

Nathan E. Soland, Jie Luo, Arifin Luthfi Maulana, Julian Feijóo, Gea‐Jae Joo, Alexander M. Oddo, Yu Shan, Tianle Wang, Geonhui Lee, Ji-Hoon Choi, Wei-Shan Huynh, Maria Fonseca Guzman, L. Jayasinghe, Cheng Zhu, Yao Yang, Peidong YangProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, modular, three-step abiotic pathway to convert carbon dioxide (CO₂) into sugars using renewable energy. By sequentially electrocatalytically reducing CO₂ to methanol, photocatalytically oxidizing methanol to formaldehyde, and then organocatalytically condensing formaldehyde into various aldoses, the researchers demonstrate a promising route for sustainable chemical production and carbon utilization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The world faces a dual challenge: a surplus of CO₂ emissions contributing to climate change and a growing demand for chemicals, fuels, and even food, which are largely derived from finite fossil fuels. Converting CO₂ into valuable products using renewable energy is a critical goal for sustainability. While biological processes can convert CO₂ to sugars, they are often inefficient. Abiotic methods offer a potential alternative, but efficiently and selectively converting CO₂ into complex molecules like sugars, especially through the elusive formaldehyde intermediate, has been a significant hurdle. This paper addresses the need for a scalable, abiotic strategy to bridge the gap between CO₂ waste streams and the production of valuable carbohydrates.

Methods

The researchers employ a three-stage catalytic approach:

  1. Electrocatalytic CO₂ Reduction to Methanol: They utilize a cobalt phthalocyanine on carbon nanotube (CoPc/CNT) catalyst in a flow cell to convert CO₂ into methanol. This step leverages electrocatalysis, a standard technique for CO₂ conversion, but focuses on achieving high partial current densities for methanol production.
  2. Photocatalytic Methanol to Formaldehyde (PMOR): Methanol is then converted to formaldehyde using a photocatalyst. The team developed a zinc indium sulfide (ZIS) nanocrystal photocatalyst modified with nickel (Ni/ZIS) for this step. This process integrates methanol oxidation and hydrogen evolution, aiming for high selectivity and productivity.
  3. Organocatalytic Formaldehyde to Sugars (Formoin Reaction): The key step involves using an N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) catalyst (specifically, Enders' carbene NHC-1) to condense formaldehyde into aldose sugars. This "formoin" reaction is highlighted for its ability to produce higher sugars (tetroses, pentoses, and hexoses) with high selectivity and without the undesirable byproducts often seen in traditional formose reactions. The use of an alcohol-trapped carbene precursor allows for in situ activation without a base, which is crucial for controlling selectivity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental synthesis and characterization of catalysts and products, rather than training on large datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Modular, Sequential Approach: The paper demonstrates the power of breaking down a complex conversion into optimized, sequential steps, allowing for tailored catalyst design and control at each stage.
  • Formaldehyde as a Key Intermediate: Successfully generating and utilizing formaldehyde as a precursor for sugar synthesis is a significant achievement, as it's often difficult to isolate and control.
  • NHC Catalysis for Selective Sugar Synthesis: The use of NHC catalysts, particularly the Enders' carbene, offers a highly selective route to aldose sugars, circumventing the issues of over-condensation and ketose formation common in traditional formose reactions.
  • Abiotic Alternative to Agriculture: This work presents a compelling vision for producing carbohydrates without the environmental burdens of conventional agriculture (e.g., water consumption, land use, fertilizer).
  • Bridging Waste and Value: The research directly addresses the challenge of CO₂ valorization, turning a waste product into a valuable feedstock for chemicals and potentially food.

Key Results

  • Electrocatalysis: Achieved a peak partial current density of 35 mA cm⁻² for methanol production from CO₂ using the CoPc/CNT catalyst, exceeding a benchmark goal.
  • Photocatalysis: The Ni/ZIS catalyst demonstrated high productivity (over 80 mmol g cat⁻¹ h⁻¹) and near-unit selectivity for methanol dehydrogenation to formaldehyde.
  • Organocatalysis: The NHC-catalyzed formoin reaction achieved carbon conversion yields of 60-80% for tetrose, pentose, and triose mixtures, and over 20% for hexoses.
  • Product Viability: The synthesized sugar mixture was shown to be biocompatible, supporting growth in E. coli cultures, albeit with a lower growth rate compared to glucose.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Electrocatalytic Efficiency: The paper acknowledges limitations in the electrocatalytic step, including low faradaic efficiency (FE) and high overpotential, which impact overall energy efficiency. The production rate of methanol is also noted as not yet suitable for preparative scale in the laboratory.
  • Photocatalytic Yield: The total formaldehyde yield from the photocatalytic step is a small fraction of the total methanol, suggesting room for improvement in carbon yield.
  • Water/Alcohol Sensitivity: The NHC carbene catalysts can be deactivated by water or alcohol, necessitating anhydrous conditions or efficient separation of formaldehyde.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further optimization of the electrocatalytic methanol production to bridge the gap for preparative scale. They also highlight the potential for improving the photocatalytic formaldehyde yield and exploring the recycling of solvents. The ultimate goal is to achieve enantioenriched hexose sugars for enhanced caloric density and microbial suitability. The integration of these steps into a continuous flow system is also a logical next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Carbon dioxide (CO<sub>2</sub>) to multicarbon (C<sub>n</sub>) upgrading for commodity chemicals, fuel production, or artificial food synthesis using renewable energy input is a golden target for researchers in sustainable carbon emission reduction. Here, we explore and analyze a flexible modular roadmap for the task, utilizing sequential electro-, photo-, and organocatalysis to develop a strategy for CO<sub>2</sub> conversion using the key and elusive formaldehyde precursor of interest for sugar generation. We study the electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction to methanol in a flow cell and its discontinuous photooxidation to formaldehyde (PMOR) with excellent selectivity. Utilizing a highly active <i>N-</i>heterocyclic carbene catalyst enables tunable generation of C<sub>4</sub>-C<sub>6</sub> aldoses without undesirable byproducts, with carbon conversion yield reaching 60 to 80% for desired pentose, tetrose, and triose product mixtures and over 20% for hexose. This approach presents a roadmap for CO<sub>2</sub> valorization, aiming to bridge carbon waste streams with sustainable sugar synthesis and opening broad avenues for green chemical production.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{soland2025multistep,
  author = {Nathan E. Soland and Jie Luo and Arifin Luthfi Maulana and Julian Feijóo and Gea‐Jae Joo and Alexander M. Oddo and Yu Shan and Tianle Wang and Geonhui Lee and Ji-Hoon Choi and Wei-Shan Huynh and Maria Fonseca Guzman and L. Jayasinghe and Cheng Zhu and Yao Yang and Peidong Yang},
  title = {{Multistep catalytic abiotic CO <sub>2</sub> conversion to sugars through C <sub>1</sub> intermediates}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2514826122},
}
Figure