Multiscale Modeling of Germinal Center Recapitulates the Temporal Transition From Memory B Cells to Plasma Cells Differentiation as Regulated by Antigen Affinity-Based Tfh Cell Help

Elena Merino Tejero, Danial Lashgari, Rodrigo García-Valiente, Xuefeng Gao, Fabien Crauste, Philippe A. Robert, Michael Meyer‐Hermann, María Rodríguez Martínez, S. Marieke van Ham, Jeroen E. J. Guikema, Huub Hoefsloot, Antoine H. C. van KampenFrontiers in Immunology 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel multiscale computational model that integrates cellular dynamics and molecular gene regulation to simulate germinal center (GC) B cell differentiation. The model successfully recapitulates the observed temporal switch from memory B cell to plasma cell production, driven by antigen affinity-dependent Tfh cell help and the transcription factor BLIMP1.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The adaptive immune system relies on germinal centers (GCs) to generate high-affinity antibodies, memory B cells (MBCs), and plasma cells (PCs). However, the precise molecular and cellular mechanisms that govern B cell fate decisions within GCs, leading to either memory or antibody-producing plasma cells, remain incompletely understood. Specifically, it's unclear how factors like antigen (Ag) binding, B cell receptor (BcR) affinity, interactions with T follicular helper (Tfh) cells (mediated by CD40 signaling), and the interplay of key transcription factors (BCL6, IRF4, BLIMP1) orchestrate this differentiation. Furthermore, experimental evidence suggests a temporal shift in GC output, favoring MBCs early on and PCs later. This study aims to unravel these complex interactions and investigate if antigen affinity-based Tfh cell help can explain this temporal switch.

Methods

The researchers developed a multiscale model (MSM) that bridges two existing computational frameworks:

  1. Agent-Based Model (ABM) for Cellular Level: This model, based on the "LEDA" hypothesis, simulates individual GC B cells, Tfh cells, and follicular dendritic cells (FDCs) within a 3D spatial grid. It captures cellular behaviors like proliferation, migration, antigen capture, and asymmetric division. Crucially, it incorporates a probability of 72% for asymmetric distribution of antigen and transcription factors during cell division.
  2. Gene Regulatory Network (GRN) for Molecular Level: This component uses ordinary differential equations (ODEs) to model the dynamics of three key transcription factors: BCL6, IRF4, and BLIMP1. This GRN is embedded within each individual B cell agent in the ABM.

The MSM integrates these by updating the TF concentrations at each time step of the ABM, allowing cellular signals (BcR and CD40) to influence the molecular network, which in turn dictates cell fate (differentiation into PC or MBC). They explored two main cell-fate decision rules: one based on Ag inheritance (Ag+ cells differentiate) and another based on BLIMP1 levels (high BLIMP1 cells differentiate). They also tested different CD40 signaling scenarios: constant strong, constant weak, and affinity-based.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a computational model and simulation, rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BLIMP1 is a Key Driver of PC Differentiation: The model strongly suggests that BLIMP1 levels, rather than solely antigen presence, are a more critical determinant for plasma cell differentiation.
  • Affinity-Based CD40 Signaling Explains Temporal Switch: The temporal transition from MBCs to PCs observed in GCs is effectively recapitulated when CD40 signaling strength is modulated by B cell affinity for the antigen. This highlights the importance of affinity maturation in directing cell fate.
  • Asymmetric Division Alone is Insufficient: While asymmetric division of antigen plays a role, it's not the sole driver of cell fate. The model shows that relying solely on this mechanism doesn't fully explain the observed differentiation patterns.
  • Synergy of Molecular and Cellular Events: The MSM demonstrates how the interplay between cellular interactions (Tfh-B cell contact, CD40 signaling) and intracellular molecular dynamics (GRN of BCL6, IRF4, BLIMP1) drives complex biological outcomes.

Key Results

  • Scenario 1 (Ag Inheritance-Based Fate):
    • A strong, constant CD40 signal exclusively produced PCs, with no MBCs generated.
  • An affinity-based CD40 signal, while still relying on Ag inheritance for output cell determination, led to the production of both PCs and a small fraction of low-affinity MBCs, particularly in the early GC phase. This showed a temporal shift.
  • Scenario 2 (BLIMP1 Level-Based Fate):
    • A strong, constant CD40 signal resulted in a significant increase in PC production compared to Scenario 1, but still no MBCs.
  • An affinity-based CD40 signal in this scenario produced both PCs and a small fraction of MBCs, with a temporal switch from MBCs to PCs. This scenario showed a more pronounced temporal shift.
  • A weak, constant CD40 signal produced MBCs throughout the GC reaction at the expense of PCs, failing to show a temporal switch.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation Needed: The authors acknowledge that experimental data to directly validate their findings is lacking, particularly regarding the precise role of asymmetric TF division and the definition of MBCs. They propose specific experiments to address this.
  • MBC Definition: The definition of MBCs as Ag+BLIMP1- cells is a simplification. Future work could improve this by modeling the BTB domain and CNC homolog 2 (BACH2) and exploring other signaling pathways.
  • Simplified Signaling: The model neglects cytokine-driven signals and assumes CD40 signaling is the primary Tfh-mediated interaction. Future models could incorporate a broader range of signals.
  • Model Extensions: The authors suggest extending the model to include other cell fates like apoptosis and DZ recycling, and to incorporate additional transcription factors and signaling pathways to further unravel GC B cell differentiation mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Germinal centers play a key role in the adaptive immune system since they are able to produce memory B cells and plasma cells that produce high affinity antibodies for an effective immune protection. The mechanisms underlying cell-fate decisions are not well understood but asymmetric division of antigen, B-cell receptor affinity, interactions between B-cells and T follicular helper cells (triggering CD40 signaling), and regulatory interactions of transcription factors have all been proposed to play a role. In addition, a temporal switch from memory B-cell to plasma cell differentiation during the germinal center reaction has been shown. To investigate if antigen affinity-based Tfh cell help recapitulates the temporal switch we implemented a multiscale model that integrates cellular interactions with a core gene regulatory network comprising BCL6, IRF4, and BLIMP1. Using this model we show that affinity-based CD40 signaling in combination with asymmetric division of B-cells result in switch from memory B-cell to plasma cell generation during the course of the germinal center reaction. We also show that cell fate division is unlikely to be (solely) based on asymmetric division of Ag but that BLIMP1 is a more important factor. Altogether, our model enables to test the influence of molecular modulations of the CD40 signaling pathway on the production of germinal center output cells.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tejero2021multiscale,
  author = {Elena Merino Tejero and Danial Lashgari and Rodrigo García-Valiente and Xuefeng Gao and Fabien Crauste and Philippe A. Robert and Michael Meyer‐Hermann and María Rodríguez Martínez and S. Marieke van Ham and Jeroen E. J. Guikema and Huub Hoefsloot and Antoine H. C. van Kampen},
  title = {{Multiscale Modeling of Germinal Center Recapitulates the Temporal Transition From Memory B Cells to Plasma Cells Differentiation as Regulated by Antigen Affinity-Based Tfh Cell Help}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Immunology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fimmu.2020.620716},
}

Loading related content...

Figure