Multiplexed Digital Characterization of Misfolded Protein Oligomers via Solid-State Nanopores

Sarah E. Sandler, Robert I. Horne, Sara Rocchetti, Robert W. Novak, Nai‐Shu Hsu, Marta Castellana Cruz, Z. Faidon Brotzakis, Rebecca C. Gregory, Sean Chia, Gonçalo J. L. Bernardes, Ulrich F. Keyser, Michele VendruscoloJournal of the American Chemical Society 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel single-molecule nanopore-based technique to detect and quantify misfolded protein oligomers, crucial for diagnosing and treating neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson's. By combining solid-state nanopores with multiplexed DNA barcoding, this method offers high throughput and digital readout, enabling the screening of potential therapeutic inhibitors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Misfolded protein oligomers, particularly alpha-synuclein (aS) in Parkinson's disease, are central to disease pathology. However, accurately detecting and quantifying these transient and often low-concentration species has been a significant challenge. Existing methods, like those relying on amyloid-binding dyes, primarily detect end-stage fibrils and don't directly measure oligomer populations, which are thought to be the most toxic species. While some single-molecule techniques exist, they suffer from low throughput, making them impractical for large-scale screening of therapeutic compounds. This paper addresses the need for a high-throughput, single-molecule method to characterize oligomer populations and assess the efficacy of inhibitors that target their formation.

Methods

The core innovation is a multiplexed digital nanopore sensing approach. Here's a breakdown:

  • Solid-State Nanopores: The researchers utilized solid-state nanopores (10-15 nm diameter) fabricated from quartz capillaries. These pores allow individual molecules to pass through, generating measurable changes in ionic current. The key advantage of solid-state nanopores is their tunability in size, allowing optimization for specific analytes.
  • DNA Nanostructure Barcoding: Each protein sample (monomer or oligomer) is coupled to a unique DNA nanostructure. This nanostructure contains a "barcode region" composed of DNA dumbbells that create distinct electrical signals (spikes) as they pass through the nanopore. The presence or absence of these spikes allows for digital encoding (0s and 1s), enabling the identification of individual particles.
  • Click Chemistry for Coupling: A DBCO-tagged DNA nanostructure is used to "click" onto azide-tagged aS proteins. This bio-orthogonal reaction allows for specific and efficient conjugation of the protein to its unique DNA barcode.
  • Multiplexed Detection: Different samples (e.g., from different inhibitor treatments) are labeled with distinct DNA barcodes. These barcoded samples can then be mixed together and analyzed simultaneously in the same nanopore measurement. This multiplexing capability dramatically increases throughput.
  • Digital Readout: The nanopore signal from the DNA barcode provides a digital "readout" for each particle. By analyzing the frequency of barcode events with and without an attached protein spike, researchers can quantify the proportion of oligomers in a sample. The integral of the current drop associated with the protein spike provides information about the oligomer's size.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The study uses prepared samples of:

  • Stabilized aS Oligomers: Used for initial method optimization and validation due to their higher stability and concentration.
  • aS Aggregation Time-Course Samples: These are more physiologically relevant, transient samples generated in vitro under conditions designed to promote secondary nucleation. These samples were collected at specific time points during aggregation in the presence of different inhibitors.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses its developed method to analyze the prepared protein samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Oligomers, Not Fibrils, Are the Key Target: The paper reinforces the idea that toxic protein species in neurodegenerative diseases are often oligomers, not the end-stage fibrils. This highlights the importance of developing methods that can specifically detect and quantify these oligomers.
  • Nanopores as Digital Readouts: The use of DNA nanostructures as digital barcodes that generate distinct electrical signals in nanopores is a powerful concept. This transforms a continuous current signal into discrete digital information, simplifying analysis and enabling multiplexing.
  • Tailoring Nanopore Size for Specificity: The ability to tune the nanopore diameter is crucial. By using pores too small to detect monomers but large enough for oligomers, the researchers achieved a clear distinction between these species, simplifying sample preparation and analysis.
  • High-Throughput Screening Potential: The multiplexed nature of the assay is a game-changer. It allows for the simultaneous analysis of multiple samples, paving the way for rapid screening of potential drug candidates that inhibit oligomer formation.

Key Results

  • Successful Detection of Stabilized Oligomers: The method successfully distinguished between aS monomers and stabilized aS oligomers, with monomers producing negligible signals in the chosen nanopore size.
  • Quantification of Oligomer Inhibition: The study demonstrated the ability to quantify the effect of small-molecule inhibitors (Anle-138b and 13.08) on aS oligomer production in time-course experiments.
  • Ranking of Inhibitor Efficacy: Compound 13.08 was found to be a more effective inhibitor of oligomer production than Anle-138b, reducing oligomer events by 48% and oligomer mass by 22% compared to the DMSO control. This ranking was consistent with results from a micro free-flow electrophoresis (µFFE) method.
  • Multiplexing Demonstrated: The ability to run multiple barcoded samples simultaneously in the same pore was successfully demonstrated, showing comparable results to individual measurements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dilution-Induced Dissociation: The significant dilution required for nanopore measurements (2500-fold) could potentially lead to the dissociation of oligomers during the DBCO coupling step. The authors suggest cross-linking or using more reactive click chemistry pairs as potential solutions.
  • High Salt Concentration: The high salt concentration used in the nanopore measurement buffer could potentially perturb aggregate distribution. However, the click chemistry was performed in PBS, and samples were only mixed in the detection buffer just before measurement, mitigating this concern. Cross-linking is also suggested as a solution.
  • Size Limitations: Nanopores have a fundamental size limit; particles significantly larger or smaller than the pore diameter may not be detected. However, this can be addressed by tailoring the nanopore size to the specific analyte of interest.
  • Future Work: The authors envision this method being beneficial for researchers studying protein misfolding diseases and for early-stage drug discovery. They also suggest its potential for in vivo applications with the introduction of artificial amino acids bearing azides. Further optimization of DNA barcodes for increased multiplexing capacity is also implied.

Summary updated

Abstract

Misfolded protein oligomers are of central importance in both the diagnosis and treatment of Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases. However, accurate high-throughput methods to detect and quantify oligomer populations are still needed. We present here a single-molecule approach for the detection and quantification of oligomeric species. The approach is based on the use of solid-state nanopores and multiplexed DNA barcoding to identify and characterize oligomers from multiple samples. We study α-synuclein oligomers in the presence of several small-molecule inhibitors of α-synuclein aggregation as an illustration of the potential applicability of this method to the development of diagnostic and therapeutic methods for Parkinson's disease.
BibTeX
@article{sandler2023multiplexed,
  author = {Sarah E. Sandler and Robert I. Horne and Sara Rocchetti and Robert W. Novak and Nai‐Shu Hsu and Marta Castellana Cruz and Z. Faidon Brotzakis and Rebecca C. Gregory and Sean Chia and Gonçalo J. L. Bernardes and Ulrich F. Keyser and Michele Vendruscolo},
  title = {{Multiplexed Digital Characterization of Misfolded Protein Oligomers via Solid-State Nanopores}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1021/jacs.3c09335},
}
Figure