Multiple Temperature-Sensing Behavior of Green and Red Upconversion Emissions from Stark Sublevels of Er3+

Baosheng Cao, Jin-Lei Wu, Xuehan Wang, Yangyang He, Zhiqing Feng, Bin Dong2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel approach to optical temperature sensing using Er³⁺-doped TiO₂ phosphors. By exploiting the multiple, thermally coupled Stark sublevels of Er³⁺, the researchers demonstrate a system capable of multiple, independent temperature measurements across a wide range, offering enhanced accuracy and flexibility compared to traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate and reliable temperature sensing is crucial in various industrial and scientific applications, especially in harsh environments where conventional sensors like thermocouples fail. Optical temperature sensors, particularly those utilizing the fluorescence intensity ratio (FIR) technique, offer a promising alternative due to their immunity to electromagnetic interference and ability to operate remotely. However, existing FIR-based sensors often rely on a limited number of energy level transitions, restricting their sensing range and multiplexing capabilities. This paper addresses the need for more versatile and accurate optical temperature sensors by exploring the potential of multiple, closely spaced energy levels (Stark sublevels) within the Er³⁺ ion to provide independent temperature readings.

Methods

The researchers synthesized Er³⁺-Yb³⁺-Mo⁶⁺-codoped TiO₂ phosphors using a sol-gel method followed by high-temperature sintering. The material's structure was confirmed using X-ray Diffraction (XRD). Temperature-dependent upconversion emission spectra were collected using a 976 nm laser diode as the excitation source and a monochromator with a photomultiplier tube for detection.

The core of the temperature sensing mechanism relies on the Fluorescence Intensity Ratio (FIR) technique. This method leverages the temperature-dependent population distribution among thermally coupled energy levels. Specifically, the paper investigates four pairs of coupled Stark sublevels within the Er³⁺ ion: (²H₁₁/₂⁽¹⁾+²H₁₁/₂⁽²⁾)/(⁴S₃/₂⁽¹⁾+⁴S₃/₂⁽²⁾), ²H₁₁/₂⁽¹⁾/²H₁₁/₂⁽²⁾, ⁴S₃/₂⁽¹⁾/⁴S₃/₂⁽²⁾, and ⁴F₉/₂⁽¹⁾/⁴F₉/₂⁽²⁾. The ratio of fluorescence intensities from these coupled levels is directly related to temperature via a Boltzmann distribution. By analyzing the FIR of these different level pairs, the researchers can achieve multiple, independent temperature measurements. The paper also investigates the temperature dependence of individual green and red emission intensities, fitting them to established models for thermal quenching and multiphonon-assisted excitation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilizes self-generated experimental data from the synthesized phosphors under controlled temperature and excitation conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Exploiting Stark Sublevels for Multiplexed Sensing: The most significant insight is the successful demonstration that Stark sublevels of Er³⁺, which are split by the crystal field, can act as independent temperature sensors. This opens up a pathway for multiplexed optical temperature sensing within a single material.
  • Correlation between Energy Gap and Sensing Performance: The paper clearly shows that the energy gap (ΔΕ) between coupled Stark sublevels plays a critical role in determining sensing performance. Larger ΔΕ values generally lead to higher absolute sensitivity and better accuracy, while smaller ΔΕ values can contribute to higher maximum sensitivity (Smax).
  • Tunable Sensitivity and Accuracy: By selecting different pairs of coupled Stark sublevels, the sensor's sensitivity and accuracy can be tailored for specific temperature ranges. This flexibility is a major advantage over single-channel sensors.
  • Green Emission Behavior: The unusual increase in green emission intensity with increasing temperature, contrary to typical thermal quenching, is attributed to an increased Yb³⁺ absorption cross-section at elevated temperatures, highlighting complex interactions within the material.

Key Results

  • Multiple Sensing Channels: Four distinct temperature-sensing channels were established using different pairs of Er³⁺ Stark sublevels.
  • Wide Temperature Range: The developed sensor system demonstrated effective temperature sensing in the range of 307 K to 673 K.
  • High Sensitivity Achieved: The coupled energy levels (H₁ + H₁₁)/(S₁ + SII) exhibited the highest absolute sensitivity (Smax) due to a larger energy gap (ΔΕ = 0.0558 eV). Conversely, the F₁/F₁₁ levels provided the highest relative sensitivity (Sr) due to a combination of a smaller ΔΕ and a larger pre-exponential factor (C).
  • Accuracy and Error Analysis: The paper quantifies temperature measurement error, showing that higher relative sensitivity (Sr) leads to better accuracy. The (H₁ + H₁₁)/(S₁ + SII) levels offered better accuracy at higher temperatures, while other level pairs showed promise for lower temperature ranges.
  • Material Characterization: XRD confirmed the anatase phase of TiO₂ and the presence of Yb₂Ti₂O₇, with Mo⁶⁺ incorporated into the lattice.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Excitation Power: While the use of a 976 nm laser diode is advantageous for low excitation power, the paper notes that the intensity of upconversion emissions increased with pump current, suggesting potential for further optimization with higher power sources or different excitation wavelengths.
  • Material Optimization: The study focuses on a specific composition (2 mol % Er³⁺–20 mol % Yb³⁺–2 mol % Mo⁶⁺-codoped TiO₂). Further research could explore the effects of varying doping concentrations and host materials on sensing performance.
  • Real-World Application Testing: While the paper discusses potential applications, extensive testing in actual industrial or environmental conditions would be necessary to validate the sensor's robustness and long-term stability.
  • Further Exploration of Energy Transfer Mechanisms: While the paper references previous work on Mo⁶⁺ sensitization, a deeper understanding of the precise energy transfer pathways, especially concerning the Stark sublevels, could lead to further improvements.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{cao2015multiple,
  author = {Baosheng Cao and Jin-Lei Wu and Xuehan Wang and Yangyang He and Zhiqing Feng and Bin Dong},
  title = {{Multiple Temperature-Sensing Behavior of Green and Red Upconversion Emissions from Stark Sublevels of Er3+}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3390/s151229839},
}

Loading related content...

Figure