Multiple laboratory mouse reference genomes define strain specific haplotypes and novel functional loci

Jingtao Lilue, Anthony Doran, Ian T. Fiddes, Monica Abrudan, Joel Armstrong, Ruth Bennett, William Chow, Joanna Collins, Stephan C. Collins, Anne Czechanski, Petr Danecek, Mark Diekhans, Dirk-Dominic Dolle, Matt Dunn, Richard Durbin, Dent Earl, Anne C. Ferguson‐Smith, Paul Flicek, Jonathan Flint, Adam Frankish, Beiyuan Fu, Mark Gerstein, James Gilbert, Leo Goodstadt, Jennifer Harrow, Kerstin Howe, Mikhail Kolmogorov, Stefanie Köenig, Chris Lelliott, Jane Loveland, Clayton E. Mathews, Richard Mott, Paul Muir, Fábio C. P. Navarro, Duncan T. Odom, Naomi Park, Sarah Pelan, Stephen Phan, Michael A. Quail, Laura G. Reinholdt, Lars Romoth, Lesley Shirley, Cristina Sisu, Marcela Sjöberg, Mario Stanke, Charles A. Steward, Mark Thomas, Glen Threadgold, David Thybert, James Torrance, Kim Wong, Jonathan Wood, Binnaz Yalcin, Fengtang Yang, David J. Adams, Benedict Paten, Thomas KeanebioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first comprehensive de novo genome assemblies for 16 diverse laboratory mouse strains, revealing extensive strain-specific genetic variations and novel functional loci. These new genomes significantly improve the mouse reference genome annotation and uncover a large, previously unannotated gene (Efcab3-like) with a critical role in brain development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The laboratory mouse is a cornerstone for biomedical research, but its genetic diversity has been historically under-characterized. Relying on a single reference genome (C57BL/6J) for variant calling can obscure true strain-specific differences, making it difficult to understand how genetic variation influences phenotypes, disease susceptibility, and drug responses. This paper addresses the need for a more complete picture of mouse genomic diversity by generating high-quality de novo assemblies for a broad range of inbred and wild-derived strains.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-platform sequencing approach, combining Illumina paired-end, mate-pairs, fosmid, and BAC-end sequencing. For some strains, Dovetail Genomics' Chicago libraries were used to improve long-range accuracy and contiguity. They then performed de novo genome assembly, creating pseudo-chromosomes by aligning to syntenic regions in other species. To improve gene annotation, they integrated strain-specific RNA-Seq data and PacBio long-read cDNA sequencing. They also developed a systematic approach to identify regions of high heterozygous SNP density (hSNPs) as indicators of significant strain-specific variation.

Datasets

The study utilized sequencing data from 16 laboratory mouse strains: 12 classical inbred strains (129S1/SvImJ, A/J, AKR/J, BALB/cJ, C3H/HeJ, C57BL/6NJ, CBA/J, DBA/2J, FVB/NJ, LP/J, NZO/HILtJ, and NOD/ShiLtJ) and 4 wild-derived strains (Mus musculus castaneus (CAST/EiJ), Mus musculus musculus (PWK/PhJ), Mus musculus domesticus (WSB/EiJ), and Mus spretus (SPRET/EiJ)). They also leveraged existing mouse genome variation catalogs and the GRCm38 reference genome annotation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unveiling Hidden Diversity: The de novo assemblies revealed that strain-specific variation can account for 0.5-2.8% of the mouse genome, highlighting the limitations of relying solely on reference-based variant calling.
  • Immunity and Defense Genes are Hotspots: Regions with the highest strain-specific variation were significantly enriched for genes involved in immunity, defense, and sensory perception, suggesting these are key areas driving phenotypic differences.
  • Transposable Elements Drive Variation: Young transposable elements and recent retrotransposition events were also enriched in these variable regions, indicating their significant role in shaping genome diversity.
  • A Giant New Gene: The discovery of Efcab3-like, an 188-exon gene encoding a 5,874 amino acid protein, is remarkable. This gene is conserved across mammals and appears to play a crucial role in brain development.
  • Improving the Reference: The new assemblies provided valuable data to correct errors and complete gene structures in the official mouse reference genome (GRCm38).

Key Results

  • 16 De Novo Assemblies: High-quality, chromosome-scale de novo genome assemblies were generated for 16 diverse mouse strains.
  • 2,567 Highly Variable Regions: Approximately 2,567 regions exhibiting the greatest sequence diversity between strains were identified.
  • 10 New Gene Structures Completed: The study contributed to the completion of 10 previously incomplete gene structures in the GRCm38 reference genome.
  • 62 New Coding Loci Added: 62 new coding loci were added to the mouse genome annotation.
  • Efcab3-like Knockout Phenotype: Mice lacking Efcab3-like exhibited significant size anomalies in four brain regions, suggesting its critical role in regulating brain development and size.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Draft Assemblies: While high-quality, the assemblies are described as "draft" in some instances, indicating potential for further refinement.
  • Focus on Specific Strains: The study focused on a selection of commonly used inbred and wild-derived strains. Future work could expand to include a broader range of strains to capture even more diversity.
  • Functional Validation: While the study identified novel genes and regions of interest, further functional studies are needed to fully elucidate the roles of these genes and the implications of strain-specific variation for various biological processes and diseases. The authors suggest that these new resources will facilitate such future investigations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The most commonly employed mammalian model organism is the laboratory mouse. A wide variety of genetically diverse inbred mouse strains, representing distinct physiological states, disease susceptibilities, and biological mechanisms have been developed over the last century. We report full length draft de novo genome assemblies for 16 of the most widely used inbred strains and reveal for the first time extensive strain-specific haplotype variation. We identify and characterise 2,567 regions on the current Genome Reference Consortium mouse reference genome exhibiting the greatest sequence diversity between strains. These regions are enriched for genes involved in defence and immunity, and exhibit enrichment of transposable elements and signatures of recent retrotransposition events. Combinations of alleles and genes unique to an individual strain are commonly observed at these loci, reflecting distinct strain phenotypes. Several immune related loci, some in previously identified QTLs for disease response have novel haplotypes not present in the reference that may explain the phenotype. We used these genomes to improve the mouse reference genome resulting in the completion of 10 new gene structures, and 62 new coding loci were added to the reference genome annotation. Notably this high quality collection of genomes revealed a previously unannotated gene (Efcab3-like) encoding 5,874 amino acids, one of the largest known in the rodent lineage. Interestingly, Efcab3-like −/− mice exhibit severe size anomalies in four regions of the brain suggesting a mechanism of Efcab3-like regulating brain development.
BibTeX
@misc{lilue2018multiple,
  author = {Jingtao Lilue and Anthony Doran and Ian T. Fiddes and Monica Abrudan and Joel Armstrong and Ruth Bennett and William Chow and Joanna Collins and Stephan C. Collins and Anne Czechanski and Petr Danecek and Mark Diekhans and Dirk-Dominic Dolle and Matt Dunn and Richard Durbin and Dent Earl and Anne C. Ferguson‐Smith and Paul Flicek and Jonathan Flint and Adam Frankish and Beiyuan Fu and Mark Gerstein and James Gilbert and Leo Goodstadt and Jennifer Harrow and Kerstin Howe and Mikhail Kolmogorov and Stefanie Köenig and Chris Lelliott and Jane Loveland and Clayton E. Mathews and Richard Mott and Paul Muir and Fábio C. P. Navarro and Duncan T. Odom and Naomi Park and Sarah Pelan and Stephen Phan and Michael A. Quail and Laura G. Reinholdt and Lars Romoth and Lesley Shirley and Cristina Sisu and Marcela Sjöberg and Mario Stanke and Charles A. Steward and Mark Thomas and Glen Threadgold and David Thybert and James Torrance and Kim Wong and Jonathan Wood and Binnaz Yalcin and Fengtang Yang and David J. Adams and Benedict Paten and Thomas Keane},
  title = {{Multiple laboratory mouse reference genomes define strain specific haplotypes and novel functional loci}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/235838},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure