Multiple Immunostainings with Different Epitope Retrievals—The FOLGAS Protocol

Anna von Schoenfeld, Peter Bronsert, Michael Poc, Andrew Fuller, Andrew Filby, Stefan Kraft, Konrad Kurowski, Kristin Sörensen, Julia Huber, Jens Pfeiffer, Michele Proietti, Verena Stehl, Martin Werner, Maximilian SeidlInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces FOLGAS, a novel protocol for performing multiple immunofluorescence and immunohistochemistry stainings on the same tissue slide, even when different antigen retrieval methods are required. This method preserves tissue morphology and allows for the integration of CyTOF imaging, significantly expanding the multiplexing capabilities for FFPE samples.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Analyzing multiple proteins simultaneously within a single tissue section is crucial for understanding complex biological processes, such as cell co-localization or signaling pathways. However, existing methods for multiplexed staining on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissues face significant challenges. These include the need for different epitope retrieval techniques for different antibodies, which can lead to tissue degradation or loss of signal. Furthermore, cross-reactivity between antibodies and the difficulty of combining various detection methods (like immunohistochemistry and CyTOF) on the same slide limit the depth of analysis. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a robust and versatile protocol that enables sequential staining with diverse retrieval methods while maintaining tissue integrity and signal quality.

Methods

The core of the FOLGAS protocol lies in a novel re-fixation step using formaldehyde gas. After an initial staining procedure (IHC or IF), the tissue slide, while still moist, is exposed to formaldehyde vapor overnight at 37°C. This gas-phase fixation serves two critical purposes: it re-fixes the tissue, preventing degradation during subsequent harsh retrieval steps, and it denatures any remaining unbound antibodies, thereby preventing cross-reactivity in subsequent staining rounds.

Key aspects of the method include:

  • Sequential Staining: The protocol allows for the sequential application of multiple antibodies, each potentially requiring a different epitope retrieval method (e.g., heat-induced antigen retrieval in citric buffer or proteinase K digestion).
  • Formaldehyde Gas Phase Refixation: This is the central innovation. Instead of liquid formalin, which can macerate tissue, the gas phase provides a gentler yet effective re-fixation.
  • Independent Antibody and Retrieval Choice: The protocol is designed to be independent of the primary and secondary antibody species and the specific retrieval method used for each target.
  • Preservation of Histomorphology: The refixation step is shown to maintain the structural integrity of the tissue.
  • Integration with CyTOF: A significant extension of FOLGAS is its adaptation for CyTOF imaging. This involves using a DAB-based hydrophobic masking technique. After the metal-labeled primary antibody is applied and detected, it's "cloaked" with a DAB precipitate (formed via HRP-coupled secondary antibody). This shields the metal label during subsequent staining steps, allowing it to be detected by CyTOF after laser ablation.

Datasets

The study utilized FFPE sections from palatine tonsils of immunologically healthy donors. No specific large-scale public datasets were used for training or evaluation; rather, the method was validated on these tissue samples using a panel of well-characterized antibodies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Formaldehyde Gas as a Gentle Yet Effective Re-fixative: The use of formaldehyde gas for re-fixation is a clever workaround to prevent tissue degradation during sequential harsh retrieval steps, a major bottleneck in multiplexed staining.
  • True Antibody Species Independence: The protocol's ability to accommodate antibodies from different species and with different retrieval needs without significant cross-reactivity or signal loss is a major step forward.
  • Bridging the Gap to CyTOF: The adaptation of FOLGAS for CyTOF imaging, particularly with the DAB masking strategy, is a significant contribution. It opens up the possibility of high-plex CyTOF analysis on FFPE tissues, which are far more abundant and better preserved than cryosections.
  • Preservation of Histological Detail: The ability to maintain fine tissue morphology alongside multiplexed protein detection is critical for accurate interpretation in diagnostic and research settings.

Key Results

  • The FOLGAS protocol successfully enabled triple stainings with different epitope retrieval methods, preserving tissue structure and signal intensity comparable to single stainings.
  • In immunofluorescence triple stainings, the sum of H-scores (a measure of staining intensity and cell count) was comparable to single stainings, with only minor variations.
  • In immunohistochemistry triple stainings, the H-scores were also largely comparable to single stainings, with the third staining often showing similar or higher scores.
  • A pilot experiment successfully demonstrated the transferability of the FOLGAS protocol to CyTOF imaging using DAB masking, enabling double staining of CD163 and CD68 on FFPE sections.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Protocol Duration: The authors acknowledge that the current FOLGAS protocol, especially for a comprehensive panel, can take up to three working days, which might be too long for routine diagnostics.
  • Potential for Hydrophobic Precipitations: In IHC multistainings, the formation of hydrophobic precipitates was observed, which the authors attribute to incomplete deparaffinization. This suggests a need for careful optimization of the deparaffinization step.
  • AP Chromogen Sensitivity: The AP-based blue chromogen showed diminished signal intensity after refixation, leading the authors to recommend using it for the last staining step.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest automating the FOLGAS protocol, potentially in autostainers, to improve reproducibility and reduce processing time. They also highlight the potential for applying FOLGAS to evaluate immune checkpoint proteins in various tissue components, particularly in cancer research and diagnostics. Further optimization of antibody orders and chromogen/fluorophore choices is also implied.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe a sequential multistaining protocol for immunohistochemistry, immunofluorescence and CyTOF imaging for formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded specimens (FFPE) in the formalin gas-phase (FOLGAS), enabling sequential multistaining, independent from the primary and secondary antibodies and retrieval. Histomorphologic details are preserved, and crossreactivity and loss of signal intensity are not detectable. Combined with a DAB-based hydrophobic masking of metal-labeled primary antibodies, FOLGAS allows the extended use of CyTOF imaging in FFPE sections.
BibTeX
@article{schoenfeld2021multiple,
  author = {Anna von Schoenfeld and Peter Bronsert and Michael Poc and Andrew Fuller and Andrew Filby and Stefan Kraft and Konrad Kurowski and Kristin Sörensen and Julia Huber and Jens Pfeiffer and Michele Proietti and Verena Stehl and Martin Werner and Maximilian Seidl},
  title = {{Multiple Immunostainings with Different Epitope Retrievals—The FOLGAS Protocol}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms23010223},
}

Loading related content...

Figure