Multiple health complaints in preadolescence and hospital contacts during adolescence: a prospective cohort study

Martin Bernstorff, Charlotte Ulrikka Rask, Dorte Rytter, Stefan Nygaard Hansen, Bodil Hammer BechScientific 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that preadolescents experiencing multiple non-specific health complaints (MHC) are significantly more likely to have hospital contacts during adolescence. This finding highlights the importance of addressing these seemingly minor complaints early on, as they predict future healthcare utilization, particularly for psychiatric issues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

There's a growing concern about the increasing prevalence of "multiple health complaints" (MHC) in preadolescents worldwide. These are non-specific symptoms like headaches, stomachaches, or feeling nervous, which aren't easily attributed to a defined medical disorder. While the rise in MHC is noted, its long-term implications for individual well-being and societal resource use (like healthcare costs) remain poorly understood. This makes it challenging for policymakers and healthcare professionals to gauge the significance of this trend and decide on appropriate interventions. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by investigating whether MHC in preadolescence can predict future hospital contacts in adolescence.

Methods

The researchers employed a prospective, population-based cohort study design using data from the Danish National Birth Cohort. Preadolescents were assessed at age 11 using a modified version of the Health Behaviour in School Children Symptom Checklist (HBSC-SCL) to identify MHC. MHC was defined as reporting two or more concurrent symptoms with at least weekly frequency. Hospital contacts (in-patient, out-patient, and emergency room) were then tracked through Danish national health registers until the end of 2018.

Statistical analysis primarily involved negative binomial regression to estimate incidence rate ratios (IRRs), comparing the rate of hospital contacts in children with MHC to those without. The models were progressively adjusted for various factors, including sociodemographic variables, pre-existing somatic and psychiatric morbidity, and parental characteristics, to isolate the prognostic effect of MHC. They also explored the dose-response relationship between the total number of reported symptoms (sum-score) and hospital contacts.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Danish National Birth Cohort, a large, nationwide population-based cohort.

  • Preadolescent data: Collected at age 11 (between 2010-2013) via a questionnaire including a modified Health Behaviour in School Children Symptom Checklist (HBSC-SCL).
  • Adolescent data: Hospital contact data was obtained from the Danish National Patient Registry from the time of the questionnaire response until December 31st, 2018.
  • Covariate data: Information on child and parental characteristics was sourced from the Civil Registration System, the Danish Register of Medicinal Product Statistics, and Statistics Denmark.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study leverages existing national registries and a well-established symptom checklist.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MHC as a "red flag": The study strongly suggests that MHC in preadolescence is not just a transient phase but a significant predictor of future healthcare needs, particularly hospitalizations. This challenges the notion that these symptoms can be easily dismissed.
  • Psychiatric contacts are particularly elevated: The association between MHC and hospital contacts was notably stronger for psychiatric admissions, suggesting a potential link between early non-specific complaints and later mental health challenges.
  • Dose-response relationship: The more symptoms a child reported, the higher their likelihood of hospital contact, indicating that symptom burden is a crucial factor in predicting healthcare utilization.
  • Robustness of findings: The association between MHC and hospital contacts remained significant even after adjusting for a wide range of confounding factors, underscoring the independent prognostic value of MHC.

Key Results

  • Increased hospital contacts: Preadolescents with MHC had, on average, 62% more total hospital contacts during adolescence compared to those without MHC, even after comprehensive adjustments (IRR = 1.62 [95% CI 1.54–1.71]).
  • Psychiatric vs. Somatic: The association was more than twice as strong for psychiatric contacts (IRR = 2.84 [2.54, 3.18]) compared to somatic contacts (IRR = 1.32 [1.25, 1.38]).
  • Symptom burden matters: For every unit increase in the HBSC-SCL sum-score, there was a significant increase in the rate of hospital contacts. The highest symptom score (28) was associated with an IRR of 3.62 [95% CI: 3.12, 4.20] for hospital contacts compared to a score of 0.
  • Prevalence: 10.3% of the responding children reported MHC at age 11.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * Attrition: The study experienced a 48% attrition rate at the 11-year follow-up, with responders potentially differing from non-responders in ways that could bias results (e.g., lower parental education in non-responders). * Symptom checklist: The exclusion of the "backache" item from the HBSC-SCL may have led to an underestimation of MHC prevalence. * Healthcare system context: The findings are based on a universal healthcare system with gatekeeping, which might limit generalizability to countries with different healthcare structures or cost barriers. * Cultural interpretation: Symptom interpretation can vary across cultures, potentially affecting generalizability.

Future Work: The authors emphasize the urgent need to understand the underlying causes of MHC. This causal understanding is crucial for developing effective interventions to prevent potentially unhelpful healthcare use and to guide future actions for both society and the healthcare system. Further research should focus on elucidating these mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Multiple health complaints (MHC) is increasing among preadolescents in many countries, but their prognostic effect for individual thriving or societal resource use is scarcely studied. This makes interpreting the significance of this increase challenging. We contribute by examining whether MHC in preadolescence predicts hospital contacts in adolescence by doing a nation-wide population-based cohort-study following preadolescents from the Danish National Birth-Cohort from 2010 to 2018. 96,382 children were invited at age 11. Responses to a modified version of the Health Behaviour in School Children Symptom Checklist (headache, dizziness, stomachache, irritability, feeling nervous, difficulty in getting to sleep and feeling low) was dichotomized into MHC (≥ 2 concurrent symptoms, each with a frequency of at least weekly, yes/no). Hospital contacts were derived from Danish registers from the date of answering the questionnaire to December 31st 2018. Negative binomial regression estimated incidence rate ratios (IRRs) comparing children with MHC to children without. Analyses were further broken down by hospital sector (psychiatric/somatic) and contact type (in-patient/out-patient/emergency room). 47,365 (49.1%) responded. Mean age was 11.2 years, 52% girls. 10.3% of responders reported MHC. For hospital contacts, the unadjusted IRR was 1.74 [95% CI 1.65, 1.83]. Results were robust to adjustment for sociodemographic variables and somatic/psychiatric morbidity diagnosed before baseline, IRR 1.62 [95% CI 1.54–1.71]. In conclusion, MHC in preadolescents are prognostic of hospital contacts. This shows that we cannot ignore MHC, and to prevent potentially unhelpful healthcare use, we must act. Future research should focus on the underlying causes of MHC to understand which changes will be most helpful and thus how to act.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bernstorff2022multiple,
  author = {Martin Bernstorff and Charlotte Ulrikka Rask and Dorte Rytter and Stefan Nygaard Hansen and Bodil Hammer Bech},
  title = {{Multiple health complaints in preadolescence and hospital contacts during adolescence: a prospective cohort study}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-11167-y},
}
Figure