Multiple cosmic collisions and the microwave background power spectrum

Anthony Aguirre, Jonathan KozaczukPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Collisions between cosmic bubbles of different vacua are a generic feature of false vacuum eternal inflation scenarios. While previous studies have focused on the consequences of a single collision event in an observer's past, we begin here an investigation of the more general scenario allowing for many ``mild'' collisions intersecting our past light cone (and one another). We discuss the general features of multiple collision scenarios and consider their impact on the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature power spectrum, treating the collisions perturbatively. In a large class of models, one can approximate a multiple collision scenario as a superposition of individual collision events governed by nearly isotropic and scale-invariant distributions, most appearing to take up less than half of the sky. In this case, the shape of the expected CMB temperature spectrum maintains statistical isotropy and typically features a dramatic increase in power in the low multipoles relative to that of the best-fit $\Lambda$CDM model, which is in tension particularly with the observed quadrupole. We argue that this predicted spectrum is largely model independent and can be used to outline features of the underlying statistical distributions of colliding bubbles consistent with CMB temperature measurements.

The Problem of a Crowded Multiverse

In the theory of "false vacuum eternal inflation," our observable universe is just one of many "bubbles" nucleating within a rapidly expanding background. A natural consequence of this framework is that these bubbles should occasionally collide. While previous research has focused on the signature of a single such collision—which would appear as a giant, azimuthally symmetric disk on the sky—there is no theoretical reason to assume we have only been hit once.

Causal structure of bubble collisions within an observation bubble.

If the nucleation rate is high enough, our past light cone could be littered with the remnants of many "mild" collisions. This paper moves beyond the single-collision model to determine the collective statistical impact of multiple collisions on the CMB temperature power spectrum and evaluate if such a scenario is compatible with current observations.

Methodology: Superposition and Statistical Averaging

The researchers employ a perturbative approach, assuming the collisions are mild enough that they do not disrupt the overall evolution of our universe but leave a detectable imprint on the last scattering surface.

Key technical steps include:

  • Superposition: Arguing that for a large class of models, the total gravitational potential perturbation is simply the sum of individual collision impacts.
  • The "Frame Shift": Introducing a geometric argument to handle observers who might be "foreign-born" (originating within a post-collision region). This effectively maps collisions that would cover more than half the sky into smaller, "frame-shifted" versions.
  • Statistical Averaging: Instead of looking for specific disks, the authors derive the expected power spectrum ($C_l$) by averaging over the probability distributions of bubble sizes, locations, and perturbation strength.
Spatial distribution of observers (A, B, C) relative to a collision interface.

Using the Sachs-Wolfe approximation, these gravitational potential fluctuations are related directly to CMB temperature variations at large angular scales ($l \lesssim 70$).

Results: The Low-Multipole Power Boost

The analysis yields several key insights into the nature of a crowded multiverse:

  • Isotropy from Chaos: Even though individual collisions break local symmetry, a large number of them distributed randomly across the sky restores statistical isotropy. We would not see one big "bruise," but rather a general change in the texture of the CMB.
  • Scale Invariance: For "late-time" collisions occurring near the end of inflation, the distribution of bubble sizes on the sky is nearly scale-invariant.
  • The Low-Multipole Power Boost: The most significant finding is that multiple collisions act as a "red-tilted" source of noise. Because larger bubbles are physically closer to the collision event and thus "brighter," they contribute disproportionately to the lowest multipoles ($l=2, 3, 4$).
  • Model Independence: The authors argue that the shape of this power boost is largely independent of the specific inflationary potential, depending only on the geometry of de Sitter space.

Constraints and Future Directions

The predicted increase in power at low $l$ is in direct tension with the famously low "quadrupole" observed in our CMB. To remain consistent with WMAP7 observations (specifically the 95% confidence limit of the quadrupole), the parameters must satisfy: $$N_{obs} \alpha_2 \Omega_c \lesssim 3.5 \times 10^{-9}$$ This provides a concrete "speed limit" for how crowded our multiverse can be.

Future work is needed to model smaller-scale effects beyond the Sachs-Wolfe approximation and incorporate CMB polarization and non-Gaussianity, which might provide even tighter constraints or a "smoking gun" for bubble collisions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Collisions between cosmic bubbles of different vacua are a generic feature of false vacuum eternal inflation scenarios. While previous studies have focused on the consequences of a single collision event in an observer's past, we begin here an investigation of the more general scenario allowing for many ``mild'' collisions intersecting our past light cone (and one another). We discuss the general features of multiple collision scenarios and consider their impact on the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature power spectrum, treating the collisions perturbatively. In a large class of models, one can approximate a multiple collision scenario as a superposition of individual collision events governed by nearly isotropic and scale-invariant distributions, most appearing to take up less than half of the sky. In this case, the shape of the expected CMB temperature spectrum maintains statistical isotropy and typically features a dramatic increase in power in the low multipoles relative to that of the best-fit $\ensuremath{\Lambda}\mathrm{CDM}$ model, which is in tension particularly with the observed quadrupole. We argue that this predicted spectrum is largely model independent and can be used to outline features of the underlying statistical distributions of colliding bubbles consistent with CMB temperature measurements.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aguirre2013multiple,
  author = {Anthony Aguirre and Jonathan Kozaczuk},
  title = {{Multiple cosmic collisions and the microwave background power spectrum}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.87.023506},
}
Figure