Multiparameter analysis of timelapse imaging reveals kinetics of megakaryocytic erythroid progenitor clonal expansion and differentiation

Vanessa Scanlon, Evrett N. Thompson, Betty R. Lawton, Maria P. Kochugaeva, Kevinminh Ta, Madeline Y. Mayday, Juliana Xavier-Ferrucio, Elaine Kang, Nicole M. Eskow, Yi-Chien Lu, Nayoung Kwon, Anisha Laumas, Matthew Cenci, Kalyani Lawrence, Katie Barden, Shannon T. Larsuel, Fiona Reed, Gabriela Pena Carmona, Ashley Ubbelohde, June P. Lee, Shakthi Boobalan, Yvette Oppong, Rachel Anderson, Colby Maynard, Kaylie Sahirul, Callista Lajeune, Varsha Ivathraya, Tiffany Addy, Patricia Sanchez, Colin Holbrook, Andrew Tri Van Ho, James S. Duncan, Helen M. Blau, Andre Levchenko, Diane S. KrauseScientific 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a high-resolution, long-term (>7 days) time-lapse imaging pipeline to "crack the black box" of how blood progenitor cells decide their fate. By tracking primary human cells for up to 13 generations, the study reveals that while cytokines like TPO and EPO are essential for keeping cells alive and dividing, they don't actually "instruct" a cell to become a red blood cell or a platelet-producer—the cells seem to make those choices independently.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In hematopoiesis (the process of blood cell formation), scientists traditionally rely on Colony-Forming Unit (CFU) assays. You plate a single progenitor cell, wait two weeks, and see what kind of "colony" it grew into. While useful, this is a "black box" approach: it provides a static snapshot of the end result but misses the entire journey.

We didn't know the kinetics—how fast do they divide? Do they move? Do they divide symmetrically (making two identical daughters) or asymmetrically? Furthermore, there has been a long-standing debate: do external signals (cytokines) tell a progenitor what to become (instructive), or do they simply allow cells that have already "decided" to survive and multiply (permissive)?

Methods

The authors built a sophisticated methodological pipeline to observe these dynamics in primary human Megakaryocytic-Erythroid Progenitors (MEPs):

  • Stabilization: To track non-adherent cells in 3D space without them drifting out of focus, they developed a "collagen sandwich" technique, restricting cell movement to a thin 30 µm z-plane.
  • Phototoxicity Management: Imaging primary cells every 10 minutes for a week usually kills them. The team optimized a "low-exposure" start (imaging every 2 hours for the first 60 hours) before ramping up to high-frequency imaging once the colonies were established.
  • In Situ Staining: Instead of fixing and killing cells to identify them, they added fluorescently conjugated antibodies (CD41, CD71, CD235a) directly to the live culture.
  • Computational Tracking: They used the Baxter algorithm for automated cell segmentation and lineage tracing, allowing them to build family trees for thousands of cells.
  • Mathematical Modeling: They applied a nonhomogeneous Markov probabilistic model to predict division outcomes (expansion vs. exhaustion) across generations.

Datasets

The study utilized primary human hematopoietic cells:

  • Source: CD34+ enriched cells from G-CSF mobilized peripheral blood from healthy donors.
  • Validation: Results were compared against "ground truth" sorted populations of committed progenitors (MkPs and ErPs) to ensure the tracking algorithm correctly identified cell states based on behavior and markers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MEPs are capable of self-renewal: For the first time, the data shows that human MEPs can undergo symmetric self-renewal for up to 13 generations before exhausting.
  • Behavior as a Phenotype: The researchers found that cell motility is a reliable predictor of cell fate. Megakaryocyte progenitors (MkPs) are significantly more motile and "active" than Erythroid progenitors (ErPs), which tend to stay stationary in tight clusters.
  • The "Permissive" Nature of TPO/EPO: Perhaps the most significant finding is that removing Thrombopoietin (TPO) or Erythropoietin (EPO) didn't change the ratio of red blood cell colonies to platelet colonies. It just made all colonies smaller and increased cell death. This strongly suggests these cytokines are survival/proliferation factors, not fate-instruction manuals.
  • Skewed Output: MEPs naturally produce twice as many erythroid-destined daughters as megakaryocytic ones, and those erythroid cells divide much faster, explaining why red blood cells vastly outnumber platelets in our blood.

Key Results

  • Division Rates: MEPs divide roughly every 15.8 hours. Once committed, Erythroid cells speed up (10.2 hours), while Megakaryocytic cells slow down significantly (35.7 hours) as they prepare for endomitosis (growing large without dividing).
  • Lineage Commitment: In control conditions, the frequency of MEP-generating progeny giving rise to E- vs. Mk-committed cells is approximately 2:1.
  • Cytokine Impact: In the absence of TPO or EPO, total colony counts dropped by ~20%, and colony size was significantly stunted, yet the fundamental "decision-making" probabilities remained consistent with the Markov model.

Limitations and Future Work

While this study provides a high-resolution look at in vitro behavior, the authors acknowledge that a plastic dish with a few cytokines cannot fully replicate the complex bone marrow microenvironment.

Future work could involve:

  1. Complex Cues: Testing more diverse combinations of cytokines or niche-mimicking scaffolds to see if other external factors are instructive.
  2. Spatial Transcriptomics: Linking these live-imaging family trees with end-point single-cell RNA sequencing to map behavioral "family history" to gene expression.
  3. Disease Models: Applying this pipeline to blood cancers (like myeloproliferative neoplasms) to see how kinetics go haywire during malignancy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Single-cell assays have enriched our understanding of hematopoiesis and, more generally, stem and progenitor cell biology. However, these single-end-point approaches provide only a static snapshot of the state of a cell. To observe and measure dynamic changes that may instruct cell fate, we developed an approach for examining hematopoietic progenitor fate specification using long-term (> 7-day) single-cell time-lapse imaging for up to 13 generations with in situ fluorescence staining of primary human hematopoietic progenitors followed by algorithm-assisted lineage tracing. We analyzed progenitor cell dynamics, including the division rate, velocity, viability, and probability of lineage commitment at the single-cell level over time. We applied a Markov probabilistic model to predict progenitor division outcome over each generation in culture. We demonstrated the utility of this methodological pipeline by evaluating the effects of the cytokines thrombopoietin and erythropoietin on the dynamics of self-renewal and lineage specification in primary human bipotent megakaryocytic-erythroid progenitors (MEPs). Our data support the hypothesis that thrombopoietin and erythropoietin support the viability and self-renewal of MEPs, but do not affect fate specification. Thus, single-cell tracking of time-lapse imaged colony-forming unit assays provides a robust method for assessing the dynamics of progenitor self-renewal and lineage commitment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{scanlon2022multiparameter,
  author = {Vanessa Scanlon and Evrett N. Thompson and Betty R. Lawton and Maria P. Kochugaeva and Kevinminh Ta and Madeline Y. Mayday and Juliana Xavier-Ferrucio and Elaine Kang and Nicole M. Eskow and Yi-Chien Lu and Nayoung Kwon and Anisha Laumas and Matthew Cenci and Kalyani Lawrence and Katie Barden and Shannon T. Larsuel and Fiona Reed and Gabriela Pena Carmona and Ashley Ubbelohde and June P. Lee and Shakthi Boobalan and Yvette Oppong and Rachel Anderson and Colby Maynard and Kaylie Sahirul and Callista Lajeune and Varsha Ivathraya and Tiffany Addy and Patricia Sanchez and Colin Holbrook and Andrew Tri Van Ho and James S. Duncan and Helen M. Blau and Andre Levchenko and Diane S. Krause},
  title = {{Multiparameter analysis of timelapse imaging reveals kinetics of megakaryocytic erythroid progenitor clonal expansion and differentiation}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-19013-x},
}
Figure