Multipanel Limited Angle PET System With 50 ps FWHM Coincidence Time Resolution: A Simulation Study

Gašper Razdevšek, R. Dolenec, P. Križan, Stan Majewski, Andrej Studen, S. Korpar, Georges El Fakhri, R. PestotnikIEEE Transactions on Radiation and Plasma Medical Sciences 2021 · DOI

Abstract

In this simulation study, we evaluate the performance of a limited angular coverage PET system consisting of two/four fast-timing 50 ps FWHM CTR flat-panel detectors made of 5–20 mm long pixelated lutetium oxyorthosilicate crystals. We studied image quality and count rates following the National Electrical Manufacturers Association standard, spatial resolution by imaging a Derenzo phantom and a hot rod, and investigated the sensitivity of different scanner designs. We demonstrated the possible use of such a scanner by imaging a human head and a torso of the extended cardiac-torso (XCAT) digital phantom. All the designs were compared to the reference scanner, based on Siemens Biograph Vision PET/CT scanner geometry. We show that good coincidence timing resolution (CTR) can compensate for lower detection efficiency or smaller angular coverage. Good image quality can be obtained with a simple limited-angle PET system without distortions or artefacts. Substantial degradation of the spatial resolution with increased crystal length is observed in the two-panel design due to the parallax error, but not in the four-panel design. The four-panel design simulated with a CTR of 50 ps FWHM is comparable to that of the current state-of-the-art clinical PET/CT scanner. Similar fast-timing limited-angle planar detectors could enable much less expensive total-body or single organ (dynamically selectable) imaging devices.

Introduction

Standard Positron Emission Tomography (PET) scanners are typically full-ring systems designed to capture gamma rays from a complete 360-degree angular range. While effective, these systems are bulky and expensive. Simplifying the design by using limited angular coverage—such as two parallel flat panels—traditionally results in severe image distortions and artifacts due to missing projection data.

However, the advent of ultra-fast Time-of-Flight (TOF) PET offers a potential solution. By measuring the precise difference in arrival time between two coincidence photons, the emission point can be localized along a line-of-response (LOR). This study investigates whether a Coincidence Time Resolution (CTR) of 50 ps—a current benchmark for next-generation scintillators—can effectively compensate for missing angular data, making limited-angle systems clinically viable.

Methods and Materials

The researchers utilized the GATE (Geant4 Application for Tomographic Emission) toolkit for comprehensive Monte Carlo simulations.

Scanner Geometries

Two primary limited-angle designs were modeled: a two-panel system consisting of parallel plates and a four-panel system arranged in an orthogonal box configuration. These were compared against a simulated Siemens Biograph Vision, representing current state-of-the-art clinical full-ring PET/CT technology.

Schematic representation of the two-panel (left) and four-panel (right) limited-angle PET scanner geometries evaluated in the study.

Detector Specifications

The panels utilized LSO (lutetium oxyorthosilicate) crystals with 3 × 3 mm² pixels. Crystal lengths were varied from 5 mm to 20 mm to study the impact on sensitivity and parallax error. Timing resolutions were tested from 200 ps down to the target 50 ps FWHM. Images were reconstructed using the MLEM algorithm via the CASToR platform.

Evaluation Phantoms

Performance was quantified using several digital phantoms to assess different imaging characteristics:

  • Derenzo Phantom: For spatial resolution analysis.
  • NEMA NU 2-2018 Phantom: For measuring contrast recovery and background variability.
  • XCAT Phantom: For testing clinical feasibility using detailed anatomical models of the human head and torso.
Digital phantoms used for performance evaluation: a torso-like phantom with hot spheres (left) and a Derenzo-style rod phantom for spatial resolution testing (right).

Key Results and Discussion

Timing as a Substitute for Geometry

The study confirms that 50 ps timing resolution acts as a mathematical substitute for missing angular data. In a two-panel system, this ultra-fast timing effectively "fills in" the gaps that would otherwise cause blurring and streaking artifacts.

Parallax and Crystal Length

A critical finding involved the trade-off between sensitivity and resolution. In two-panel systems, increasing crystal length to 20 mm (to improve sensitivity) caused spatial resolution to degrade from ~3 mm to ~8 mm due to parallax errors. Conversely, the four-panel system almost entirely mitigated this degradation, maintaining a stable resolution of ~3–4 mm regardless of crystal length.

Clinical Parity

The four-panel "box" configuration emerged as the optimal design, providing homogeneous resolution across the field of view. With 50 ps timing, this system achieved an MSSIM (Structural Similarity Index) of 0.626 for head imaging, outperforming the reference clinical scanner's 0.576. This suggests that a four-panel system with superior timing can match or exceed the performance of a full-ring scanner while using significantly less detector material.

Conclusion and Future Work

This simulation study demonstrates that 50 ps CTR enables high-quality PET imaging using simplified, limited-angle geometries. Such designs could lead to the development of more affordable, portable, or organ-specific imaging devices.

Future research will need to address real-world factors not included in this idealized simulation, such as positron range and gamma non-collinearity. Additionally, implementing Depth-of-Interaction (DOI) information and scaling ultra-fast timing electronics to thousands of channels remain key engineering challenges for translating these findings into clinical hardware.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this simulation study, we evaluate the performance of a limited angular coverage PET system consisting of two/four fast-timing 50 ps FWHM CTR flat-panel detectors made of 5–20 mm long pixelated lutetium oxyorthosilicate crystals. We studied image quality and count rates following the National Electrical Manufacturers Association standard, spatial resolution by imaging a Derenzo phantom and a hot rod, and investigated the sensitivity of different scanner designs. We demonstrated the possible use of such a scanner by imaging a human head and a torso of the extended cardiac-torso (XCAT) digital phantom. All the designs were compared to the reference scanner, based on Siemens Biograph Vision PET/CT scanner geometry. We show that good coincidence timing resolution (CTR) can compensate for lower detection efficiency or smaller angular coverage. Good image quality can be obtained with a simple limited-angle PET system without distortions or artefacts. Substantial degradation of the spatial resolution with increased crystal length is observed in the two-panel design due to the parallax error, but not in the four-panel design. The four-panel design simulated with a CTR of 50 ps FWHM is comparable to that of the current state-of-the-art clinical PET/CT scanner. Similar fast-timing limited-angle planar detectors could enable much less expensive total-body or single organ (dynamically selectable) imaging devices.
BibTeX
@article{razdevsek2021multipanel,
  author = {Gašper Razdevšek and R. Dolenec and P. Križan and Stan Majewski and Andrej Studen and S. Korpar and Georges El Fakhri and R. Pestotnik},
  title = {{Multipanel Limited Angle PET System With 50 ps FWHM Coincidence Time Resolution: A Simulation Study}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Radiation and Plasma Medical Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/trpms.2021.3115704},
}
Figure