Multimodal dynamic and unclonable anti-counterfeiting using robust diamond microparticles on heterogeneous substrate

Tongtong Zhang, Lingzhi Wang, Jing Wang, Zhongqiang Wang, Madhav Gupta, Xuyun Guo, Ye Zhu, Yau Chuen Yiu, Tony K. C. Hui, Yan Zhou, Can Li, Dangyuan Lei, Kwai Hei Li, Xinqiang Wang, Qi Wang, Lei Shao, Zhiqin ChuNature Communications 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The growing prevalence of counterfeit products worldwide poses serious threats to economic security and human health. Developing advanced anti-counterfeiting materials with physical unclonable functions (PUFs) offers an attractive defense strategy. Here, we report multimodal, dynamic and unclonable anti-counterfeiting labels based on diamond microparticles containing silicon-vacancy centers. These chaotic microparticles are heterogeneously grown on silicon substrate by chemical vapor deposition (CVD), facilitating low-cost scalable fabrication. The intrinsically unclonable functions are introduced by the randomized features of each particle. The highly stable signals of photoluminescence from silicon-vacancy centers and light scattering from diamond microparticles can enable high-capacity optical encoding. Moreover, time-dependent encoding is achieved by modulating photoluminescence signals of silicon-vacancy centers via air oxidation. Exploiting the robustness of diamond, the developed labels exhibit ultrahigh stability in extreme application scenarios, including harsh chemical environments, high temperature, mechanical abrasion, and ultraviolet irradiation. Hence, our proposed system can be practically applied immediately as anti-counterfeiting labels in diverse fields.

Introduction

Counterfeiting is a multi-billion dollar global crisis affecting industries ranging from luxury goods to life-saving pharmaceuticals. Traditional security features, such as QR codes and holograms, are deterministic and can be replicated by sophisticated counterfeiters. Physical Unclonable Functions (PUFs) address this by utilizing microscopic, random variations introduced during manufacturing that are impossible to replicate—even by the original manufacturer. However, existing PUFs based on polymers or dyes are often fragile and offer limited encoding capacity. This research introduces a diamond-based PUF that is both high-capacity and exceptionally robust.

Fabrication and Material Characterization

The fabrication process utilizes Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) to grow diamond microparticles on a silicon substrate. The process begins with the non-deterministic spin-coating of nanodiamond seeds onto a silicon wafer. During the subsequent CVD growth, the silicon substrate acts as an in-situ dopant source. Silicon atoms enter the diamond lattice to create Silicon-Vacancy (SiV) centers—atomic-scale defects that exhibit photoluminescence (PL) when excited by a laser.

Elemental mapping of a diamond microparticle showing the distribution of Carbon (green) and Silicon (red), confirming the in-situ doping of SiV centers.

This "two birds with one stone" approach—using the substrate as both the growth platform and the dopant source—simplifies manufacturing and ensures scalability. The resulting microparticles possess unique, random facets and positions that form the basis of the physical fingerprint.

Multimodal and Dynamic Encoding Architecture

The security system leverages two distinct optical signals to exponentially increase encoding capacity:

  1. Static Scattering (Low Level): The unique physical distribution and facets of the diamond particles scatter light in a random pattern, which can be captured via simple optical imaging.
  2. Photoluminescence (High Level): The intensity of the glow from SiV centers varies based on local defect concentrations, providing a second layer of complex data.
Overview of the diamond-PUF system, illustrating the fabrication workflow and the hierarchy of static and dynamic encoding levels.

A standout feature of this system is Dynamic Modulation. By heating the labels in air (air oxidation), the researchers can selectively tune the PL intensity of the SiV centers without altering the physical shape of the diamonds. This allows the security key to be "refreshed" or updated over time, moving the PUF from a static fingerprint to a dynamic security system.

Security Performance and Robustness

The diamond-PUF labels demonstrate near-ideal security metrics. They achieved a normalized Hamming distance of approximately 0.5000, indicating that any two labels are completely distinct and unpredictable. Furthermore, the uniformity of the generated keys was measured at 0.4996, showing an almost perfect distribution of bits.

Owing to the inherent properties of diamond, these tags are nearly indestructible. They maintained signal integrity (less than 1.19% deviation) after two hours of continuous laser irradiation and survived extreme conditions, including boiling in strong acids (HCl, NaOH), heating to 400°C, and heavy mechanical abrasion. With an estimated fabrication cost of just $0.0001 USD per label, the system is highly viable for mass-market applications.

Conclusion

This work presents a robust, high-capacity, and dynamic anti-counterfeiting solution. While current high-level PL readout requires specialized equipment like confocal microscopes, the low-level scattering patterns can already be authenticated using smartphone-compatible tools. Future developments focusing on deep learning-based automated authentication and transfer methods for diverse surfaces will further enhance the practical utility of these diamond-based security labels.

Summary updated

Abstract

The growing prevalence of counterfeit products worldwide poses serious threats to economic security and human health. Developing advanced anti-counterfeiting materials with physical unclonable functions offers an attractive defense strategy. Here, we report multimodal, dynamic and unclonable anti-counterfeiting labels based on diamond microparticles containing silicon-vacancy centers. These chaotic microparticles are heterogeneously grown on silicon substrate by chemical vapor deposition, facilitating low-cost scalable fabrication. The intrinsically unclonable functions are introduced by the randomized features of each particle. The highly stable signals of photoluminescence from silicon-vacancy centers and light scattering from diamond microparticles can enable high-capacity optical encoding. Moreover, time-dependent encoding is achieved by modulating photoluminescence signals of silicon-vacancy centers via air oxidation. Exploiting the robustness of diamond, the developed labels exhibit ultrahigh stability in extreme application scenarios, including harsh chemical environments, high temperature, mechanical abrasion, and ultraviolet irradiation. Hence, our proposed system can be practically applied immediately as anti-counterfeiting labels in diverse fields.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023multimodal,
  author = {Tongtong Zhang and Lingzhi Wang and Jing Wang and Zhongqiang Wang and Madhav Gupta and Xuyun Guo and Ye Zhu and Yau Chuen Yiu and Tony K. C. Hui and Yan Zhou and Can Li and Dangyuan Lei and Kwai Hei Li and Xinqiang Wang and Qi Wang and Lei Shao and Zhiqin Chu},
  title = {{Multimodal dynamic and unclonable anti-counterfeiting using robust diamond microparticles on heterogeneous substrate}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-38178-1},
}
Figure