Multifocal skull-compensated transcranial focused ultrasound system for neuromodulation applications based on acoustic holography

Geon Kook, Yehhyun Jo, Chaerin Oh, Xiaojia Liang, Jae-Won Kim, Sang Mok Lee, Subeen Kim, Jung‐Woo Choi, Hyunjoo J. LeeMicrosystems 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel, ultra-lightweight (0.75g) transcranial focused ultrasound (TFUS) system for precise neuromodulation in freely moving mice. By integrating a 3D-printed acoustic lens with a MEMS transducer and employing acoustic holography for skull aberration compensation, the system achieves accurate multifocal targeting, paving the way for advanced preclinical behavioral studies of brain disorders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Transcranial focused ultrasound (TFUS) holds immense promise for non-invasively modulating brain activity for therapeutic purposes. However, a significant hurdle is the skull, which distorts and scatters ultrasound waves, leading to inaccurate targeting of specific brain regions. This "skull aberration" is particularly problematic for high-frequency ultrasound needed for precise stimulation. Furthermore, existing preclinical systems are often bulky, complex, or lack the necessary skull compensation, hindering their use in behavioral studies with freely moving animals. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a compact, skull-compensated TFUS system capable of accurate, multifocal neuromodulation for preclinical research.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the combination of several key techniques:

  • Skull Aberration Compensation via Acoustic Holography: The system utilizes a time-reversal recording approach combined with a phase conjugation mirror principle. This involves simulating ultrasound propagation through a skull model to record the aberrated wavefront. This recorded phase information is then used to design an acoustic lens that reconstructs the original, un-aberrated wavefront, effectively compensating for skull distortion.
  • 3D-Printed Acoustic Lens: A miniature acoustic lens is fabricated using stereolithography (SLA) 3D printing. This lens is designed to manipulate the ultrasound wavefront based on the calculated phase map, allowing for precise focusing. The 3D printing approach enables the creation of complex microscale structures with high spatial resolution.
  • MEMS Transducer (CMUT): A capacitive micromachined ultrasound transducer (CMUT) is employed as the ultrasound source. CMUTs are chosen for their miniaturization capabilities, standalone operation without bulky housing, and ability to be fabricated using wafer-scale processes. This contributes significantly to the system's lightweight design.
  • System Integration and Miniaturization: The CMUT and the 3D-printed acoustic lens are integrated into a single, lightweight package (0.75g) using silicone elastomer and a custom PCB. This miniaturization is crucial for enabling behavioral studies in freely moving mice without significantly impacting their movement.
  • In Vivo Characterization: The system's performance is validated in freely moving mice. This involves surgical implantation of the device, followed by behavioral analysis using DeepLabCut for pose estimation to assess locomotion and overall activity.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed in the paper as distinct datasets for training. However, the authors utilized:

  • 3D models of skulls from X-ray computerized tomography (CT) imaging: These were used to create skull phantoms for simulation and acoustic characterization of the lens.
  • Animal behavior data: Collected from freely moving mice in an open-field test, analyzed using DeepLabCut.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Acoustic Holography for Skull Compensation is Feasible at High Frequencies: The paper demonstrates that acoustic holography, specifically using time-reversal principles, can effectively compensate for skull aberrations even at 5 MHz, a frequency critical for precise neuromodulation in small animals.
  • 3D Printing Enables Complex Acoustic Lens Design: The ability to 3D print intricate acoustic lenses with microscale features is key to achieving fine phase modulation and skull aberration correction with a single-channel transducer.
  • MEMS Transducers are Ideal for Wearable Neuromodulation: The use of CMUTs significantly reduces the system's weight and size, making it suitable for chronic implantation and behavioral studies in small animals without hindering their natural movements.
  • Multifocal Targeting is Achievable with a Single Transducer: The system's design allows for the generation of multiple focal points by configuring the simulation and lens design, enabling simultaneous stimulation of different brain regions. This is a significant advantage over traditional phased array systems.
  • Minimal Impact on Animal Behavior: The ultra-lightweight design (0.75g) ensures that the attached device does not significantly alter the mice's natural behavior, a critical requirement for valid behavioral studies.

Key Results

  • Skull-Compensated Acoustic Lens: The fabricated acoustic lens successfully focused ultrasound through a skull phantom, producing a clear focal spot, whereas a standard Fresnel lens showed significant aberration.
  • Multifocal Capability: The system demonstrated the ability to generate two distinct focal points by designing the acoustic lens based on simulated multifocal time-reversal recording.
  • Lightweight System: The integrated neuromodulation system weighed only 0.75g, significantly lighter than commercial PUTs.
  • No Significant Behavioral Impact: In vivo characterization showed no statistically significant changes in mouse speed or cumulative travel distance due to the device's weight.
  • Sufficient Acoustic Pressure: The system achieved a peak pressure amplitude of 44.6 kPa, deemed sufficient for neuromodulation applications.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Acoustic Pressure Amplitude: The current system's acoustic pressure might not be high enough for applications requiring higher pressures, such as blood-brain-barrier opening. Future work could explore alternative acoustic lens materials with better impedance matching to the CMUT.
  • Focal Resolution: The axial focal size (3 mm at 2 MHz) is not small enough for targeting very small brain subregions. Improving focal resolution would require increasing the CMUT aperture size or developing CMUTs with higher resonance frequencies (e.g., 5 MHz).
  • Tethering: The current system requires a wired connection for power, limiting experiments like running wheel studies. Future work could involve integrating wireless driving circuits.
  • Lens Steering: The current system's lens is fixed after surgery. While different lenses can be used for different targets during surgery, post-operative steering is not possible.
  • Scalp Incision: A scalp incision was necessary for implantation. Future research aims to develop targeting methods that do not require skull referencing and potentially leverage fMRI for guidance.
  • Material Optimization: Further investigation into optimized material pairs for the acoustic lens is needed to minimize reflections at interfaces.
  • Frequency Expansion: The system can be readily adapted to different ultrasound frequencies by designing CMUTs with appropriate resonance frequencies.
  • Skull Properties: More detailed measurements of mouse skull properties across different ages are needed for more precise in vivo simulations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Transcranial focused ultrasound stimulation is a promising therapeutic modality for human brain disorders because of its noninvasiveness, long penetration depth, and versatile spatial control capability through beamforming and beam steering. However, the skull presents a major hurdle for successful applications of ultrasound stimulation. Specifically, skull-induced focal aberration limits the capability for accurate and versatile targeting of brain subregions. In addition, there lacks a fully functional preclinical neuromodulation system suitable to conduct behavioral studies. Here, we report a miniature ultrasound system for neuromodulation applications that is capable of highly accurate multiregion targeting based on acoustic holography. Our work includes the design and implementation of an acoustic lens for targeting brain regions with compensation for skull aberration through time-reversal recording and a phase conjugation mirror. Moreover, we utilize MEMS and 3D-printing technology to implement a 0.75-g lightweight neuromodulation system and present in vivo characterization of the packaged system in freely moving mice. This preclinical system is capable of accurately targeting the desired individual or multitude of brain regions, which will enable versatile and explorative behavior studies using ultrasound neuromodulation to facilitate widespread clinical adoption.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kook2023multifocal,
  author = {Geon Kook and Yehhyun Jo and Chaerin Oh and Xiaojia Liang and Jae-Won Kim and Sang Mok Lee and Subeen Kim and Jung‐Woo Choi and Hyunjoo J. Lee},
  title = {{Multifocal skull-compensated transcranial focused ultrasound system for neuromodulation applications based on acoustic holography}},
  booktitle = {Microsystems},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41378-023-00513-3},
}
Figure