Multifield consequences for D-brane inflation

Mafalda Dias, Jonathan Frazer, Andrew R. LiddleJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2012 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We analyze the multifield behavior in D-brane inflation when contributions from the bulk are taken into account. By studying a large number of potential realizations, we find that the inflationary trajectory is remarkably consistent: inflation is canonical and occurs in the vicinity of an inflection point. However, the resulting spectral index is typically blue and the running positive, putting the model under moderate pressure from WMAP7 constraints. Furthermore, the persistence of isocurvature perturbations renders the model technically unpredictive without a detailed description of reheating.

The Problem: Inflation in a Crowded Room

Most textbook models of inflation involve a single scalar field (the inflaton) rolling down a potential hill. However, high-energy theories like string theory naturally provide a "crowded room" of many fields. In D-brane inflation, our universe is modeled as a D3-brane moving through a higher-dimensional "warped throat" toward an anti-D3-brane.

This motion involves six degrees of freedom—one radial and five angular coordinates—and the potential energy is influenced by random contributions from the "bulk" (the rest of the string geometry). Previous studies often simplified this to a single field, but this paper investigates what happens to cosmological predictions when we account for the full multifield dynamics and the randomness of the string theory landscape.

Schematic of the D-brane inflation model within a warped throat geometry, showing the D-brane moving toward the anti-D-brane.

Methodology: Simulating the Landscape

The authors employ a combination of numerical simulations and analytical approximations to explore this complex landscape:

  • Random Potential Realizations: They generate a large sample of potentials using random "Wilson coefficients" to represent different possible string theory configurations.
  • Transport Method: To calculate observables, they use "transport equations" to evolve the correlation functions of field perturbations from horizon exit to the end of inflation. This was extended to handle "non-slow-roll" regimes where fields accelerate rapidly.
  • Curved Field-Space: In a significant update, they incorporate the actual curved geometry of the warped throat (Klebanov-Witten metric) and use quantum transport to set initial conditions.

Key Insights and Observational Tension

Despite the complexity of the potential, inflation almost always occurs near an "inflection point"—a relatively flat region. This makes the dynamics surprisingly consistent across different random setups. However, this consistency leads to several observational challenges:

  1. The "Blue" Problem: Most realizations produce a "blue" spectral index ($n_s > 1$), meaning there is more power on small scales. This is in tension with CMB data (like WMAP7), which shows a "red" tilt ($n_s \approx 0.96$).
  2. Small Tensors: The tensor-to-scalar ratio ($r$) is extremely small ($r < 10^{-5}$), making primordial gravitational waves from this model likely unobservable.
  3. Non-Gaussianity: The local $f_{NL}$ is generally very small, though approximately 0.5% of cases produced potentially observable signals.

The Predictivity Crisis

A major finding is the persistence of "isocurvature" modes—perturbations that do not change the local density but can later convert into adiabatic perturbations. Because these modes persist until the end of inflation, the final state of the universe depends heavily on the unknown physics of "reheating" (when the branes collide). This renders the model technically "unpredictive" without a specific theory of that collision, a problem likely shared by many multifield models involving inflection points.

Conclusion

While D-brane inflation provides a robust mechanism for inflation within string theory, the multifield effects introduce significant observational and theoretical hurdles. The tension with the observed spectral index and the reliance on reheating physics suggest that further refinements—perhaps involving the non-linear physics of brane-antibrane collisions—are necessary to reconcile the model with our observed universe.

Summary updated

Abstract

We analyse the multifield behaviour in D-brane inflation when contributions from the bulk are taken into account. For this purpose, we study a large number of realisations of the potential; we find the nature of the inflationary trajectory to be very consistent despite the complex construction. Inflation is always canonical and occurs in the vicinity of an inflection point. Extending the transport method to non-slow-roll and to calculate the running, we obtain distributions for observables. The spectral index is typically blue and the running positive, putting the model under moderate pressure from WMAP7 constraints. The local f_NL and tensor-to-scalar ratio are typically unobservably small, though we find approximately 0.5% of realisations to give observably large local f_NL. Approximating the potential as sum-separable, we are able to give fully analytic explanations for the trends in observed behaviour. Finally we find the model suffers from the persistence of isocurvature perturbations, which can be expected to cause further evolution of adiabatic perturbations after inflation. We argue this is a typical problem for models of multifield inflation involving inflection points and renders models of this type technically unpredictive without a description of reheating.
BibTeX
@article{dias2012multifield,
  author = {Mafalda Dias and Jonathan Frazer and Andrew R. Liddle},
  title = {{Multifield consequences for D-brane inflation}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2012/06/020},
}
Figure