TL;DR
This paper introduces the Faceted Domain Encoder (FDE), a novel approach to create document embeddings that capture multiple facets of meaning, especially for domain-specific texts with limited training data. By leveraging knowledge graphs and a Siamese neural network, FDE learns separate embeddings for different knowledge categories, leading to more nuanced and interpretable document similarity measures.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Traditional document embeddings often struggle with domain-specific language, especially when training data is scarce. They typically produce a single vector per document, making it difficult to understand why two documents are considered similar or to capture different types of relationships (e.g., a doctor searching for documents about similar diseases vs. similar treatment protocols). This limitation hinders effective information retrieval and analysis in specialized fields where nuanced understanding is crucial. The paper aims to address the challenges of limited training data, vocabulary mismatch, and granularity mismatch in domain-specific contexts.
Methods
The core of the Faceted Domain Encoder (FDE) is a supervised learning approach using a Siamese neural network. This architecture processes two documents at a time and learns to predict their similarity. The novelty lies in how it incorporates external domain knowledge through a knowledge graph.
- Knowledge Graph Integration: The paper uses a knowledge graph where nodes represent entities (e.g., diseases, chemicals) and are categorized. These categories represent different "facets" of domain knowledge.
- Faceted Embeddings: Instead of a single embedding vector, FDE learns a separate embedding for each identified category (facet) within a document. These facet-specific embeddings are then concatenated to form the final document representation. This allows for capturing different aspects of a document's content.
- Siamese Network Training: The network is trained to minimize the difference between the cosine distance of document embeddings and their "ground-truth" distance derived from the knowledge graph. This guides the model to align embeddings with the relationships present in the domain knowledge.
- Category Normalization: To prevent certain facets from dominating the overall embedding, the authors propose two normalization strategies:
- Corpus-IDF: Weights categories based on the inverse document frequency of terms within them across the entire corpus.
- Document-TFIDF: Weights categories based on term frequency-inverse document frequency within individual documents, with an additional step to distribute weight from uncategorized words.
Datasets
The paper evaluates its approach on two biomedical Semantic Textual Similarity (STS) benchmarks:
- BIOSSES: Contains 100 sentence pairs from medical articles, scored by domain experts on a scale of 0-4.
- Med-STS: Contains 1,068 sentence pairs from medical records, scored by domain experts on a scale of 0-5.
The authors also mention using a knowledge graph derived from the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) taxonomy, which comprises 29,641 concepts and 271,846 synonyms.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Multifaceted Representation is Key: The paper strongly advocates that a single document embedding is insufficient for capturing the diverse ways documents can be related, especially in specialized domains. Learning separate embeddings for different knowledge categories (facets) is crucial.
- Knowledge Graphs as a Data Augmentation Tool: Leveraging knowledge graphs is shown to be highly effective for learning high-quality domain-specific embeddings, even with very limited training data. This is a significant advantage over methods requiring massive corpora.
- Interpretability through Facets: The faceted approach offers a degree of interpretability. By examining similarity based on specific facets, users can understand why documents are related (e.g., similar disease vs. similar treatment).
- Normalization Matters: The choice of category normalization strategy (corpus-IDF vs. document-TFIDF) can impact performance, suggesting that how facet contributions are weighted is an important hyperparameter.
Key Results
- Competitive Performance with Less Data: The Faceted Domain Encoder (FDE) achieves embedding quality comparable to state-of-the-art models on both BIOSSES and Med-STS benchmarks, while requiring a "tiny fraction" of their training data.
- Outperforming Domain-Agnostic Embeddings: FDE significantly outperforms general-purpose embeddings like fastText and Universal Sentence Encoder on both datasets.
- On Par with Specialized Embeddings: FDE performs on par with or close to specialized biomedical embeddings like BioWordVec and BioSentVec, which are trained on much larger corpora. This highlights FDE's efficiency.
- Normalization Strategy Impact: Corpus-IDF normalization performed better on BIOSSES, while document-TFIDF was better on Med-STS, indicating that the optimal strategy can be dataset-dependent.
Limitations and Future Work
- Reliance on Ground Truth: The current approach is supervised and relies on ground truth data for training. The authors suggest a promising future direction is to develop a semi-supervised approach that removes this reliance, allowing the model to learn and update its training goals while discovering new domain terms independently.
- Knowledge Graph Quality: The performance of FDE is inherently tied to the quality and coverage of the knowledge graph used.
- Computational Cost of Facet Selection: While FDE reduces training data needs, the process of identifying and weighting facets might introduce computational overhead during inference or analysis if not managed efficiently.
Summary updated