Multi-Year Phenotypic Assessment and Genetic Selection in Progeny Trials of Liriodendron Hybrids

Yanghui Fang, Fuhui Liu, Tong Wang, Liang Fang, Jie Guo, Shunde Su, Xiaochou Chen, Libin Zhuang, Jiayu Sun, Daiquan Ye, Zhou Wang, Xuemei WangPlants 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that multi-year phenotypic data from Liriodendron hybrid progeny trials can effectively identify superior hybrids and individuals for improved growth traits, particularly stem volume. The findings provide a strong basis for early selection and genetic improvement of these valuable tree species, crucial for conservation and sustainable forestry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Liriodendron chinense, a rare and endangered tree species native to China, faces significant threats due to habitat destruction. While it exhibits good compatibility with its North American relative, Liriodendron tulipifera, leading to promising interspecific hybrids, there's a need for efficient methods to identify and propagate the best-performing individuals for conservation and commercial use. Traditional breeding programs require long-term evaluation to understand genetic potential and optimize selection strategies. This paper addresses the challenge of how to effectively and efficiently select superior Liriodendron hybrids and individuals for traits like height, diameter, and volume, using data collected over several years in a progeny trial. The goal is to establish a robust framework for genetic improvement and to inform conservation efforts for this valuable genus.

Methods

The researchers established a progeny trial with 29 Liriodendron hybrids (both interspecific and intraspecific) in Fujian Province, China. Over several years (from 2011 to 2025), they meticulously measured key growth traits: tree height (H), diameter at breast height (DBH), and individual stem volume (V). Stem volume was calculated using a specific allometric equation based on H and DBH.

To analyze the data, they employed a linear model for analysis of variance (ANOVA) to detect significant differences among hybrids and their interactions with replication blocks. Crucially, they estimated genetic parameters, including broad-sense heritability ($h_B^2$) and narrow-sense heritability ($h_N^2$), to quantify the genetic control over these traits. The ratio of $h_N^2/h_B^2$ was used to assess the proportion of additive genetic variance, which is key for predicting gains from selection.

Selection strategies were simulated at different intensities (10% and 20% for hybrid selection, and 1% for individual tree selection) to evaluate their effectiveness in identifying elite individuals and predicting genetic gains.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a progeny trial established in 2011, comprising 29 Liriodendron hybrid entries. Phenotypic data for tree height, diameter at breast height, and individual stem volume were collected across multiple years (2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2016, 2024). No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relied on the long-term monitoring of the established trial.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Long-term data is crucial for reliable selection: The study highlights that multi-year data collection is essential for accurately assessing genetic potential and ensuring the stability of hybrid rankings, reducing the influence of random environmental variation.
  • Stem volume is a prime target for selection: Individual stem volume consistently showed the highest phenotypic coefficient of variation, indicating substantial diversity and making it a strong candidate for selection to drive genetic gains.
  • Additive genetic effects dominate: The high ratio of narrow-sense to broad-sense heritability ($h_N^2/h_B^2$) suggests that additive genetic effects are the primary drivers of growth in these hybrids. This is excellent news for breeding, as additive effects are directly heritable and predictable.
  • Early selection is feasible and effective: The study demonstrates that selecting elite hybrids based on early growth data (even from the first few years) can be highly predictive of later performance, especially when stem volume is the criterion.
  • Survival is a key differentiator, more so than early growth: While juvenile growth traits were similar across different hybrid types (intraspecific L. chinense, intraspecific L. tulipifera, and interspecific), survival rates varied significantly, suggesting that "hybrid advantage" might be more pronounced in establishment success and stress tolerance than in accelerated early growth.

Key Results

  • Significant genetic variation: Highly significant differences (p < 0.01) were observed among hybrids for all measured traits across all assessment years, confirming substantial genetic variation.
  • High heritability: Broad-sense heritabilities for growth traits were consistently high (0.4073–0.7253), and narrow-sense heritabilities were also substantial (0.3410–0.6501).
  • Effective hybrid selection: At a 10% selection intensity, hybrids No. 39, No. 59, and No. 74 were identified as elite, with selection based on individual stem volume yielding the highest predictive accuracy and genetic gain (26.54–34.69%).
  • Remarkable individual selection gains: Individual tree selection at a 1% intensity for stem volume resulted in exceptionally high predicted genetic gains, ranging from 95.55% to 107.12%.
  • Hybrid type differences: While growth traits were comparable, L. tulipifera intraspecific hybrids showed significantly lower survival rates (25.46%) compared to L. chinense intraspecific (64.20%) and interspecific hybrids (70.25%) in 2024.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single-site trial: The study was conducted at a single location, limiting the assessment of genotype-by-environment interactions. Future work should incorporate multi-site trials to ensure the broad adaptability and stability of selected hybrids across different environments.
  • Lack of parental controls: The trial did not include co-planted parental controls, preventing a direct quantification of heterosis (mid-parent or better-parent) and transgressive segregation. Future studies should include these for more rigorous evaluation.
  • Juvenile stage focus: The study primarily focused on juvenile growth and survival. Future research should incorporate reproductive fitness measures and longer-term growth assessments to provide a more comprehensive evaluation.
  • Potential bias in individual selection: The authors caution that high predicted gains from individual tree selection (especially at very low intensities like 1%) can be upwardly biased due to small sample sizes and sensitivity to micro-environmental effects. These results should be interpreted cautiously and validated.

The authors suggest that future work should focus on multi-site testing, incorporating parental controls, and evaluating reproductive traits to further refine selection and deployment strategies for improved Liriodendron hybrids.

Summary updated

Abstract

The conservation and genetic improvement of rare and endangered tree species are crucial for sustainable forest management. Liriodendron chinense, a relict species with limited distribution in China, exhibits high cross-compatibility with Liriodendron tulipifera, providing opportunities for interspecific hybrid breeding. In this study, 29 Liriodendron hybrids were established in a progeny trial plantation in Fujian Province, China, and subjected to multi-year evaluation of tree height, diameter at breast height (DBH), and individual stem volume. Significant differences (p &lt; 0.01) among hybrids and hybrid × replicate interactions were detected for all traits across all assessment years, with individual stem volume showing the highest phenotypic coefficient of variation (35.30–40.56%). The mean annual increment in tree height increased during the early years, peaking at 1.50 m in the fourth year. Broad-sense and narrow-sense heritabilities for growth traits were consistently high (0.4073–0.7253 and 0.3410–0.6501, respectively), and the ratio of narrow-sense to broad-sense heritability ranged from 0.64 to 0.99, supporting the feasibility of early hybrid and individual selection. At a 10% selection intensity, hybrids No. 39, No. 59, and No. 74 were identified as elite, with selection based on individual stem volume providing the highest predictive accuracy and genetic gain (26.54–34.69%). Individual selection at a 1% intensity yielded genetic gains of 95.55–107.12% for stem volume. These results demonstrate substantial potential for early and efficient genetic improvement in Liriodendron hybrids, providing a theoretical foundation for the selection and deployment of elite hybrids and individuals in subtropical forest plantations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fang2026multi,
  author = {Yanghui Fang and Fuhui Liu and Tong Wang and Liang Fang and Jie Guo and Shunde Su and Xiaochou Chen and Libin Zhuang and Jiayu Sun and Daiquan Ye and Zhou Wang and Xuemei Wang},
  title = {{Multi-Year Phenotypic Assessment and Genetic Selection in Progeny Trials of Liriodendron Hybrids}},
  booktitle = {Plants},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.3390/plants15040638},
}
Figure