TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel multi-view framework for cross-lingual structured prediction that leverages a small amount of labeled target data to effectively combine multiple source language models. By treating an aggregated source view and a target task-specific view as complementary, the framework dynamically learns the confidence of each source model, leading to significant improvements over existing methods, even those with more resources.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Structured prediction tasks, like sequence labeling or dependency parsing, typically require large amounts of labeled data, which are expensive and time-consuming to obtain, especially for low-resource languages. Cross-lingual transfer learning offers a solution by transferring knowledge from high-resource languages. However, simply aggregating predictions from multiple source models can be detrimental if some source languages are not similar to the target language. Existing methods often rely on heuristic similarity measures or struggle to dynamically adjust the influence of different source models, leading to suboptimal performance. This paper addresses the challenge of effectively leveraging multiple source models for cross-lingual structured prediction when only a small amount of labeled target data is available.
Methods
The core of this work is a multi-view framework that creates two complementary "views" of the data:
- Aggregated Source View: This view combines predictions from multiple pre-trained source language models. The authors propose three novel, coarse-to-fine aggregation strategies:
- Language-level Aggregation: A simple approach where source models are weighted uniformly.
- Sentence-level Aggregation: Uses an attention mechanism to learn sentence-specific weights for each source model, allowing for dynamic weighting based on sentence content.
- Sub-structure-level Aggregation: The most fine-grained approach, employing attention to weigh source models at the token or sub-structure level, enabling highly dynamic adaptation.
- Target View: This is a task-specific model trained directly on the target language data. The authors use mBERT as the sentence encoder for this view.
The framework encourages interaction between these two views using a KL-divergence loss to promote similarity. The overall training objective balances supervised cross-entropy losses for labeled data with the KL-divergence loss for both labeled and unlabeled data, allowing the model to learn from all available resources.
Datasets
The experiments were conducted on several standard datasets for three structured prediction tasks:
- Named Entity Recognition (NER): CONLL02 and CONLL03 datasets.
- Part-of-Speech (POS) Tagging: Datasets from Universal Dependencies Treebanks (v2.2).
- Dependency Parsing: Datasets from Universal Dependencies Treebanks (v2.2).
The evaluation was performed in a leave-one-out setting, where one language was held out as the target, and the remaining languages served as sources. For training, a small set of fifty labeled sentences was used, along with varying amounts of unlabeled target data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Multi-view learning is crucial: Treating the aggregated source knowledge and the target-specific model as distinct but interacting views allows for a better trade-off between leveraging existing knowledge and adapting to the target language.
- Fine-grained aggregation matters: The sub-structure-level aggregation strategy proved most effective, demonstrating that dynamically weighing source models at a granular level is key to handling diverse source language quality.
- Small labeled data is powerful: Even a small set of labeled target data can be highly effective in guiding the aggregation process and improving both the source and target views.
- The "best" source model is context-dependent: No single source model consistently performs best across all languages or even all sub-structures within a sentence, highlighting the need for dynamic weighting.
Key Results
The proposed multi-view framework, particularly the sub-structure-level aggregation approach (Ours-sub), achieved state-of-the-art performance across all three structured prediction tasks and multiple languages. For instance, on dependency parsing, Ours-sub significantly outperformed strong baselines like KD (Knowledge Distillation) and UMM (Unified Multilingual Model), even when those baselines had access to more source language training data. The paper also shows that the framework is robust to the randomness in selecting labeled data.
Limitations and Future Work
- Hyperparameter sensitivity: While the paper tunes hyperparameters, the performance might still be sensitive to their exact values.
- Computational cost: The multi-view framework, especially with fine-grained aggregation, can be computationally intensive.
- Future work: The authors suggest exploring more sophisticated ways to model the relationships between the two views and investigating the framework's applicability to other cross-lingual tasks. They also highlight the potential of their approach for scenarios with extremely low-resource languages where even fifty labeled sentences might be unavailable.
Summary updated