Multi-scale stochastic organization-oriented coarse-graining exemplified on the human mitotic checkpoint

Richard Henze, Mu Chun-yan, Mate Puljiz, Nishanthan Kamaleson, Jan Huwald, John Haslegrave, Pietro Speroni di Fenizio, David Parker, Chris Good, Jonathan E. Rowe, Bashar Ibrahim, Peter DittrichScientific 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel framework for multi-scale coarse-graining of complex biological systems, exemplified by the human mitotic spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC). By combining manual and automated techniques, they demonstrate how to systematically reduce the complexity of a detailed molecular model to simpler, computationally tractable versions while preserving essential biological behavior, enabling deeper understanding and analysis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biological systems are incredibly complex, with vast numbers of interacting molecules. Simulating these systems at a fine-grained level is computationally prohibitive, yet overly simplified models can miss crucial details. This creates a challenge for understanding and analyzing these systems: how can we build models that are both accurate enough to capture biological reality and simple enough to be analyzed and understood? The authors tackle this by developing and demonstrating a hierarchical approach to coarse-graining, where progressively simpler models are derived from a detailed one, with clear links between each level. This allows for a multi-model approach that balances accuracy and tractability, crucial for gaining insights into complex biological processes like the SAC, which ensures genomic integrity during cell division.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in its multi-faceted approach to coarse-graining. They start with a detailed 3D spatial stochastic simulation model (using ReaDDy) of the human mitotic spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC). From this, they derive a series of progressively coarser models using a combination of methods:

  • Manual Coarse-Graining: This involves expert knowledge to simplify the model, focusing on preserving specific biological functions, like the checkpoint behavior.
  • Aggregation Analysis: This method is used to systematically reduce the number of species and reactions by grouping similar components.
  • Organization-Oriented Techniques (Chemical Organization Theory - COT): This novel approach identifies "organizations" – closed and self-maintaining sets of molecular species that can coexist stably. By analyzing the lattice of these organizations, they can identify and preserve the most biologically relevant ones during coarse-graining.
  • Discrete State-Transition Simulation (using PRISM): For the coarsest models, they employ probabilistic model checking to analyze discrete state-transition systems, allowing for exact probability calculations and formal verification.

This combination allows them to move from a model with 14 species and 21 reactions down to one with just 4 species and 3 reactions, while maintaining the core functionality of the SAC.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The models are built from established biological knowledge and reaction networks, and the "datasets" are the simulation outputs generated by the models themselves.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hierarchical Coarse-Graining is Powerful: The paper strongly advocates for a systematic, multi-level approach to coarse-graining. By linking different levels of abstraction, they show how to maintain interpretability and parameter consistency across models.
  • Chemical Organization Theory (COT) as a Guiding Principle: COT proves to be a valuable tool for identifying "meaningful" behaviors and simplifying models by focusing on stable sets of interacting molecules (organizations). This helps to prune away less relevant dynamics.
  • Space is Not Always Critical for SAC Function: For the SAC, the authors found that global communication between kinetochores is more important than precise spatial localization. This suggests that spatial models can be simplified to non-spatial or compartmentalized ones without losing essential behavior.
  • Bridging Model Classes: The framework successfully bridges different modeling paradigms, from detailed particle-based simulations to abstract state-transition models, demonstrating the flexibility of their approach.
  • Domain Knowledge Integration: The paper highlights the importance of integrating expert biological knowledge (manual coarse-graining) with automated methods for effective model reduction.

Key Results

  • Model Reduction: They successfully reduced a complex 14-species, 21-reaction model of the human mitotic spindle assembly checkpoint (SAC) to a 4-species, 3-reaction model.
  • Preservation of Behavior: Despite significant simplification, the coarser models accurately reproduced the essential switching behavior of the SAC, demonstrating the effectiveness of the coarse-graining methods.
  • Identification of Key Organizations: Through COT, they identified specific sets of molecular species (organizations) that represent critical states and transitions within the SAC, providing deeper insights into its dynamics.
  • Computational Efficiency: The coarser models are significantly more computationally efficient, allowing for simulations that run in seconds or minutes, compared to days for the full model. This enables faster analysis and exploration of parameter spaces.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Automation of Spatial Coarse-Graining: While the paper touches on spatial organization, the authors suggest that developing a more automated framework for spatial organization-oriented coarse-graining is a promising future direction.
  • Formalizing Domain Knowledge: The paper notes that while domain knowledge is crucial, formalizing it as constraints can be challenging. Future work could focus on developing methods to better integrate and formalize expert knowledge.
  • Semantic Linking of Models: The authors suggest exploring semantic technologies to link different coarse-grained levels, enhancing the interpretability and reusability of models.
  • Generalizability: While demonstrated on the SAC, the full applicability and robustness of this multi-scale coarse-graining framework to other complex biological systems would benefit from further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The complexity of biological models makes methods for their analysis and understanding highly desirable. Here, we demonstrate the orchestration of various novel coarse-graining methods by applying them to the mitotic spindle assembly checkpoint. We begin with a detailed fine-grained spatial model in which individual molecules are simulated moving and reacting in a three-dimensional space. A sequence of manual and automatic coarse-grainings finally leads to the coarsest deterministic and stochastic models containing only four molecular species and four states for each kinetochore, respectively. We are able to relate each more coarse-grained level to a finer one, which allows us to relate model parameters between coarse-grainings and which provides a more precise meaning for the elements of the more abstract models. Furthermore, we discuss how organizational coarse-graining can be applied to spatial dynamics by showing spatial organizations during mitotic checkpoint inactivation. We demonstrate how these models lead to insights if the model has different "meaningful" behaviors that differ in the set of (molecular) species. We conclude that understanding, modeling and analyzing complex bio-molecular systems can greatly benefit from a set of coarse-graining methods that, ideally, can be automatically applied and that allow the different levels of abstraction to be related.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{henze2019multi,
  author = {Richard Henze and MU Chun-yan and Mate Puljiz and Nishanthan Kamaleson and Jan Huwald and John Haslegrave and Pietro Speroni di Fenizio and David Parker and Chris Good and Jonathan E. Rowe and Bashar Ibrahim and Peter Dittrich},
  title = {{Multi-scale stochastic organization-oriented coarse-graining exemplified on the human mitotic checkpoint}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-40648-w},
}
Figure