Multi-party Response Generation with Relation Disentanglement

Lizi LiaoarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of generating relevant responses in multi-party conversations, where traditional sequential models fall short. They introduce a novel framework, Multi-RG, that automatically infers conversational relationships between utterances using a "relational thinking" approach and a deep graph random process, then uses these inferred relationships to guide response generation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Generating natural and coherent responses in conversations is a long-standing goal in AI. While significant progress has been made for two-party dialogues, where conversations are treated as linear sequences, real-world conversations often involve multiple participants. In these multi-party settings, utterances can occur in parallel, creating a complex web of interactions that a simple sequential model cannot capture. Existing methods for multi-party conversations often rely on pre-defined or manually annotated relationships between utterances, which is impractical for real-world scenarios. This paper aims to bridge this gap by automatically inferring these crucial relationships without human supervision.

Methods

The core of the Multi-RG framework lies in its ability to infer relational structures within conversations. This is achieved through a "relational thinking" process, inspired by human cognitive processes.

  • Deep Graph Random Process (DGP) for Relation Inference: The model uses a DGP to generate an infinite number of probabilistic "percept graphs" that represent potential relationships between utterances. This allows it to explore a wide range of possible connections without explicit labels.
  • Summary Graph and Task-Specific Relation Graph: These percept graphs are then summarized into a single "summary graph." This summary graph is further transformed into a "task-specific relation graph" (G) by considering the context and the target utterance. This graph explicitly models the probability of a relation between any two utterances.
  • Structure-Aware Context Encoder: A Graph Neural Network (GNN) is employed to perform message passing over the inferred relation graph. This process allows utterances that are strongly related to the current context to have a greater influence on the representation of the anchor utterance, leading to a more informed context representation.
  • GAN-based Variational Autoencoder (VAE) Decoder: The inferred context representation is then fed into a VAE for response generation. To address the common "posterior collapse" problem in VAEs and to better model the complex latent space of responses, a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) is integrated within the latent variable space. This GAN helps to shape the distribution of generated responses.

Datasets

The authors evaluate their model on two publicly available datasets:

  • Movie Dialogue Dataset: This dataset consists of independent conversation sessions from movie scripts. It provides session labels and speaker tags, but not explicit reply-to annotations, making it suitable for evaluating unsupervised relation inference.
  • Ubuntu IRC Dataset: This dataset is extracted from Ubuntu technical support channels and includes speaker tags, reply-to targets, and session indices. It's a more challenging dataset for relation inference due to its entangled nature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Relational Thinking for Unsupervised Inference: The paper's central idea is that "relational thinking" can be computationally modeled to infer conversational structures without human labels. This is a significant departure from previous methods that relied on explicit annotations.
  • Graph Representation for Multi-Party Context: Representing multi-party conversations as graphs, rather than linear sequences, is crucial for capturing the complex interdependencies between utterances.
  • GANs for Improved Latent Space Modeling in VAEs: Integrating GANs into the VAE framework for response generation helps to overcome limitations of standard VAEs, leading to more diverse and higher-quality responses.
  • Heuristics as Pseudo-Supervision: While the core method is unsupervised, the paper shows that incorporating simple heuristics (like same-speaker or mention relations) as "pseudo-supervision" can further improve relation disentanglement performance, demonstrating a practical way to leverage readily available information.

Key Results

  • Superior Response Generation: The Multi-RG model consistently outperforms several state-of-the-art models on both the Movie Dialogue and Ubuntu IRC datasets across various metrics (BLEU, BOW Embedding, ROUGE-L). For instance, on the Ubuntu IRC dataset, Multi-RG achieves the highest BLEU score of 0.162 and ROUGE-L score of 0.144.
  • Effective Relation Disentanglement: The model also demonstrates strong performance in relation disentanglement tasks, outperforming unsupervised counterparts on the Ubuntu IRC dataset with an ARI score of 0.426 and Shen-F score of 0.715.
  • Ablation Studies: Experiments show that both the relational thinking for graph inference and the GAN-based VAE decoder are critical components for the model's success. Ignoring heuristic information or using a fixed graph structure significantly degrades performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Human Evaluation Nuances: While automatic metrics are strong, human evaluation reveals that Multi-RG can sometimes be less fluent than models with advanced decoders (like HeterMPCBERT).
  • Speaker Style: The authors acknowledge that speaker style and characteristics play a role in response generation, which their current model does not explicitly incorporate. They plan to explore ways to integrate this information in future work.
  • Generic Responses: In some case studies, responses were noted as being too generic or lacking critical information, suggesting room for improvement in generating more specific and informative outputs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Existing neural response generation models have achieved impressive improvements for two-party conversations, which assume that utterances are sequentially organized. However, many real-world dialogues involve multiple interlocutors and the structure of conversational context is much more complex, e.g. utterances from different interlocutors can occur "in parallel". Facing this challenge, there are works trying to model the relations among utterances or interlocutors to facilitate response generation with clearer context. Nonetheless, these methods rely heavily on such relations and all assume that these are given beforehand, which is impractical and hinders the generality of such methods. In this work, we propose to automatically infer the relations via relational thinking on subtle clues inside the conversation context without any human label, and leverage these relations to guide the neural response generation. Specifically, we first apply a deep graph random process to fully consider all possible relations among utterances in the conversational context. Then the inferred relation graphs are integrated with a variational auto-encoder framework to train a GAN for structure-aware response generation. Experimental results on the Ubuntu Internet Relay Chat (IRC) channel benchmark and the most recent Movie Dialogues show that our method outperforms various baseline models for multi-party response generation.
BibTeX
@misc{liao2024multi,
  author = {Lizi Liao},
  title = {{Multi-party Response Generation with Relation Disentanglement}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2403.10827},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.10827},
}
Figure