Multi-Parameter Measurement of Rotors Using the Doppler Effect of Frequency-Swept Interferometry

Bin Shao, Wei Zhang, Peng Zhang, Weimin ChenSensors 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel method to simultaneously measure a rotor's axial clearance, angular velocity, and tilt angle using frequency-swept interferometry (FSI). Instead of treating the Doppler effect as an error, the researchers leverage its characteristics to extract these multiple parameters from a single FSI signal, offering a more compact and efficient solution for monitoring rotating machinery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rotating machines like turbines, generators, and engines rely heavily on the precise functioning of their rotors. Deviations from ideal operation, caused by manufacturing tolerances, assembly issues, or imbalances, can lead to reduced efficiency and even catastrophic failure. Accurately monitoring rotor parameters such as axial clearance (how much it moves along its axis), angular velocity (how fast it spins), and tilt angle (its inclination) is crucial for performance evaluation, fault diagnosis, and health monitoring. Traditional methods often require multiple sensors and complex integration, which is challenging in space-constrained environments like the interior of rotating machinery. Furthermore, existing FSI techniques, while good for distance measurement, typically treat the Doppler effect as an error that degrades accuracy. This paper tackles the challenge of achieving multi-parameter rotor measurement with a single, non-intrusive sensor, by ingeniously repurposing the Doppler effect.

Methods

The core innovation lies in reframing the Doppler effect in FSI from an obstacle to a measurement tool. The researchers derived a new FSI formula that explicitly incorporates the rotational Doppler effect. They found that the resulting dynamic distance measurement from FSI contains information about the rotor's axial clearance, angular velocity, and tilt angle, encoded in its frequency, DC component, and amplitude, respectively.

The method involves:

  1. Establishing a Rotational Doppler Formula: They developed a theoretical model that relates the FSI signal's phase to the rotor's parameters (axial clearance L, angular velocity Ω, and tilt angle α), along with probe installation parameters.
  2. Parameter Estimation: By analyzing the frequency, DC component, and amplitude of the measured dynamic distance signal (derived from the FSI phase), they can simultaneously estimate Ω, L, and α using a set of derived equations.
  3. Addressing Probe Misalignment: The paper also analyzes the impact of non-parallel probe installation (deflection angles) on measurement accuracy and provides guidance on optimal probe placement to minimize errors.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using a custom-built rotor platform and a fiber-optic FSI system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Doppler Effect as a Feature, Not a Bug: The most significant insight is the clever inversion of the Doppler effect's role. Instead of trying to eliminate it, the authors exploit its modulation properties to extract multiple rotor parameters.
  • Single-Sensor Multi-Parameter Measurement: The proposed method enables simultaneous measurement of three critical rotor parameters using a single, small fiber-optic probe, drastically simplifying system design and installation, especially in confined spaces.
  • Direct Measurement in Harsh Environments: Fiber optics are inherently robust, lightweight, and bendable, making them ideal for deployment within the challenging environments of rotating machinery where traditional sensors might fail or be impractical.
  • Theoretical Foundation for Multi-Parameter Extraction: The paper provides a solid theoretical framework linking FSI signal characteristics (frequency, DC component, amplitude) to specific rotor parameters, moving beyond simple distance measurement.

Key Results

The experimental validation demonstrated the effectiveness of the proposed method:

  • High Accuracy: Relative errors for measured axial clearance, angular velocity, and tilt angle were consistently below 3.5%. Specifically, errors were reported as:
  • Axial Clearance (L): < 0.06% in some experiments, < 0.1% overall.
  • Angular Velocity (Ω): < 1.5% in some experiments, < 2.2% overall.
  • Tilt Angle (α): < 1% in some experiments, < 3.5% overall.
  • Robustness: The method showed good performance across variations in angular velocity, axial clearance, and probe radial distance.
  • Theoretical Error Bound: The analysis of probe misalignment provided a theoretical upper bound for the relative error in tilt angle estimation, offering practical guidance for installation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Probe Installation Parameters: The method relies on knowing certain probe installation parameters (like radial distance 'r' and deflection angles). While the paper analyzes the impact of non-parallel installation, precise knowledge or calibration of these parameters is still necessary.
  • Complexity of the Signal: The derivation of the dynamic distance signal from the raw FSI signal involves calculating the instantaneous phase, which can be done using techniques like the Hilbert transform.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest combining their method with existing fiber-optic radial clearance measurement techniques to achieve even more comprehensive multi-parameter measurement of rotors. Further research could explore extending this to other types of rotating machinery or dynamic conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Doppler effect of frequency-swept interferometry (FSI) is often seen as an obstacle to the dynamic ranging accuracy. However, the potential of this obstacle is rarely noticed and used. In this paper, by combining the periodical characteristics of the rotational Doppler effect, an FSI-based multi-parameter measurement method for the rotor is proposed. Through the establishment of the rotational Doppler formula of FSI, it is found that the frequency, direct component, and amplitude of the dynamic distance given by FSI can be utilized to estimate the angular velocity, axial clearance, and tilt angle of the rotor, respectively. A rotor platform and a fiber-optic FSI system were constructed, and a series of experiments were carried out to verify the proposed method. The experimental results showed that the relative errors of the measured axial clearance, angular velocity, and tilt angle were less than 3.5%. This work provides a new perspective on the multi-parameter measurement of the rotor and makes it possible to directly perform multi-parameter measurement inside the space-confined rotating machinery as only a single small-size fiber-optic probe is needed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shao2020multi,
  author = {Bin Shao and Wei Zhang and Peng Zhang and Weimin Chen},
  title = {{Multi-Parameter Measurement of Rotors Using the Doppler Effect of Frequency-Swept Interferometry}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20247178},
}
Figure