Multi-Objective Optimization Dispatching Strategy for Wind-Thermal-Storage Generation System Incorporating Temporal and Spatial Distribution Control of Air Pollutant Dispersion

Zhuohuan Li, Tao Yu, Yixuan Chen, Hanxin Zhu, Weicong WuIEEE Access 2020 · DOI

Overview

This research introduces a sophisticated power dispatch strategy that shifts the focus from total emission volume to the temporal and spatial distribution (TSD) of pollutants. By integrating a TSD model with wind and pumped-storage hydro systems, the study demonstrates that ground-level breathable pollutants can be drastically reduced without necessarily slashing total power output. This approach bridges the gap between power system engineering and atmospheric physics to protect public health more effectively.

The Challenge: Beyond Total Emissions

Traditional Environmental Economic Dispatch (EED) models typically treat pollution as a flat numerical penalty: a plant emitting 100 tons of $SO_2$ is penalized for 100 tons regardless of where those tons go. However, the atmosphere is dynamic. A ton of sulfur dioxide emitted during a windy afternoon might disperse harmlessly, while the same ton emitted during a temperature inversion at dawn might settle directly into a city, causing a localized health crisis.

The authors identify that most dispatch strategies ignore the physics of the Atmospheric Boundary Layer (ABL)—the lowest part of the atmosphere that changes throughout the day. To truly protect urban populations, power systems must optimize for Ground Level Pollutant Concentration (GLPC) rather than just total emission volume.

Methodology: Modeling Atmospheric Dynamics

The researchers developed a multi-objective optimization model balancing three conflicting goals: minimizing fuel costs, minimizing $CO_2$ emissions, and minimizing the average Comprehensive Pollution Evaluation Value (CPEV).

Diurnal evolution of the Atmospheric Boundary Layer (ABL) structure, showing the transitions between stable, unstable, and neutral layers.

Key technical components include:

  • Gaussian Puff Model: Unlike simpler plume models, this simulates pollutants as discrete "puffs" that move and expand over time, allowing for more accurate tracking in light or shifting winds.
  • ABL Dynamics: The model accounts for diurnal phases including Fumigation (morning trapping), Enclosed (afternoon mixing), and Downward Inhibited (nighttime restriction).
  • Chance-Constrained Programming: To account for wind power unpredictability, the authors used chance constraints to ensure system stability and reserve requirements are met with a 95% mathematical probability.
  • NBI & TOPSIS: The Normal Boundary Intersection (NBI) method finds the "Pareto front" of optimal trade-offs, while the TOPSIS decision-making method selects the best compromise solution for daily operations.

Case Studies: IEEE 39-Bus and Guangdong Grid

The model was validated using two primary setups:

  1. Modified IEEE 39-bus System: A standard benchmark geographically mapped to include 10 thermal units, a wind farm, and a pumped storage plant near a hypothetical urban area.
  2. Guangdong Grid System: A real-world dataset from China involving 59 thermal plants (134 units) and 31 gas turbines, with a total capacity exceeding 61,000 MW. This test utilized actual weather data from January 2017.

Key Insights: The Pollution Buffer and Location Paradox

  • Location vs. Efficiency: The model reveals that a "cleaner" plant located upwind of a city can be more hazardous than a "dirtier" plant located downwind. The strategy successfully identifies plants with the highest target-oriented impact on urban air quality.
  • The "Pollution Peak" Shifting: Just as batteries shift energy, this model uses Pumped Storage to shift pollution. By pumping water (consuming power) when atmospheric dispersion is poor and generating power when dispersion is high, the system acts as a "pollution buffer."
  • The Emission Paradox: Strategy 3 (minimizing total emissions) actually increased ground-level pollution by 28.3% in some cases compared to the authors' proposed Strategy 4. This occurs because total emission reduction might favor a plant that emits less gas overall but is located where that gas settles directly onto the population.

Results and Future Directions

In light-wind conditions, the proposed strategy reduced average ground-level $SO_2$ concentration by 59.3% compared to standard economic dispatch. When applied to the Guangdong grid, it reduced ground-level $SO_2$ by 13.15% while saving approximately $950,000 in daily economic costs compared to a baseline without wind/storage integration.

Future work will aim to incorporate complex topography (mountains and valleys), secondary chemical reactions (such as PM2.5 formation), and additional weather variables like humidity and precipitation to further refine the dispersion coefficients.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2020multi,
  author = {Zhuohuan Li and Tao Yu and Yixuan Chen and Hanxin Zhu and Weicong Wu},
  title = {{Multi-Objective Optimization Dispatching Strategy for Wind-Thermal-Storage Generation System Incorporating Temporal and Spatial Distribution Control of Air Pollutant Dispersion}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2020.2978092},
}
Figure