Abstract
Multi-messenger searches for gravitational waves and high-energy neutrinos provide important insights into the dynamics of and particle acceleration by black holes and neutron stars. With LIGO's third observing period (O3), the number of gravitational wave detections has been substantially increased. The rapid identification of joint signals is crucial for electromagnetic follow-up observations of transient emission that is only detectable for short periods of time. High-energy neutrino direction can be reconstructed to sub-degree precision, making a joint detection far better localized than a standalone gravitational-wave signal. We present the latest sensitivity of joint searches and discuss the Low-Latency Algorithm for Multi-messenger Astrophysics (LLAMA) that combines LIGO/Virgo gravitational-wave candidates and searches in low-latency for coincident high-energy neutrinos from the IceCube Neutrino Observatory. We will further discuss future prospects of joint searches from the perspective of better understanding the interaction of relativistic and sub-relativistic outflows from binary neutron star mergers.
Introduction
The landmark detection of the binary neutron star merger GW170817 demonstrated the immense potential of multi-messenger astronomy. However, a persistent challenge in this field is the "fuzzy" localization of gravitational-wave (GW) events, which often span hundreds or thousands of square degrees on the sky. This broad uncertainty makes it difficult for traditional electromagnetic telescopes to identify the source before its transient signal fades.
High-energy neutrinos (HENs) offer a solution. Produced in the relativistic outflows of these cataclysmic mergers, neutrinos can be reconstructed with sub-degree angular precision. By identifying a neutrino coincident in time and space with a GW event, researchers can pinpoint the source location with high accuracy, enabling rapid follow-up observations.
The LLAMA Pipeline
To address the need for speed, researchers developed the Low-Latency Algorithm for Multi-messenger Astrophysics (LLAMA). This pipeline provides a real-time bridge between the LIGO/Virgo gravitational-wave detectors and the IceCube Neutrino Observatory.
LLAMA utilizes a Bayesian framework to calculate a "Bayes’ factor," which quantifies the likelihood that a GW and a neutrino share a common origin versus being a random coincidence. The pipeline automatically triggers on public alerts from LIGO/Virgo and searches the IceCube Gamma-ray Follow-Up (GFU) stream for neutrinos within a $\pm 500$-second window of the GW event. The analysis incorporates several key variables:
- GW Data: Detection time, reconstructed sky location, signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and estimated distance.
- HEN Data: Detection time, sky location, and an energy proxy based on the muon produced by the neutrino.
The entire process, from receiving a GW alert to producing a joint skymap, is completed in just a few seconds, providing the low latency required for electromagnetic follow-up.
Results from the O3 Observing Run
During the third observing run (O3) of LIGO and Virgo, the LLAMA pipeline analyzed 14 public GW candidates. The results of these searches are visualized through skymaps that overlay the GW probability regions with the reconstructed directions of coincident neutrino candidates.
While the pipeline successfully processed these events, none yielded a statistically significant coincidence (defined as a p-value $< 1\%$). Most of the analyzed events were identified as Binary Black Hole (BBH) mergers, which are theoretically less likely to produce detectable neutrino emission compared to mergers involving neutron stars. Despite the lack of a "smoking gun" detection, the O3 run demonstrated the robustness and speed of the LLAMA system. Sensitivity analysis indicates that the search can detect a neutrino fluence of $0.049 \text{ GeV/cm}^2$ (assuming an $E^{-2}$ spectrum) with 50% probability across the sky.
Discussion and Future Prospects
The current sensitivity of joint searches is partially limited by sky coverage; IceCube is significantly more sensitive to events in the Northern sky. Future improvements will focus on refining the astrophysical "priors" used in the Bayesian analysis to better predict which mergers are most likely to produce neutrinos.
Furthermore, neutrino searches provide a unique window into "choked jets"—mergers where the relativistic jet is trapped within a cocoon of debris, preventing the escape of gamma rays but allowing neutrinos to pass through. As gravitational-wave detectors reach higher sensitivities and additional neutrino observatories come online, the probability of a joint GW+HEN detection will increase, offering unprecedented insights into the engines of the universe's most violent phenomena.
Summary updated