Multi-market trading and liquidity: Evidence from cross-listed companies

Christina Atanasova, Mingxin LiJournal of International Financial Markets Institutions and Money 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how liquidity in different stock markets affects the pricing and convergence of cross-listed companies. It finds that lower liquidity in the U.S. market and higher liquidity in the home market are associated with higher ADR premiums, and that increased liquidity generally speeds up price convergence between markets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When a company's shares are traded on multiple exchanges (cross-listing), it's possible for the same stock to have different prices in different markets. This phenomenon, known as a deviation from the "law of one price," has long intrigued academics and financial professionals. While previous research has explored these price differences, questions remain about how factors like market liquidity influence the premium (or discount) of these cross-listed securities and how quickly prices converge across markets. This paper aims to shed light on these relationships, specifically focusing on the role of liquidity in determining ADR premiums and the speed of price convergence for cross-listed firms.

Methods

The authors employ several econometric techniques to analyze their data:

  • OLS Regression: Used to examine the cross-sectional variation in ADR premiums, controlling for various firm- and country-level characteristics.
  • Instrumental Variables (IV) / 2SLS Estimation: To address potential endogeneity between liquidity and ADR premiums, they use the introduction of decimal trading in 2001 as an exogenous shock to U.S. market liquidity.
  • Error Correction Model (VECM): To study price discovery and the speed of price convergence between home and U.S. markets for cross-listed stocks.
  • Survival Analysis (Cox Proportional Hazard Model): To analyze the duration of price deviations from parity and how liquidity affects the time it takes for prices to converge.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from several sources:

  • Datastream: For daily home-market closing prices and U.S. market closing prices.
  • CRSP (Center for Research in Security Prices): For U.S. stock market data.
  • TAQ (Trade and Quote) Consolidated Trades: For intraday trading prices on U.S. markets.
  • Compustat: For firm-level accounting data.
  • Bank of New York Mellon Corporation's DR Directory and J.P. Morgan adr.com: For ADR ratio information.

The sample consists of 650 cross-listed firms from 18 countries, covering the period from January 2, 1997, to December 29, 2012.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Liquidity's Dual Role: The paper highlights that liquidity isn't a monolithic concept. Higher liquidity in the U.S. market decreases ADR premiums, while higher liquidity in the home market increases them. This suggests a complex interplay where the relative liquidity of each market matters.
  • Decimalization as a Natural Experiment: Using the introduction of decimal trading in the U.S. as an exogenous shock to liquidity provides a robust way to tackle the endogeneity problem, strengthening the findings on liquidity's impact on ADR premiums.
  • U.S. Market's Price Discovery Dominance (with caveats): While previous studies often found price discovery concentrated in home markets, this research suggests the U.S. market plays a significant role, sometimes even a dominant one, in price discovery for cross-listed stocks. However, this dominance can vary by country.
  • Liquidity Accelerates Convergence: More liquid stocks converge to price parity faster. This implies that market efficiency, as measured by the speed of price adjustment, is directly linked to how easily shares can be traded.

Key Results

  • ADR Premiums: A one-standard deviation increase in the U.S. bid-ask spread (a measure of illiquidity) is associated with a 0.91% increase in the ADR premium. This effect is statistically and economically significant.
  • Price Discovery: Liquidity has a positive effect on price discovery, with this effect being stronger in the U.S. market than in the home market.
  • Price Convergence: More liquid stocks exhibit shorter durations of deviations from price parity, meaning prices converge faster. This finding holds even after controlling for major market events like the 2008 Financial Crisis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Synchronization Imperfection: The paper acknowledges that synchronizing home and U.S. market prices can be imperfect, especially for markets with significant time differences (e.g., Asian Pacific countries).
  • Endogeneity Concerns: While the study uses decimalization as an instrumental variable to address endogeneity between liquidity and ADR premiums, the authors note that other potential endogeneity issues might exist.
  • Future Research: The paper suggests further research could explore the impact of liquidity on price discovery over time and investigate the reasons behind the observed variations in U.S. market dominance in price discovery across different countries.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{atanasova2017multi,
  author = {Christina Atanasova and Mingxin Li},
  title = {{Multi-market trading and liquidity: Evidence from cross-listed companies}},
  journal = {Journal of International Financial Markets Institutions and Money},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.intfin.2017.09.015},
}
Figure