Multi-level multi-domain statistical shape model of the subtalar, talonavicular, and calcaneocuboid joints

Andrew C. Peterson, Rich J. Lisonbee, Nicola Krähenbühl, Charles L. Saltzman, Alexej Barg, Nawazish Khan, Shireen Elhabian, Amy L. LenzFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a sophisticated 3D "multi-level multi-domain" statistical model to map the complex architecture of the human hindfoot and midfoot. By analyzing weightbearing CT scans, the study reveals that the way our foot bones are shaped (morphology) influences joint health metrics far more than how they are positioned (alignment), providing a new blueprint for diagnosing and treating ankle pathologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human foot is a mechanical marvel, but its internal geometry is a nightmare to image. Traditionally, clinicians rely on 2D X-rays to assess joint health. However, the subtalar, talonavicular, and calcaneocuboid joints—the "engine room" of foot rotation and stability—are buried deep within the ankle, where bones overlap in 2D views.

Standard 2D measurements fail to capture the 3D spatial relationships and the subtle "locking" mechanisms that occur during movement. Furthermore, most existing 3D models look at bones in isolation. This paper addresses the need for a multi-domain approach: a model that looks at how multiple bones vary together as a functional unit, specifically under the natural stress of standing (weightbearing).

Methods

The researchers utilized Weightbearing Computed Tomography (WBCT) to capture high-resolution 3D reconstructions of the talus, calcaneus, navicular, and cuboid bones in 27 asymptomatic participants.

The core innovation lies in the Statistical Shape Modeling (SSM) framework:

  • Multi-Domain SSM (MD SSM): Instead of modeling one bone at a time, the team treated the four-bone complex as a single "object," capturing how changes in one bone correlate with changes in its neighbors.
  • Multi-Level Analysis: They mathematically separated morphology (the intrinsic shape of the bones) from alignment (their relative orientation and position).
  • Particle-Based Modeling: Using an open-source tool called ShapeWorks, they placed thousands of "correspondence particles" across the bone surfaces to quantify variation without the bias of manual landmarking.
  • Joint Metrics: They calculated three key 3D metrics: coverage area (how much the bones overlap), joint space distance (the gap between surfaces), and congruence (how well the surfaces "fit" together).

Datasets

The study used a primary dataset of 27 asymptomatic participants (average age 50, 7 males).

  • Inclusion criteria: No history of ankle injury or surgery, and no clinical deformities like flatfoot (planovalgus) or high arches (cavovarus).
  • Imaging: Unilateral WBCT scans with 0.4 mm isotropic pixel resolution.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Talus-Calcaneus Trade-off: The most significant morphological variation (Mode 2) revealed an inverse relationship: as the talar dome (the top of the ankle) gets higher, the calcaneus (heel bone) tends to shorten, and the slope of the joint facets changes. This suggests the hindfoot scales and reshapes itself in predictable, coupled ways.
  • Shape Trumps Alignment: Surprisingly, the study found that population-level variation in joint coverage and congruence is driven much more by the shape of the bones themselves than by how they are aligned. This implies that some people may be predisposed to joint issues simply due to their innate bone geometry.
  • Stability in the Midfoot: While the talus and calcaneus showed significant shape changes, the navicular and cuboid bones remained relatively consistent in shape across the population. Their variation was almost entirely positional (alignment), specifically rotating around the anterior-posterior axis.
  • Predictive Power: The MD SSM was able to accurately predict joint space distance, suggesting these models could eventually be used to "fill in the blanks" for patients with degraded joints or incomplete imaging data.

Key Results

  • Statistical Significance: Three Principal Component Analysis (PCA) modes accounted for 74.8% of the total shape and alignment variation in the four-bone complex.
  • Joint Space: The average joint space distance for the subtalar joint was 3.33 ± 2.06 mm, while the talonavicular joint was much tighter at 1.32 ± 0.43 mm.
  • Congruence: The subtalar joint showed a worsening congruence index on its outer edges, a detail that 2D imaging would likely miss.
  • Validation: The multi-domain mean shapes were nearly identical to single-domain models (differences < 0.1 mm), proving that modeling bones together doesn't sacrifice individual accuracy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • The "Missing" Tissue: The study focused purely on subchondral bone. It did not include soft tissues like ligaments, tendons, or articular cartilage, which are critical for a complete picture of joint mechanics.
  • Static vs. Dynamic: WBCT captures a "standing still" moment. It doesn't show how these bones move and lock during the gait cycle (walking).
  • Sample Size and Diversity: With only 27 healthy participants, the model doesn't yet account for the full spectrum of human diversity or pathological states (like osteoarthritis or flatfoot deformity).
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest expanding the model to include more bones of the foot and applying this framework to pathological populations to see how "normal" variation shifts into "disease" states.

Summary updated

Abstract

Traditionally, two-dimensional conventional radiographs have been the primary tool to measure the complex morphology of the foot and ankle. However, the subtalar, talonavicular, and calcaneocuboid joints are challenging to assess due to their bone morphology and locations within the ankle. Weightbearing computed tomography is a novel high-resolution volumetric imaging mechanism that allows detailed generation of 3D bone reconstructions. This study aimed to develop a multi-domain statistical shape model to assess morphologic and alignment variation of the subtalar, talonavicular, and calcaneocuboid joints across an asymptomatic population and calculate 3D joint measurements in a consistent weightbearing position. Specific joint measurements included joint space distance, congruence, and coverage. Noteworthy anatomical variation predominantly included the talus and calcaneus, specifically an inverse relationship regarding talar dome heightening and calcaneal shortening. While there was minimal navicular and cuboid shape variation, there were alignment variations within these joints; the most notable is the rotational aspect about the anterior-posterior axis. This study also found that multi-domain modeling may be able to predict joint space distance measurements within a population. Additionally, variation across a population of these four bones may be driven far more by morphology than by alignment variation based on all three joint measurements. These data are beneficial in furthering our understanding of joint-level morphology and alignment variants to guide advancements in ankle joint pathological care and operative treatments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{peterson2022multi,
  author = {Andrew C. Peterson and Rich J. Lisonbee and Nicola Krähenbühl and Charles L. Saltzman and Alexej Barg and Nawazish Khan and Shireen Elhabian and Amy L. Lenz},
  title = {{Multi-level multi-domain statistical shape model of the subtalar, talonavicular, and calcaneocuboid joints}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2022.1056536},
}
Figure