Multi-Level Dynamic Weight Optimization Scheduling Strategy for Flexible Interconnected Distribution Substations Based on Three-Port SNOPs

Dan Pang, Zhipeng Wang, Xiaomeng Shi, Jinming Ge, Zhenhao Wang, Hongyin Yi, Yan Zhuang, Yu Yin, Wei WangEnergies 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel multi-level dynamic weight optimization scheduling strategy for flexible interconnected distribution substations (FIDS) utilizing three-port soft normal open points (SNOPs). By dynamically adjusting optimization weights based on voltage overrun levels, the strategy effectively balances operational costs, voltage quality, customer satisfaction, and SNOP regulation capabilities, leading to improved system efficiency and stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of distributed generation (DG) into power distribution networks presents challenges like voltage overruns and fluctuations. Traditional distribution networks, relying on fixed switches, lack the flexibility to manage these issues effectively. Soft Normal Open Points (SNOPs) offer a solution by enabling flexible interconnections and active power transfer between distribution substations. However, optimizing the operation of these interconnected systems, especially under varying voltage conditions, requires a sophisticated scheduling strategy that can adapt to different operational states and balance multiple, often conflicting, objectives. This paper addresses the need for such an adaptive strategy that can dynamically adjust its priorities based on real-time voltage conditions to ensure both economic efficiency and reliable power supply.

Methods

The core of this paper's contribution lies in its multi-level dynamic weight optimization scheduling strategy. The approach involves:

  • Voltage Overrun Classification: Distribution station areas are categorized into three levels based on voltage deviation: "Normal Operation," "Safe Boundary," and "Protection Boundary." This classification is crucial for tailoring the scheduling strategy to the severity of the voltage issue.
  • Multi-Objective Optimization Framework: The strategy aims to optimize four key objectives: customer satisfaction, voltage deviation, system operation cost, and SNOP residual capacity regulation capability.
  • Dynamic Weighting Coefficients: Instead of using fixed weights for each objective, this paper proposes a method to dynamically determine these weights based on the current voltage overrun level. This allows the system to prioritize different objectives as needed. For instance, in normal operation, cost might be prioritized, while in a protection boundary scenario, voltage quality and customer satisfaction take precedence.
  • SNOP Modeling: A model for three-port SNOPs is developed, considering power loss and capacity constraints.
  • Optimization Model Transformation: The non-convex optimization model is transformed into a solvable form using techniques like second-order cone relaxation and auxiliary variables to handle absolute value terms.
  • Solver: The final optimization problem is solved using MATLAB with the Yalmip toolbox and the Gurobi solver.

Datasets

The paper utilizes a modified IEEE 33-node test system as its simulation environment. This system is configured to represent three interconnected distribution stations, each with multiple nodes, transformers, PV devices, and energy storage systems, connected via three-port SNOPs. This setup serves as a benchmark for evaluating the proposed strategy.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Adaptive Prioritization is Key: The most significant insight is that a one-size-fits-all optimization approach is insufficient for FIDS. Dynamically adjusting the importance of different objectives based on real-time voltage conditions is crucial for effective operation.
  • SNOPs as Dynamic Regulators: The strategy highlights the active role SNOPs can play not just in connecting networks but also in actively regulating power flow and voltage, especially during abnormal conditions.
  • Balancing Act: The paper demonstrates that by carefully tuning weights, it's possible to achieve a balance between seemingly competing goals like minimizing costs and ensuring high voltage quality, even under stress.
  • Granular Control: The multi-level approach, classifying voltage states, allows for more nuanced and effective control compared to a single, overarching strategy.

Key Results

The paper presents simulation results across three scenarios representing different voltage overrun levels:

  • Scenario 1 (Normal Operation): The proposed dynamic weighting method achieved a total system cost of CNY 65,768.22, with 20 iterations and a convergence interval of 0.0000716% in 41.79 seconds. It showed comparable voltage regulation to other methods but with a slightly lower cost.
  • Scenario 2 (Safe Boundary): The dynamic weighting strategy resulted in a total system cost of CNY 98,660.59, with 21 iterations and a convergence interval of 0.0001118% in 43.09 seconds. This method effectively brought voltages back within normal operation levels and demonstrated a lower system cost compared to fixed weighting and adaptive weighting methods.
  • Scenario 3 (Protection Boundary): The proposed method achieved the lowest total system cost of CNY 118,535.88, with 23 iterations and a convergence interval of 0.0000667% in 44.32 seconds. It was particularly effective in preventing voltage from exceeding protection boundaries and restoring it to normal levels, outperforming other methods in voltage regulation and cost-efficiency.

Across all scenarios, the proposed dynamic weighting strategy consistently showed competitive or superior performance in terms of system cost, convergence speed, and voltage regulation compared to fixed weighting and adaptive weighting methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper focuses on a specific test system (IEEE 33-node) and its modifications. The scalability and performance on larger, more complex real-world grids are not explicitly discussed.
  • While the method addresses voltage overruns, the impact of other potential disturbances like equipment failures or communication delays is not deeply explored.
  • The "human factors" in optimization are mitigated by dynamic weighting, but the initial selection of objective functions and their relative importance might still involve some degree of expert judgment.
  • Future Work:
    • Investigating the application of this strategy to larger and more diverse distribution network configurations.
  • Incorporating other operational constraints and uncertainties, such as communication network reliability and cyber-physical attacks.
  • Exploring advanced control techniques for SNOPs to further enhance their dynamic response and coordination capabilities.
  • Real-world implementation and validation of the proposed strategy.

Summary updated

Abstract

By using a soft normal open point (SNOP) to connect multiple distribution networks to form a flexible interconnected distribution system (FIDS), the power distribution can be flexibly and controllably regulated among distribution stations, but it is also necessary to ensure the system’s operational efficiency and maintain voltage quality when carrying out optimal scheduling. In this paper, a FIDS optimal scheduling strategy considering dynamic weight grading is proposed. By considering the voltage overrun status of each distribution station area, the voltage level of each distribution station area is divided into three voltage overrun situations, including normal operation, safe boundary, and protection boundary levels, and an optimal scheduling model applicable to the multi-level operation of the FIDS is constructed. In order to adapt to the coordinated optimal operation objectives under different overrun levels, an optimal operation strategy considering the dynamic weights of system operation cost, voltage deviation, customer satisfaction, and SNOP regulation capability is proposed and finally simulated and verified using the improved IEEE33 node arithmetic case. The results verify the effectiveness of the method proposed in this paper in improving the system’s operational efficiency and node voltage quality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pang2025multi,
  author = {Dan Pang and Zhipeng Wang and Xiaomeng Shi and Jinming Ge and Zhenhao Wang and Hongyin Yi and Yan Zhuang and Yu Yin and Wei Wang},
  title = {{Multi-Level Dynamic Weight Optimization Scheduling Strategy for Flexible Interconnected Distribution Substations Based on Three-Port SNOPs}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/en18102421},
}
Figure