Multi-hop Sub-THz-FSO: A Technique for High-rate Uninterrupted Backhauling in 6G

Praveen Kumar Singya, Behrooz Makki, A. D’Errico, Mohamed‐Slim AlouiniarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

As we transition to 6G, backhaul networks—the "pipes" connecting base stations to the core—face a massive capacity crunch. This paper proposes a hybrid multi-hop sub-THz and Free Space Optical (FSO) architecture that combines the strengths of radio and laser communications to provide fiber-like speeds with high reliability, even in adverse weather.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The demand for mobile data is skyrocketing, with 6G expected to support ultra-high-capacity use cases like VR, AI-based training, and holographic communications. Traditional backhaul relies on fiber or microwave. While fiber is the gold standard for speed, it is expensive and slow to deploy (requiring trenching). Microwave is flexible but lacks the bandwidth needed for 6G.

Researchers are looking at higher frequencies: sub-TeraHertz (sub-THz) and Free Space Optical (FSO). However, both have a "weather problem." Sub-THz signals are easily blocked by heavy rain, while FSO (which uses lasers) is crippled by fog and clouds. Furthermore, these high-frequency beams are incredibly narrow, making them highly sensitive to "pointing errors"—tiny physical misalignments caused by wind or thermal expansion of the towers.

Methods

The authors investigate a multi-hop, hybrid approach to solve these availability and alignment issues. Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Hybridization: They model a system where each backhaul node has both a sub-THz transceiver and an FSO transceiver. Since rain affects RF and fog affects FSO, the two technologies are complementary.
  • Multi-hop IAB: They utilize the Integrated Access and Backhaul (IAB) framework, breaking long, fragile links into shorter, more robust "hops" (typically 2–3 hops).
  • Switching/Combining Strategies: They compare three ways to manage the dual links:
  • Hard Switching: Using only the best link at any given time.
  • Soft Switching: Switching only when a link's performance drops below a specific threshold to avoid "ping-ponging" between links.
  • Maximum Ratio Combining (MRC): Mathematically combining signals from both links for maximum performance (the most complex but effective method).
  • Mathematical Modeling: The study uses rigorous channel models, including Gamma-Gamma distribution for FSO atmospheric turbulence and $\alpha-\mu$ fading for sub-THz links, while accounting for Rayleigh-distributed pointing errors.

Datasets

This is a theoretical and simulation-based study; therefore, it does not use a traditional "training" dataset. Instead, the authors use standardized parameters for 6G channel modeling (summarized in Table I of the paper), such as:

  • Frequencies: 119 GHz for sub-THz and 1550 nm for FSO.
  • Atmospheric Conditions: Specific coefficients for "Strong" vs. "Moderate" turbulence and rain/fog attenuation values derived from existing literature (e.g., ITU-R standards).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Complementary Weather Shield: The most significant "aha" moment is the quantitative proof of weather complementarity. By combining sub-THz and FSO, the system maintains a high "ergodic rate" (average data rate) across a wide range of visibility conditions, from heavy fog to clear air.
  • Multi-hop as a Reliability Tool: Moving from a single 400m hop to two 200m hops doesn't just help with line-of-sight; it drastically reduces the impact of pointing errors. Shorter hops mean the beam doesn't "spread" as much, making the link easier to maintain.
  • The "Sweet Spot" for Beamwidth: The paper reveals that there is an optimum beamwidth for these links. If the beam is too narrow, pointing errors kill the connection; if it's too wide, the energy is too dilute. Hybridization allows for a more forgiving "optimum" than either technology alone.

Key Results

  • Outage Probability: The hybrid sub-THz-FSO link provides over 3 orders of magnitude improvement in outage probability compared to using a single-technology link in certain scenarios.
  • Gain over Single Links: At a target outage probability of $10^{-4}$, the hybrid system (using MRC) provides a 5.3 dB gain over sub-THz alone and a 1.4 dB gain over FSO alone.
  • Handover Benefits: Multi-hop configurations (specifically "Mode 2" in the paper) showed significantly more uniform performance across a coverage area compared to single-hop setups, which suffer from rapid signal degradation as the user moves away from the donor node.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lack of Unified Testbeds: While the authors cite individual testbeds for RF and FSO, there is currently no integrated experimental setup that tests the simultaneous sub-THz-FSO hybrid multi-hop architecture in the field.
  • Total Cost of Ownership (TCO): The paper acknowledges that while the tech works, the cost of deploying dual transceivers and the need for "zero-touch" automatic calibration are significant economic hurdles.
  • Security: While FSO is inherently very secure (it's hard to intercept a laser beam), the sub-THz component remains vulnerable to traditional RF security challenges, requiring further research into end-to-end security for hybrid links.
  • Standardization: Current 3GPP standards (Rel-16-18) for IAB do not yet specifically cover the W-band and D-band (sub-THz) or FSO, meaning a regulatory gap exists.

Summary updated

Abstract

Moving towards $6^{\text{th}}$ generation (6G), backhaul networks require significant improvements to support new use-cases with restricted joint capacity and availability requirements. In this paper, we investigate the potentials and challenges of joint sub-teraHertz (sub-THz) and free space optical (FSO), in short sub-THz-FSO, multi-hop networks as a candidate technology for future backhaul communications. As we show, with a proper deployment, sub-THz-FSO networks have the potential to provide high-rate reliable backhauling, while there are multiple practical challenges to be address before they can be used in large-scale.
BibTeX
@misc{singya2023multi,
  author = {Praveen Kumar Singya and Behrooz Makki and A. D’Errico and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Multi-hop Sub-THz-FSO: A Technique for High-rate Uninterrupted Backhauling in 6G}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2312.05768},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05768},
}
Figure