Multi-Hazard Susceptibility Assessment Using the Analytical Hierarchy Process in Coastal Regions of South Aegean Volcanic Arc Islands

Pavlos Krassakis, Andreas Karavias, Paraskevi Nomikou, Κωνσταντίνος Καράντζαλος, Nikolaos Koukouzas, Ioannis Athinelis, Stavroula Kazana, Issaak ParcharidisGeoHazards 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study develops a multi-hazard susceptibility assessment framework for the low-lying coastal areas of the South Aegean Volcanic Arc islands (Milos and Thira) using the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP). The research integrates multiple natural hazards—landslides, torrential floods, soil erosion, and tsunamis—to identify vulnerable regions, providing crucial insights for coastal management and disaster risk reduction in these tourism-dependent areas.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coastal regions are increasingly vulnerable to a confluence of natural hazards, exacerbated by climate change and human development. The South Aegean Volcanic Arc (SAVA) islands, popular tourist destinations, face significant risks due to their unique geological setting and the concentration of human activities in low-lying coastal zones. While individual hazard assessments are common, a comprehensive, integrated approach to understanding the combined susceptibility to multiple hazards (landslides, torrential floods, soil erosion, and tsunamis) in these specific coastal environments has been lacking. This research aims to fill this gap by developing a robust methodology to map and prioritize these multi-hazard risks, enabling better-informed decision-making for coastal managers and planners.

Methods

The study employs a multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) approach, specifically the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), to integrate the susceptibility assessments of four distinct hazards: landslides, torrential floods, soil erosion, and tsunamis.

For landslide susceptibility, the Rock Engineering System (RES) method was used, which relies on an interaction matrix to quantify the relationships between 10 causal factors (e.g., lithology, precipitation, slope, seismic parameters).

Torrential flood susceptibility was assessed using the Flash Flood Potential Index (FFPI), which combines four factors: slope, land cover, soil type, and vegetation density.

Soil erosion susceptibility was modeled using the Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE), incorporating factors like rainfall erosivity, soil erodibility, slope length and steepness, land cover, and conservation practices.

Tsunami susceptibility was modeled using a scenario-based approach, estimating inundation depths based on earthquake magnitude and historical run-up data, then classifying these depths.

Finally, the AHP method was used to combine the individual hazard susceptibility maps, assigning weights to each hazard based on a pairwise comparison matrix to produce a final multi-hazard susceptibility map.

Datasets

The study utilized a variety of geospatial datasets, including:

  • Sentinel-2 satellite images (2016-2021): Used for calculating the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and Bare Soil Index (BSI).
  • Digital Elevation Model (DEM): Acquired from the National Cadastre for morphological analysis.
  • Geological information: Obtained from the Hellenic Survey of Geology and Mineral Exploration (HSGME).
  • Land use data: From the Corine 2018 dataset.
  • Road network data: Combined from OpenStreetMap (OSM) and Microsoft datasets.
  • Active faults and earthquake epicenters: From the National Observatory of Athens and the National and Kapodistrian University of Athens.
  • Precipitation data: From the Hellenic National Meteorological Service (HNMS).
  • Soil data: Derived from LUCAS datasets via the Joint Research Centre (JRC).
  • Topographic data: Including slope and curvature derived from the DEM.
  • Seismic parameters: Including earthquake kernel density and depth.
  • Tectonic plate seismic data: Used for tsunami modeling.
  • Google Earth Pro imagery: Used for visual validation and landslide inventory creation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated Approach is Crucial: The study strongly emphasizes that a multi-hazard assessment is essential for understanding the true risk in complex coastal environments, as individual hazard assessments can overlook critical interactions and cumulative impacts.
  • Landslides as the Dominant Threat: Despite the presence of other hazards, landslides emerged as the most prevalent threat, driven by the region's geological characteristics and frequent seismic activity.
  • Coastal Infrastructure at High Risk: A significant portion of critical infrastructure, including built-up areas, transportation networks, and seaports, falls within high and very high susceptibility zones, highlighting the urgent need for targeted mitigation strategies.
  • Tourism Dependency Amplifies Risk: The high concentration of tourism activities in vulnerable coastal areas means that natural hazards pose a direct threat to the region's economy and livelihoods.
  • AHP as a Robust Integration Tool: The AHP proved effective in synthesizing diverse hazard assessments into a single, actionable susceptibility map, demonstrating its utility for complex decision-making.

Key Results

  • Landslide Susceptibility: Over 10% of the low-lying coastal areas on Milos and Thira islands were classified as high or very high susceptibility zones for landslides. Southeastern Milos and southern Thira were identified as particularly vulnerable.
  • Torrential Flood Susceptibility: A significant portion of Milos Island's coastal region (over 70%) showed high to very high susceptibility to torrential floods, with eastern and southern Thira also exhibiting considerable risk.
  • Soil Erosion Susceptibility: Soil erosion potential was generally low across both islands, with over 90% of areas falling into low or very low susceptibility classes. However, higher values were noted near drainage networks.
  • Tsunami Susceptibility: Low-lying coastal areas, especially those adjacent to the coastline and with lower elevations, were found to be vulnerable to tsunamis. High and very high susceptibility classes covered up to 20% of Milos and 26% of Thira.
  • Multi-Hazard Susceptibility: The integrated AHP analysis revealed that over 30% of built-up areas, 20% of the transportation network, and 50% of seaports are within high and very high susceptibility zones for combined hazards.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Scenario Focus: The study acknowledges that it focused on one adopted scenario, considering landslide susceptibility as the most important hazard. Future work could explore different weighting scenarios or incorporate additional hazards.
  • Data Limitations: The study noted the lack of detailed soil maps, necessitating the use of lithological data as a proxy.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest expanding the research to include other hazards like volcanic activity and hydrothermal phenomena. They also propose using advanced remote sensing techniques (e.g., InSAR) for shoreline change analysis and integrating high-frequency radar data for tsunami early warning and sea-level rise monitoring. The development of multi-hazard integration with other hazards and the use of advanced remote sensing methods are highlighted as key areas for future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

Coastal environments are highly recognized for their spectacular morphological features and economic activities, such as agriculture, maritime traffic, fishing, and tourism. In the context of climate change and the evolution of physical processes, the occurrence of intense natural phenomena adjacent to populated coastal areas may result in natural hazards, causing human and/or structural losses. As an outcome, scientific interest in researching and assessing multi-hazard susceptibility techniques has increased rapidly in an effort to better understand spatial patterns that are threatening coastal exposed elements, with or without temporal coincidence. The islands of Milos and Thira (Santorini Island) in Greece are prone to natural hazards due to their unique volcano-tectonic setting, the high number of tourist visits annually, and the unplanned expansion of urban fabric within the boundaries of the low-lying coastal zone. The main goal of this research is to analyze the onshore coastal terrain’s susceptibility to natural hazards, identifying regions that are vulnerable to soil erosion, torrential flooding, landslides and tsunamis. Therefore, the objective of this work is the development of a multi-hazard approach to the South Aegean Volcanic Arc (SAVA) islands, integrating them into a superimposed susceptibility map utilizing Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) analysis. The illustrated geospatial workflow introduces a promising multi-hazard tool that can be implemented in low-lying coastal regions globally, regardless of their morphometric and manmade characteristics. Consequently, findings indicated that more than 30% of built-up areas, 20% of the transportation network, and 50% of seaports are within the high and very high susceptible zones, in terms of the Extended Low Elevation Coastal Zone (ELECZ). Coastal managers and decision-makers must develop a strategic plan in order to minimize potential economic and natural losses, private property damage, and tourism infrastructure degradation from potential inundation and erosion occurrences, which are likely to increase in the foreseeable future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{krassakis2023multi,
  author = {Pavlos Krassakis and Andreas Karavias and Paraskevi Nomikou and Κωνσταντίνος Καράντζαλος and Nikolaos Koukouzas and Ioannis Athinelis and Stavroula Kazana and Issaak Parcharidis},
  title = {{Multi-Hazard Susceptibility Assessment Using the Analytical Hierarchy Process in Coastal Regions of South Aegean Volcanic Arc Islands}},
  booktitle = {GeoHazards},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/geohazards4010006},
}
Figure