Multi-fault diagnosis of Industrial Rotating Machines using Data-driven approach : A review of two decades of research

Shreyas Gawde, Shruti Patil, Satish Kumar, Pooja Kamat, Ketan Kotecha, Ajith AbrahamEngineering Applications of AI 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive systematic review of data-driven multi-fault diagnosis techniques for industrial rotating machines over the past two decades. It highlights the critical need for advanced AI approaches to handle complex, multi-fault scenarios, moving beyond single-fault detection to enhance predictive maintenance strategies in Industry 4.0.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses a significant gap in the literature concerning the multi-fault diagnosis of industrial rotating machines. While Industry 4.0 emphasizes smart manufacturing and predictive maintenance (PdM), most existing research focuses on diagnosing single faults. This is insufficient for real-world industrial environments where multiple faults can occur simultaneously or interact, leading to misdiagnosis, reduced accuracy, and potential equipment failure. The authors aim to consolidate knowledge on data-driven approaches for multi-fault diagnosis, covering everything from sensor selection and data acquisition to advanced AI techniques, to provide a robust foundation for future research.

Methods

The authors employ a systematic literature review using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines. This rigorous methodology involves:

  • Framing Research Questions: Defining specific questions to guide the review (e.g., "What are the different approaches employed?", "What are the available data sources?").
  • Search Stage: Conducting comprehensive searches on databases like Scopus and Web of Science using defined keywords.
  • Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria: Applying strict criteria to select relevant articles published between 2011-2021, focusing on English literature and specific research themes.
  • Quality Assessment: Evaluating selected articles based on criteria related to multi-fault diagnosis, data collection, signal processing, and AI techniques.
  • Data Analysis: Synthesizing findings from the selected literature to answer the research questions and identify trends, challenges, and research gaps.

The paper also discusses various AI approaches, including Machine Learning (ML) and Deep Learning (DL) techniques, and their application in fault diagnosis.

Datasets

The paper discusses several publicly available datasets commonly used for bearing fault diagnosis, including:

  • Case Western Reserve University (CWRU) dataset: Ball-bearing test data for normal and defective bearings.
  • FEMTO Dataset: Used for estimating Remaining Useful Life (RUL).
  • IMS bearing dataset: Provides a comprehensive natural bearing defect history.
  • NASA Prognostic Centre of Excellence (PCoE) datasets: Includes various prognostic data sets.
  • MFPT (Society for Machinery Failure Prevention Technology) dataset: Offers condition-based maintenance data for bearings and gears.
  • Mendeley Data: Contains vibration signals from bearings under varying conditions.
  • IEEE DataPort: A platform for storing, searching, and accessing standard datasets.
  • Paderborn University dataset: Includes synchronous measurements of motor current and vibration signals.
  • SpectraQuest's Machinery Fault Simulator (MFS) dataset: Covers six different simulated states.

The authors note that while online datasets are convenient, they often have limitations in terms of fault variety and real-world complexity, suggesting the need for custom test rigs for more comprehensive data collection.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The critical need for multi-fault diagnosis: The paper strongly emphasizes that real-world industrial machinery rarely experiences single faults. Addressing multiple, interacting faults is crucial for accurate and reliable PdM.
  • Data-driven approaches are paramount: With the advent of Industry 4.0 and the proliferation of sensors, data-driven methods, particularly those leveraging AI and Big Data, are becoming the cornerstone of advanced fault diagnosis.
  • Sensor fusion is key to accuracy: Relying on single sensor data is insufficient. Multi-sensor data fusion, combining information from various sources, significantly improves diagnostic accuracy and robustness by providing a more holistic view of the machine's condition.
  • The research landscape is evolving: While significant progress has been made, there are still considerable research gaps, particularly in areas like domain adaptation, transfer learning, and the interpretability of AI models for industrial applications.
  • Challenges in real-world implementation: Issues like data availability, quality, accessibility, and the cost of data collection remain significant hurdles for deploying AI-driven PdM systems in industrial settings.

Key Results

The paper presents a systematic review of research over two decades, highlighting:

  • Evolution of Maintenance Strategies: Tracing the shift from breakdown maintenance to preventive, condition-based, and finally, predictive maintenance.
  • Comprehensive Overview of AI Techniques: Detailed discussion of various AI algorithms (ML, DL, hybrid approaches) used for fault diagnosis, including their strengths and weaknesses.
  • Analysis of Signal Processing Methods: Exploration of time-domain, frequency-domain, and time-frequency domain features for extracting relevant information from sensor data.
  • Identification of Research Gaps: The review clearly outlines areas where research is lacking, such as the multi-modal aspect of data, handling industrial conditions, and validating models in real-time environments.
  • Summary of Challenges: The paper details challenges related to data, AI models (interpretability, adversarial perturbations), and network/cloud security.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The study's scope is limited to a sample of research journals and keywords, potentially excluding relevant work from other sources. * The review primarily focuses on data-driven approaches, with less emphasis on physics-based or knowledge-based methods.

Future Work: * Multi-sensor data fusion and multimodal analysis: Further research is needed to integrate data from diverse sensors and modalities for more robust multi-fault diagnosis. * Domain Adaptation and Transfer Learning: Developing models that can adapt to different machinery configurations and changing industrial conditions is crucial. * Real-time validation: Algorithms need to be validated in actual industrial environments to prove their efficacy. * Digital Twin integration: Exploring the synergy between Digital Twins and predictive maintenance for enhanced diagnostics and prognostics. * Hybrid approaches: Combining data-driven strategies with hybrid decision-making algorithms to mitigate individual model uncertainties. * Advanced AI techniques: Investigating Reinforcement Learning for model optimization, Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) for data augmentation, and Explainable AI (XAI) for model interpretability. * Addressing security and scalability: Developing secure and scalable AI/ML models for industrial applications, considering both cloud and edge computing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Industry 4.0 is an era of smart manufacturing. Manufacturing is impossible without the use of machinery. The majority of these machines comprise rotating components and are called rotating machines. The engineers’ top priority is to maintain these critical machines to reduce the unplanned shutdown and increase the useful life of machinery. Predictive maintenance is the current trend of smart maintenance, followed by most maintenance engineers. The challenging task in predictive maintenance is to diagnose the type of fault. With Artificial Intelligence (AI) advancement, a data-driven approach for predictive maintenance is taking a new flight towards smart manufacturing. Several researchers have published work related to fault diagnosis in rotating machines, mainly exploring a single type of fault. However, a consolidated review of literature that focuses more on the “multi-fault diagnosis” aspect of rotating machines is lacking. There is a need for a study that would systematically cover all the aspects right from sensor selection, data acquisition, feature extraction, multi-sensor data fusion to the systematic review of AI techniques employed in multiple fault diagnosis. In this regard, this paper attempts to achieve the same by implementing a systematic literature review on a Data-driven approach for multi-fault diagnosis of Industrial Rotating Machines using the “Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis” (PRISMA) method. The PRISMA method is a collection of guidelines for the composition and structure of systematic reviews and other meta-analyses. This paper identifies the foundational work done in the field and gives a comparative study of different aspects related to multi-fault diagnosis of industrial rotating machines. The paper also identifies the major challenges, research gap. It gives solutions using recent advancements in AI in implementing multi-fault diagnosis, giving a strong base for future research in this field.
BibTeX
@article{gawde2022multi,
  author = {Shreyas Gawde and Shruti Patil and Satish Kumar and Pooja Kamat and Ketan Kotecha and Ajith Abraham},
  title = {{Multi-fault diagnosis of Industrial Rotating Machines using Data-driven approach : A review of two decades of research}},
  journal = {Engineering Applications of AI},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=aTxJi8i96U},
}
Figure