Multi-Criteria Evaluation of Best Available Treatment Technology for Waste Lead-Acid Battery: The Case of China

Wei Wang, Yi He, Deyuan Zhang, Yufeng Wu, Dean PanSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical issue of waste lead-acid battery (LAB) disposal by developing a multi-criteria evaluation framework to identify the "Best Available Treatment Technology" (BATT) in China. Using a novel combination of the Delphi-Attribute Hierarchy Model (AHM) and attribute mathematics theory, they evaluated five common recycling technologies, recommending Mixed Smelting Technology (MST), Pre-desulfurization and Multi-chamber Smelting Technology (PD-MCST), and Direct Smelting Technology (DST) as optimal for current needs, with DST showing particular promise for future development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global demand for lead-acid batteries (LABs), driven by the automotive and energy storage sectors, is leading to a significant increase in waste LABs. Improper disposal of these batteries poses severe environmental and health risks due to the presence of lead and its compounds, which are persistent pollutants. While various recycling technologies exist, there's a lack of a comprehensive and scientifically rigorous framework to evaluate and compare them, especially concerning their pollution control capabilities. This paper aims to fill that gap by establishing such a framework and applying it to identify the most effective BATTs for waste LAB treatment in China.

Methods

The authors employed a two-pronged methodological approach:

  1. Delphi-Attribute Hierarchy Model (AHM): This method was used to determine the relative weights of various evaluation indicators. It combines expert opinions (gathered through a Delphi process) with a hierarchical structure to systematically assign importance to different criteria and sub-criteria. Unlike traditional AHP, AHM avoids consistency checks, making it more practical for complex decision-making.
  2. Attribute Mathematics Theory: This theory was utilized to quantify and compare the performance of different technologies across the identified indicators. It allows for the conversion of qualitative descriptions and quantitative data into attribute measures, enabling a comprehensive evaluation and ranking of the technologies. The process involved calculating single-index attribute measures, then synthesizing them into overall measures for each technology, and finally performing attribute recognition analysis to determine their classification (e.g., excellent, good, medium).

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from five waste LAB recycling technologies operating in China, specifically from enterprises located in Henan, Jiangsu, Hubei, Jiangxi, and Guizhou provinces. Data was also sourced from public literature and interviews with environmental department professionals. The scope of sub-criteria was determined based on current Chinese laws, regulations, industrial policies, and technical specifications related to waste management and lead battery recycling. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing industry data and literature were compiled and analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Environmental Impact is Paramount: The study strongly emphasizes that environmental effect and comprehensive resource utilization are the most critical factors in evaluating waste LAB treatment technologies. This highlights a shift towards prioritizing sustainability over purely economic gains in this sector.
  • Lead Dust Emission is a Major Concern: Among all indicators, lead dust emission was identified as the most significant factor for BATT evaluation. This underscores the persistent challenge of controlling airborne lead pollution in the secondary lead industry.
  • Holistic Evaluation is Crucial: The research demonstrates that a comprehensive evaluation considering multiple dimensions (environmental, resource, technical, economic, and management) is essential for selecting truly effective BATTs, moving beyond single-issue assessments.
  • DST's Future Potential: While MST, PD-MCST, and DST are recommended for current use, the Direct Smelting Technology (DST) is highlighted for its significant potential for future development due to its economic advantages and reduced environmental footprint, particularly its ability to avoid costly pre-desulfurization.

Key Results

The evaluation of five waste LAB recycling technologies yielded the following:

  • Ranking: Process D (Mixed Smelting Technology - MST) was ranked highest, followed closely by Process A (Pre-desulfurization and Multi-chamber Smelting Technology - PD-MCST) and Process E (Direct Smelting Technology - DST), all falling into the "Good" category. Process B (Pre-desulfurization and Rotary Kiln Smelting Technology - PD-RKST) was rated "Medium," and Process C (Pre-desulfurization and Blast Furnace Smelting Technology - PD-BFST) was deemed "Poor."
  • BATT Recommendation: Based on the evaluation, MST, PD-MCST, and DST were recommended as the Best Available Treatment Technologies (BATTs) for waste LABs in China at the current stage.
  • Validation of DST: The validation study confirmed that DST can meet China's stringent pollution control standards for lead and SO2 emissions, reinforcing its suitability. For instance, final emissions of Pb and SO2 were significantly lower than the national standards.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subjectivity in Expert Evaluation: The authors acknowledge that not all evaluation indicators could be quantified, and some relied on expert judgment, introducing a degree of subjectivity into the assessment.
  • Long-term Vision for DST: While DST is promising, the paper suggests that in the long term, as the volume of waste LABs increases, further reduction of discard slag lead content and freshwater consumption for DST needs to be addressed.
  • Process Optimization for A: For Process A, minimizing waste generation through process optimization is identified as a critical challenge for improving its competitiveness and sustainability.
  • Further Research: The paper's findings provide a foundation for guiding enterprises in technology selection and for improving the technological level and environmental protection efficiency of the secondary lead industry. Future work could focus on refining the quantitative assessment of qualitative indicators and exploring novel technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Improper waste lead-acid battery (LAB) disposal not only damages the environment, but also leads to potential safety hazards. Given that waste best available treatment technology (BATT) plays a major role in environmental protection, pertinent research has largely focused on evaluating typical recycling technologies and recommending the BATT for waste LABs. First the evaluation indicators were selected based on the analysis of main factors affecting the pollution control of waste LAB treatment. The relative weights of each indicator were determined via the Delphi-attribute hierarchy model (AHM) in the second step. To determine the BATT, the attributive mathematics theory was adopted to calculate the attribute measure of single and multiple indices. Then, five recycling technologies commonly used in the secondary lead industry were estimated using the proposed evaluation system, and the feasibility of the recommended BATT was preliminarily verified. The results indicated that mixed smelting technology (MST), pre-desulfurization and multi-chamber smelting technology (PD-MCST), and direct smelting technology (DST) were found to perform well and were therefore deemed optimal for waste LAB disposal at this stage. The validation study showed that the DST can meet the requirements of pollution control, which is consistent with the evaluation results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020multi,
  author = {Wei Wang and Yi He and Deyuan Zhang and Yufeng Wu and Dean Pan},
  title = {{Multi-Criteria Evaluation of Best Available Treatment Technology for Waste Lead-Acid Battery: The Case of China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12114479},
}
Figure