Multi-Criteria-Based Key Transmission Section Identification and Prevention–Emergency Coordinated Optimal Control Strategy

Xinyu Peng, Chuan He, Honghao Zhang, Lu Nan, Tianqi Liu, Jian Gao, Biao Wang, Xi Ye, Xinwei SunEnergies 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to pinpoint critical "key transmission sections" in power grids by considering multiple factors like topology, power flow, and voltage. It then proposes a coordinated control strategy to prevent and manage potential failures in these sections, ultimately enhancing grid stability and reducing blackout risks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Large-scale power outages, or blackouts, are a significant concern, often stemming from "weak links" in the power grid that can lead to cascading failures. Identifying these weak links, specifically "key transmission sections" that are crucial for power flow, is vital for grid stability. Existing methods for identifying these critical sections often focus on single criteria (like topology alone) or suffer from redundancy and a lack of comprehensive analysis. Furthermore, there's a need for a unified approach that coordinates preventative measures before a fault occurs with emergency responses after a fault, addressing the interplay between these two crucial aspects of grid management.

Methods

The paper proposes a two-pronged approach:

  1. Multi-Criteria Key Transmission Section Identification:
    • Critical Line Identification: A comprehensive criticality index for individual transmission lines is developed, combining topological (edge betweenness centrality), power flow (operating power flow vs. capacity), and voltage (proximity to collapse) characteristics.
  2. Initial Transmission Section Generation: Using a Depth-First Search (DFS) algorithm, initial transmission sections are identified as cut-sets of lines with consistent power flow direction.
  3. Key Transmission Section Selection: The Theil index is employed to analyze the imbalance of power flow impacts on lines within and outside of initial transmission sections after a critical line fault. This helps identify sections with strong internal electrical correlation, distinguishing them as key transmission sections.
  4. Prevention–Emergency Coordinated Optimal Control Strategy:
    • Optimization Model: An optimization model is formulated to minimize the combined costs of prevention and emergency control, considering anticipated faults, generator costs, and load shedding.
  5. Constraint Relaxation: A constraint relaxation factor is introduced to decompose the complex, coupled prevention and emergency control problem into two sub-problems.
  6. Golden Section Method: This iterative method is used to efficiently search for the optimal value of the constraint relaxation factor, thereby finding the best balance between prevention and emergency control costs and achieving the overall optimal coordinated control solution.

Datasets

The proposed methods were evaluated using the IEEE 39-bus system, a standard benchmark for power system analysis. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic Criticality: Acknowledging that a single metric isn't enough, combining topology, power flow, and voltage provides a more accurate picture of a transmission line's criticality. This is crucial because a line might be topologically central but not heavily loaded, or vice-versa.
  • Theil Index for Correlation: Using the Theil index to analyze power flow impact distribution after a fault is an innovative way to quantify the internal electrical correlation within a transmission section. This helps filter out sections that might appear critical based on individual lines but lack cohesive behavior.
  • Coordinated Control is Key: The paper highlights that prevention and emergency controls are not independent. A well-designed coordinated strategy can significantly reduce overall costs and improve system resilience by leveraging the strengths of both.
  • Constraint Relaxation as a Bridge: The constraint relaxation factor effectively bridges the gap between prevention and emergency control, allowing for a systematic optimization of their trade-offs.

Key Results

  • The proposed multi-criteria criticality index for lines was shown to be more effective than existing methods in identifying critical lines, as demonstrated by a comparative analysis of network efficiency under simulated attacks.
  • The key transmission section identification method successfully identified critical sections in the IEEE 39-bus system, with one identified section (116-17) being particularly critical due to its role in transmitting power from generators to loads and its high susceptibility to cascading failures.
  • The coordinated prevention-emergency control strategy achieved an optimal solution with a total cost of $2762 at a constraint relaxation factor of p = 0.8119, demonstrating the ability to balance prevention and emergency control costs.
  • The method effectively reduced emergency control costs by implementing reasonable prevention measures, thereby improving overall system safety.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the golden section method is efficient, the initial identification of critical lines and initial transmission sections can still be computationally intensive for very large power systems.
  • Anticipated Faults: The model relies on a pre-defined set of anticipated faults. The accuracy of the control strategy is dependent on the completeness and accuracy of this fault set.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research into more advanced identification methods and exploring dynamic control strategies that can adapt to real-time system conditions. Investigating the impact of renewable energy integration on key transmission section identification and control would also be a valuable direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Large-scale blackouts in power systems are often triggered by weak links susceptible to cascading failures. As the concentrated reflection of the system’s weak links, identifying key transmission sections and further implementing safety control measures are of great significance for ensuring the stable operation of the system. This paper proposes a multi-criteria-based method for identifying key transmission sections and an optimal strategy for the prevention–emergency coordinated control of key transmission sections. Firstly, a line criticality index based on three characteristics—topology, power flow, and voltage—has been established to identify critical lines. Furthermore, search for all initial transmission sections that include the critical line, and form the initial transmission section set for each critical line, then, based on the analysis of the Theil index of power flow impact rate distribution after the failure of critical lines, a key transmission section identification method integrating multiple criteria is proposed. Then, based on the anticipated faults of key transmission sections, an optimization model for the prevention–emergency coordinated control of key transmission sections is established. A constraint relaxation factor is introduced to divide the above model into two independent sub-problems, then the golden section method is applied to update the value of constraint relaxation factors, so as to iteratively search for the optimal solution of the model. Finally, the feasibility and correctness of the proposed method are verified through the simulation and analysis of the IEEE 39-bus system. The results demonstrate that the proposed method can effectively identify the key transmission sections of the system and improve the operational safety of the system through the prevention–emergency coordinated optimal control strategy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{peng2025multi,
  author = {Xinyu Peng and Chuan He and Honghao Zhang and Lu Nan and Tianqi Liu and Jian Gao and Biao Wang and Xi Ye and Xinwei Sun},
  title = {{Multi-Criteria-Based Key Transmission Section Identification and Prevention–Emergency Coordinated Optimal Control Strategy}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/en18225871},
}
Figure