TL;DR
This paper presents a novel approach to fabricating complex, multi-layer electronic circuits directly onto curved surfaces using multi-axis, multi-material 3D printing (MEX) combined with electroplating. This method offers a potentially lower-cost and less complex alternative to traditional in-space electronics manufacturing, enabling on-demand repairs and upgrades for space missions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The space industry faces a significant challenge in fabricating electronics locally, which is crucial for mission resilience, reducing Earth dependency, and enabling in-mission upgrades. Current methods for in-space electronics fabrication are often complex, expensive, or limited in their ability to create intricate, multi-layer circuits on non-planar surfaces. This paper addresses the need for a more accessible and versatile in-space additive manufacturing solution for electronics, particularly for conformal (curved) surfaces, which are common in spacecraft design.
Methods
The core of this work lies in the integration of several additive manufacturing techniques:
- Multi-Axis, Multi-Material Material Extrusion (MEX): This involves a 3D printer capable of printing in multiple axes and with different materials. The substrate was printed using Polylactic Acid (PLA), and the conductive traces were printed using Electrifi filament.
- Conformal Printing: The 3D model of the circuit was projected onto a curved substrate, allowing for the creation of circuits that follow the contours of the surface.
- Electroplating: To enhance the conductivity of the printed Electrifi traces and make them comparable to traditional PCBs, copper electroplating was employed. This involved a custom setup with a plating bath, copper anode, and a variable power supply.
- Small Multi-Material Bridges: A novel aspect of this work is the introduction of small bridges made from PLA. These bridges are designed to span over conductive traces, enabling multi-layer circuitry without requiring complex via drilling and facilitating electroplating access.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the fabrication and testing of custom-designed circuits.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Conformal Electronics Fabrication is Achievable: The research successfully demonstrates the ability to print functional electronic circuits directly onto curved surfaces, opening up new possibilities for integrating electronics into complex spacecraft geometries.
- MEX + Electroplating as a Viable Alternative: The combination of MEX printing and electroplating offers a promising, lower-cost, and less complex alternative to existing in-space electronics manufacturing methods.
- Small Bridges for Miniaturization and Multi-layering: The introduction of small, multi-material PLA bridges is a clever solution for enabling multi-layer circuitry and addressing miniaturization challenges in 3D-printed electronics. These bridges also facilitate electroplating by creating space for the electrolyte.
- On-Demand Repair and Upgrade Potential: The ability to fabricate circuits in-situ significantly enhances mission resilience by allowing for on-demand repairs, replacements, or even upgrades to electronic systems during a mission.
- Trade-offs in Performance: While the printed circuits demonstrated functionality, they exhibited increased noise and reduced reliability compared to traditional FR4 PCBs, highlighting areas for future improvement.
Key Results
- Functional Circuitry: The fabricated circuits, based on a DC-DC switching voltage regulator, were able to regulate and deliver current, demonstrating the functional capability of the printed electronics.
- Dimensional Accuracy: The printed pads and traces generally showed larger dimensions than designed, with an average error of around 11-18% for pads and 18-23% for traces across different samples. Sample P1 exhibited the best dimensional accuracy.
- Bridge Performance: The bridges showed significant dimensional discrepancies (26-73% error in width and 56-73% in height), but the Electrifi traces adhered well to the PLA bridges in the best cases, demonstrating successful bridging.
- Electrical Performance: The printed circuits showed more noise and less stable voltage output compared to the FR4 benchmark, particularly under load. However, they were still capable of delivering sufficient power to actuate an intended burn-wire.
- Thermal Testing: Preliminary thermal testing showed that one sample (F2) was unaffected by low temperatures, while another (P4) showed some degradation, though this was potentially linked to prior electrical loading.
Limitations and Future Work
- Dimensional Accuracy: The paper acknowledges that the printed parts, particularly pads and traces, were larger than designed. This is attributed to factors like nozzle residue and potential mismatches in the 5-axis calibration process.
- Noise and Reliability: The printed circuits exhibited higher noise and reduced reliability compared to traditional PCBs.
- Component Assembly: The manual assembly of components using conductive epoxy was time-consuming, error-prone, and less reversible, posing a significant bottleneck.
- Bridge Design: While functional, the bridges had significant dimensional errors. Future work should focus on improving their accuracy and potentially exploring alternative designs or materials.
- Future Work Suggestions:
- More extensive and complex circuit characterization.
- Developing more reliable ways to miniaturize 3D-printed circuitry.
- Increasing the reliability and repeatability of MEX 3D printed electronics.
- Investigating more advanced component assembly methods, potentially automated pick-and-place solutions compatible with conformal substrates.
- Further investigation into the effects of uneven shrinkage and repeated thermal cycling.
Summary updated