Multi-Agent Modeling and Jamming-Aware Routing Protocols for Movable-Jammer-Affected WSNs

Biao Xu, Minyan Lu, Hong ZhangSensors 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel multi-agent modeling approach and a jamming-aware routing protocol (JRP) to address the largely unexplored threat of movable jammers in Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs). The JRP effectively helps WSNs maintain connectivity and reliability by intelligently routing data around jammer-affected areas, demonstrating significant improvements over existing protocols.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) are increasingly deployed for critical applications, from environmental monitoring to military operations. Their reliability is paramount, but they are susceptible to various security threats, including jamming attacks. Jamming disrupts communication by emitting interfering signals, degrading network performance, increasing energy consumption, and potentially causing complete communication failure. While research has addressed static jammers, the impact and mitigation of movable jammers—which can dynamically change their position and thus their area of influence—remain a significant and under-researched challenge. This mobility makes detecting and countering jamming attacks much more complex, posing a substantial threat to WSN reliability and mission success.

Methods

The authors propose a comprehensive approach centered around multi-agent modeling and a novel jamming-aware routing protocol (JRP).

  • Multi-Agent Modeling: They model the WSN environment as a system of interacting agents, including sensor nodes, a base station, and jammers. This approach allows for the simulation of complex, dynamic interactions and emergent behaviors.
  • Jamming-Aware Routing Protocol (JRP): The core of their solution is the JRP, which deviates from traditional routing protocols by incorporating two key factors when selecting relay nodes:
  • Depth: This is the traditional metric representing the number of hops to the base station, ensuring progress towards the destination.
  • Jamming Value: This metric quantifies the perceived interference intensity from jammers. Sensor nodes collect this information through environmental sensing and message exchange. The JRP uses a weighted combination of depth and jamming values to select the optimal next-hop node, prioritizing paths that avoid jammer-affected areas.

  • Maintenance Mechanisms: To further enhance robustness, the JRP includes:

  • Local Maintenance: Sensor nodes dynamically recalculate their target values and update their neighbors when they detect a significant change in jamming intensity, allowing for quick adaptation to jammer movements.
  • Global Maintenance: Periodically, the base station initiates a depth broadcast to reset sensor node depths, helping to maintain an efficient network structure and prevent issues arising from prolonged local adaptations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors developed their own simulation environment in NetLogo and generated synthetic data based on defined parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Movable Jammers are a Game Changer: The study unequivocally demonstrates that jammer mobility significantly amplifies the threat to WSN reliability. A dynamic jammer can disrupt communication patterns far more effectively than a static one.
  • Depth Alone Isn't Enough: Traditional routing protocols relying solely on hop count (depth) are insufficient against mobile jammers. The JRP's integration of jamming awareness is crucial for maintaining connectivity.
  • Local Maintenance is Key for Responsiveness: The local maintenance mechanism allows WSNs to react quickly to jammer movements, re-routing traffic and maintaining connectivity in near real-time.
  • Global Maintenance for Robustness, Not Speed: While global maintenance didn't significantly reduce latency in their simulations, it proved vital for network robustness by preventing over-reliance on a few central relay nodes, which could be catastrophic if jammed.
  • Airborne Jammers are Devastating: The research highlights that jammers deployed on aerial platforms (like drones) have a disproportionately larger impact due to their wider coverage, making them significantly more destructive than ground-based jammers.

Key Results

  • JRP Outperforms: In simulations, the JRP consistently achieved higher Maximum Connected Subgraph (MCS) values (representing the number of nodes connected to the base station) compared to standard protocols like AODV and DSR, especially under jamming conditions.
  • Mobility Impact: The study showed that the continuous movement of a jammer significantly degrades WSN reliability. Local maintenance improved MCS by up to 30% compared to no maintenance.
  • Jammer Density and Location Matter: Increasing the number of jammers led to a decrease in MCS. Notably, a single air jammer was found to be more destructive than four ground jammers.
  • Global Maintenance Enhances Robustness: While not significantly impacting Average Path Length (APL), global maintenance improved MCS by preventing the concentration of relay nodes, thus making the network more resilient to jammer attacks.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation Environment Simplification: The authors acknowledge that their simulation parameter design is a simplification of real-world scenarios. Future work could involve configuring parameters to more closely match actual environmental conditions.
  • Jammer Strategy Ignored: The current study focuses on the impact of jammer mobility but doesn't model the jammer's strategic deployment or movement patterns. Future research could explore game theory to model attacker strategies and defender detection strategies.
  • Routing Factors: The JRP currently considers only depth and jamming for routing decisions. Given WSN energy constraints, future work should integrate residual energy as a crucial factor, as nodes with heavier relay tasks consume energy faster. This would lead to a more holistic routing decision process.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wireless sensor networks (WSNs) are widely used in various fields, and the reliability and performance of WSNs are critical for their applications. However, WSNs are vulnerable to jamming attacks, and the impact of movable jammers on WSNs' reliability and performance remains largely unexplored. This study aims to investigate the impact of movable jammers on WSNs and propose a comprehensive approach for modeling jammer-affected WSNs, comprising four parts. Firstly, agent-based modeling of sensor nodes, base stations, and jammers has been proposed. Secondly, a jamming-aware routing protocol (JRP) has been proposed to enable sensor nodes to weigh depth and jamming values when selecting relay nodes, thereby bypassing areas affected by jamming. The third and fourth parts involve simulation processes and parameter design for simulations. The simulation results show that the mobility of the jammer significantly affects WSNs' reliability and performance, and JRP effectively bypasses jammed areas and maintains network connectivity. Furthermore, the number and deployment location of jammers has a significant impact on WSNs' reliability and performance. These findings provide insights into the design of reliable and efficient WSNs under jamming attacks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2023multi,
  author = {Biao Xu and Minyan Lu and Hong Zhang},
  title = {{Multi-Agent Modeling and Jamming-Aware Routing Protocols for Movable-Jammer-Affected WSNs}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23083846},
}
Figure