mTOR-mediated podocyte hypertrophy regulates glomerular integrity in mice and humans

Victor G. Puelles, James W. van der Wolde, Nicola Wanner, Markus W. Scheppach, Luise A. Cullen‐McEwen, Tillmann Bork, Maja T. Lindenmeyer, Lukas Gernhold, Milagros N. Wong, Fabian Braun, Clemens D. Cohen, Michelle M. Kett, Christoph Kuppe, Rafael Kramann, Turgay Saritas, Claudia R. van Roeyen, Marcus J. Moeller, Leon Tribolet, Richard J. Rebello, Yu Sun, Jinhua Li, Gerard Müller-Newen, Michael D. Hughson, Wendy E. Hoy, Fermín Person, Thorsten Wiech, Sharon D. Ricardo, Peter G. Kerr, Kate M. Denton, Luc Furic, Tobias B. Huber, David J. Nikolic‐Paterson, John F. BertramJCI 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The cellular origins of glomerulosclerosis involve activation of parietal epithelial cells (PECs) and progressive podocyte depletion. While mammalian target of rapamycin-mediated (mTOR-mediated) podocyte hypertrophy is recognized as an important signaling pathway in the context of glomerular disease, the role of podocyte hypertrophy as a compensatory mechanism preventing PEC activation and glomerulosclerosis remains poorly understood. In this study, we show that glomerular mTOR and PEC activation-related genes were both upregulated and intercorrelated in biopsies from patients with focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) and diabetic nephropathy, suggesting both compensatory and pathological roles. Advanced morphometric analyses in murine and human tissues identified podocyte hypertrophy as a compensatory mechanism aiming to regulate glomerular functional integrity in response to somatic growth, podocyte depletion, and even glomerulosclerosis - all of this in the absence of detectable podocyte regeneration. In mice, pharmacological inhibition of mTOR signaling during acute podocyte loss impaired hypertrophy of remaining podocytes, resulting in unexpected albuminuria, PEC activation, and glomerulosclerosis. Exacerbated and persistent podocyte hypertrophy enabled a vicious cycle of podocyte loss and PEC activation, suggesting a limit to its beneficial effects. In summary, our data highlight a critical protective role of mTOR-mediated podocyte hypertrophy following podocyte loss in order to preserve glomerular integrity, preventing PEC activation and glomerulosclerosis.

Introduction: The Challenge of Podocyte Loss

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) often originates in the glomeruli, the kidney's microscopic filtration units. The primary filters are podocytes: specialized, terminally differentiated cells that cannot divide or regenerate. When podocytes are lost due to aging or disease, such as diabetes or focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS), the remaining cells must adapt to cover the "denuded" filtration surface. If they fail, parietal epithelial cells (PECs) become activated, leading to glomerulosclerosis (scarring) and eventual kidney failure.

The role of the mTOR pathway—a master regulator of cell growth—has been controversial in this context. While mTOR hyperactivity is linked to diabetic nephropathy, some clinical uses of mTOR inhibitors have unexpectedly worsened kidney function. This research investigates whether podocyte hypertrophy is a helpful adaptation or a harmful pathological byproduct, and how mTOR mediates this balance.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach combining human clinical data with sophisticated mouse models:

  • Human Podometrics: Model-based stereology and 3D reconstruction on biopsies from patients with FSGS and Diabetic Nephropathy (DN), as well as autopsy tissue from children and adults.
  • Inducible Mouse Models: The PodCreiDTR mouse allowed for precise triggering of podocyte depletion via diphtheria toxin (DT).
  • Lineage Tracing: To definitively answer whether podocytes can regenerate, the Pod-rtTA-mT/mG-iDTR model genetically labeled existing podocytes with green fluorescent protein (eGFP).
  • Advanced Imaging: Solvent-based optical clearing and confocal microscopy enabled "whole glomerular analysis," providing accurate cell counting and volume measurements.
  • Transcriptomics: Microarray analysis on human glomerular extracts correlated gene expression of mTOR signaling with PEC activation markers.

Datasets

  • Human Biopsy Data: Sourced from the European Renal cDNA Bank, including patients with DN (n=14), FSGS (n=23), and living donors (n=42).
  • Public Transcriptomic Data: Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) accessions GSE99340, GSE32591, GSE35489, and GSE37463.
  • Morphometric Data: Derived from autopsied kidneys (University of Mississippi) and nephrectomy samples (Monash Health).

Key Insights

Hypertrophy as a Shield

Podocyte hypertrophy isn't just a symptom; it's a requirement. Remaining podocytes must grow to maintain the filtration barrier. If this growth is blocked, the resulting "leakiness" triggers PECs to swarm the area and form scars.

Figure 2: Relationship between podocyte number and glomerular volume in children, healthy adults, and adults with FSGS.

The Regeneration Myth

Using lineage tracing, the authors found zero evidence of podocyte regeneration. Recovery from injury is entirely dependent on the hypertrophy of surviving cells, rather than the birth of new ones.

The "Threshold of Doom"

The study identified a tipping point for glomerular health. Once podocyte depletion exceeds approximately 24%, even massive hypertrophy cannot prevent PEC activation and subsequent sclerosis.

The mTOR Paradox

While chronic mTOR overactivation (tested via TSC1-KO mice) eventually causes a "vicious cycle" of cell loss, acute inhibition of mTOR during a period of cell loss is disastrous. It prevents the necessary compensatory hypertrophy, turning a mild injury into severe disease.

Key Results

Human Correlation

In FSGS and DN biopsies, mTOR signaling genes were significantly upregulated and strongly intercorrelated with PEC activation markers like CD44. Surviving podocytes in FSGS patients were significantly larger than those in healthy adults, confirming a compensatory response.

Figure 1: mTOR signaling and PEC activation-related genes are upregulated and intercorrelated in human FSGS biopsies.

Experimental Failure of mTOR Inhibition

In mice with acute podocyte loss, treatment with mTOR inhibitors (RAD001 or INK128) resulted in massive albuminuria (protein in urine) and glomerulosclerosis. Control mice with the same level of cell loss but without inhibitors were able to compensate via hypertrophy and maintain filtration.

Hypertrophy Limits

In the TSC1-KO model (constant mTOR activation), podocytes grew to extreme sizes, but this eventually led to cell detachment. This suggests that there is a physical or metabolic limit to how much a single cell can compensate before the process becomes maladaptive.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The authors highlight the necessity of hypertrophy but acknowledge that the exact molecular "sensor" that tells PECs to activate when podocytes fail is still not fully understood. Given that mTOR inhibitors are common in transplant medicine and oncology, there is an urgent clinical need to develop non-invasive biomarkers to determine if a patient is undergoing "active podocyte loss." This would help clinicians decide when mTOR inhibitors are safe to use and when they might inadvertently trigger kidney failure. Future research will focus on finding the "Goldilocks zone" of mTOR signaling—enough to allow for protective hypertrophy without crossing into maladaptive overgrowth.

Summary updated

Abstract

The cellular origins of glomerulosclerosis involve activation of parietal epithelial cells (PECs) and progressive podocyte depletion. While mammalian target of rapamycin-mediated (mTOR-mediated) podocyte hypertrophy is recognized as an important signaling pathway in the context of glomerular disease, the role of podocyte hypertrophy as a compensatory mechanism preventing PEC activation and glomerulosclerosis remains poorly understood. In this study, we show that glomerular mTOR and PEC activation-related genes were both upregulated and intercorrelated in biopsies from patients with focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) and diabetic nephropathy, suggesting both compensatory and pathological roles. Advanced morphometric analyses in murine and human tissues identified podocyte hypertrophy as a compensatory mechanism aiming to regulate glomerular functional integrity in response to somatic growth, podocyte depletion, and even glomerulosclerosis - all of this in the absence of detectable podocyte regeneration. In mice, pharmacological inhibition of mTOR signaling during acute podocyte loss impaired hypertrophy of remaining podocytes, resulting in unexpected albuminuria, PEC activation, and glomerulosclerosis. Exacerbated and persistent podocyte hypertrophy enabled a vicious cycle of podocyte loss and PEC activation, suggesting a limit to its beneficial effects. In summary, our data highlight a critical protective role of mTOR-mediated podocyte hypertrophy following podocyte loss in order to preserve glomerular integrity, preventing PEC activation and glomerulosclerosis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{puelles2019mtor,
  author = {Victor G. Puelles and James W. van der Wolde and Nicola Wanner and Markus W. Scheppach and Luise A. Cullen‐McEwen and Tillmann Bork and Maja T. Lindenmeyer and Lukas Gernhold and Milagros N. Wong and Fabian Braun and Clemens D. Cohen and Michelle M. Kett and Christoph Kuppe and Rafael Kramann and Turgay Saritas and Claudia R. van Roeyen and Marcus J. Moeller and Leon Tribolet and Richard J. Rebello and Yu Sun and Jinhua Li and Gerard Müller-Newen and Michael D. Hughson and Wendy E. Hoy and Fermín Person and Thorsten Wiech and Sharon D. Ricardo and Peter G. Kerr and Kate M. Denton and Luc Furic and Tobias B. Huber and David J. Nikolic‐Paterson and John F. Bertram},
  title = {{mTOR-mediated podocyte hypertrophy regulates glomerular integrity in mice and humans}},
  booktitle = {JCI},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1172/jci.insight.99271},
}
Figure