mtDNAmanager: a Web-based tool for the management and quality analysis of mitochondrial DNA control-region sequences

Hwan Young Lee, Injee Song, Eunho Ha, Sung-Bae Cho, Woo Ick Yang, Kyoung-Jin ShinBMC Bioinformatics 2008 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces mtDNAmanager, a web-based tool designed to address the significant issue of errors in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequence data. It provides a user-friendly interface for managing, analyzing, and quality-checking mtDNA control-region sequences by automatically estimating haplogroups and facilitating database searches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The accuracy of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) data, particularly in forensic and scientific literature, has been a subject of ongoing controversy due to a high prevalence of errors. These errors can significantly impact research conclusions. While phylogenetic analysis and comparison with known mtDNA haplotypes have been proposed as methods to identify these errors, they often require specialized knowledge and high-quality, publicly available databases. Existing tools and databases, like HmtDB and EMPOP, have limitations, such as not handling control-region sequences effectively or lacking batch processing capabilities. This creates a need for a more accessible and comprehensive solution for mtDNA data management and quality control.

Methods

mtDNAmanager is a web-based bioinformatics resource built with PHP and Asynchronous JavaScript and XML (AJAX) for enhanced interactivity and speed. It utilizes a multithreaded, multiuser SQL database management system (MySQL) with seven tables to store mtDNA control-region sequences, sample information, and haplogroup estimation results.

The core functionality lies in its haplogroup estimation algorithm, which uses a mathematical approach based on propositional logic and hierarchical verification of diagnostic mutations. This algorithm relies on pre-defined "mutation motifs" for over 400 mtDNA haplogroups and subhaplogroups. The system distinguishes between "expected haplogroups" (based on clear diagnostic mutations) and "estimated haplogroups" (based on accompanying mutations), which aids in error detection.

The tool offers two primary query options:

  • "Include": Retrieves sequences containing the queried nucleotide polymorphisms, allowing for analysis of partial sequences or identification of shared mutations.
  • "Match": Searches for sequences that are identical to the queried data, with options to specify regions (HV1, HV2, HV3, Control Region), ignore heteroplasmic insertions, and permit mismatches to account for reporting variations.

Datasets

The paper describes the use of a comprehensive dataset for testing and validation:

  • Training/Development Data: The mtDNAmanager database itself contains 7090 mtDNA control-region sequences, categorized into five subsets: African (n=1388), West Eurasian (n=2857), East Asian (n=1557), Oceanian and Admixed (n=1288). These sequences were annotated with estimated haplogroup affiliations.
  • Evaluation Data: For testing the haplogroup estimation tools, the researchers used a dataset of over 5000 mtDNA control-region sequences with known haplogroup affiliations, sourced from previous publications and the internet. They also report good concordance with coding-region SNP data for specific populations (African Americans, Austrians, Koreans).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Phased Haplogroup Designation: The distinction between "expected" and "estimated" haplogroups is a clever way to flag potential issues. A sequence with only an "expected" haplogroup might indicate a previously unsampled phylogenetic node or a back mutation, prompting further investigation.
  • Bridging the Gap for Control-Region Data: Unlike some existing tools that focus on complete mtDNA genomes, mtDNAmanager specifically targets control-region sequences, which are commonly used in forensic and population studies.
  • User-Friendly Batch Processing: The ability for users to upload and manage their own data in batch mode significantly streamlines workflows, especially for large-scale studies or forensic casework involving multiple samples.
  • Integrated Quality Control: By combining haplogroup estimation with database screening, the tool provides a holistic approach to ensuring the quality and reliability of mtDNA data.

Key Results

  • The mtDNAmanager's haplogroup estimation tools were able to allocate over 98% of tested mtDNA sequences to an appropriate haplogroup or subhaplogroup.
  • Concordance rates with coding-region SNP data were very high (e.g., 99.3% for African Americans and Austrians, 99.7% for Koreans).
  • The tool successfully identified potential clerical errors and artificial recombination events in example cases, demonstrating its practical utility for error detection.
  • The open database contains 7090 mtDNA control-region sequences, providing a valuable resource for comparative analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Control-Region Limitations: The authors acknowledge that control-region sequence information alone might not always be sufficient for definitive haplogroup assignment compared to coding-region data. However, they propose that mtDNAmanager's motifs can highlight regions needing further investigation.
  • Data Integration: The paper mentions a commitment to continuously collect and integrate high-quality, publicly available mtDNA control-region sequence data to improve the database and screening capabilities.
  • User-Defined Databases: The tool's ability to allow users to construct and analyze their own databases is highlighted as a significant feature, enabling researchers to assess the quality of their own data and select appropriate databases for error detection.
  • Future Improvements: While not explicitly detailed as future work, the ongoing collection of data and the inherent flexibility of the web-based platform suggest potential for future expansion of haplogroup coverage and analytical features.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background For the past few years, scientific controversy has surrounded the large number of errors in forensic and literature mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) data. However, recent research has shown that using mtDNA phylogeny and referring to known mtDNA haplotypes can be useful for checking the quality of sequence data. Results We developed a Web-based bioinformatics resource "mtDNAmanager" that offers a convenient interface supporting the management and quality analysis of mtDNA sequence data. The mtDNAmanager performs computations on mtDNA control-region sequences to estimate the most-probable mtDNA haplogroups and retrieves similar sequences from a selected database. By the phased designation of the most-probable haplogroups (both expected and estimated haplogroups), mtDNAmanager enables users to systematically detect errors whilst allowing for confirmation of the presence of clear key diagnostic mutations and accompanying mutations. The query tools of mtDNAmanager also facilitate database screening with two options of "match" and "include the queried nucleotide polymorphism". In addition, mtDNAmanager provides Web interfaces for users to manage and analyse their own data in batch mode. Conclusion The mtDNAmanager will provide systematic routines for mtDNA sequence data management and analysis via easily accessible Web interfaces, and thus should be very useful for population, medical and forensic studies that employ mtDNA analysis. mtDNAmanager can be accessed at http://mtmanager.yonsei.ac.kr .
BibTeX
@article{lee2008mtdnamanager,
  author = {Hwan Young Lee and Injee Song and Eunho Ha and Sung-Bae Cho and Woo Ick Yang and Kyoung-Jin Shin},
  title = {{mtDNAmanager: a Web-based tool for the management and quality analysis of mitochondrial DNA control-region sequences}},
  journal = {BMC Bioinformatics},
  year = {2008},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=MLL93jI3MhP},
}
Figure