Abstract
ERSA lesions were evident on MRI in 10.8% of our cohort of professional soccer players referred for suspected acute thigh muscle injury. Characteristic morphology and the longitudinal length (mean 15.8 cm) distinguish ERSA lesions from recognized patterns of acute muscle injury.
Introduction
In the high-stakes environment of professional sports medicine, accurate MRI diagnosis is critical for determining return-to-play timelines. Current classification systems, such as the British Athletics Muscle Injury Classification (BAMIC), often rely on the longitudinal length of signal abnormalities to grade severity. Typically, a fluid-sensitive MRI signal exceeding 15 cm is classified as a Grade 3 injury, implying a severe tear. However, clinicians have identified a recurring pattern of long, faint signal changes that lack the structural disruption or "feathery" edema characteristic of high-grade tears. This study formally describes this entity as Exercise-Related Signal Abnormality (ERSA) to prevent misdiagnosis and unnecessary player downtime.
Methods
A multicenter retrospective review was conducted on 287 MRI studies of professional soccer players (mean age 24.3 years) referred for suspected acute thigh injuries between 2017 and 2020. Two experienced musculoskeletal radiologists independently evaluated fluid-sensitive sequences (STIR or PDFS) for specific signal morphologies: peritendinous ovoid regions and subfascial rings. Researchers recorded the anatomical location, morphology, and craniocaudal length of these lesions, while also grading any concurrent injuries using the BAMIC scale.
Morphological Classification of ERSA
The study identified three distinct morphological patterns of ERSA, categorized as Types A, B, and C.
- Type A: Peritendinous ovoid regions of increased signal surrounding a tendon.
- Type B: A subfascial ring of increased signal located just beneath the muscle's connective tissue sheath.
- Type C: A combination of both peritendinous and subfascial signal abnormalities.
Key Findings
ERSA was present in 10.8% of the cohort. The most common site was the rectus femoris (22 cases), followed by the adductor longus (11) and semitendinosus (6). Type B was the most frequent morphology observed.
A defining characteristic of ERSA is its length. The average lesion measured 15.8 cm, with some extending up to 27 cm. Despite these dimensions, which would traditionally trigger a "Grade 3" classification, ERSA lesions showed no evidence of muscle fiber disruption. Furthermore, in 67.7% of cases, ERSA was found alongside a primary injury in a different muscle or even the contralateral limb, suggesting it may be a physiological response to general exercise load rather than focal trauma. Follow-up imaging confirmed the transient nature of these lesions, as they typically resolved within weeks to months.
Discussion and Limitations
The identification of ERSA highlights a potential "length trap" in current injury grading systems. Misinterpreting these benign physiological echoes as high-grade tears can lead to significant clinical mismanagement.
However, this study's retrospective nature presents limitations. As most ERSA lesions were found in players with concurrent injuries, it remains unclear if isolated ERSA is symptomatic or merely an incidental finding. Future prospective studies are required to evaluate asymptomatic athletes, determine the underlying pathophysiology (e.g., fluid leakage or metabolic shifts), and establish specific return-to-play guidelines for isolated ERSA findings.
Summary updated