Mr-wallace at SemEval-2023 Task 5: Novel Clickbait Spoiling Algorithm Using Natural Language Processing

Vineet Saravanan, Steven WilsonACL 2023

TL;DR

This paper tackles the pervasive problem of clickbait by developing an algorithm that can both identify the type of clickbait and then "spoil" it by extracting the core information. Leveraging fine-tuned NLP models like DistilBERT and BERT, the approach aims to save users time by providing immediate insights into article content, thereby mitigating the nuisance of misleading headlines.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the age of the internet and social media, clickbait headlines have become a significant annoyance. These exaggerated or misleading titles lure users into clicking on content that often fails to deliver on its promise, primarily to drive ad revenue. This not only wastes users' time but also degrades the online experience. The SemEval-2023 Task 5 specifically aimed to address this by splitting the problem into two parts: first, classifying the type of clickbait (e.g., phrase, passage, multi-item), and second, generating a "spoiler" that reveals the essential information from the article, effectively negating the need to click.

Methods

The authors approached this task using a two-pronged NLP strategy.

For Task 1: Spoiler Type Classification, they employed a fine-tuned DistilBERT model. DistilBERT, a smaller, faster, and more efficient version of BERT, was chosen for its strong performance on text classification tasks and its suitability for resource-constrained environments like Google Colab. The input to the model included the clickbait post's title, text, keywords, and provenance. The text was preprocessed by concatenating these fields and adding periods where necessary. The clickbait types ("phrase," "passage," "multi") were converted into numerical labels for classification.

For Task 2: Spoiler Generation, they developed a BERT-based question-answering model. The core idea here is to treat the clickbait title as a question and the article's content as the context from which to extract the answer. They specifically focused on abstractive QA, aiming to generate a more relevant answer than simply extracting a span of text. The input to this model involved the clickbait post and the linked document. The process involved identifying the start and end positions of the spoiler within the target paragraph and then using a BERT-based model to predict the spoiler text.

Datasets

The paper utilizes datasets from previous work, specifically referencing Hagen et al. (2022a) for dataset statistics and Fröbe et al. (2023a) for the SemEval-2023 Task 5 definition. Figure 2 in the paper provides a detailed breakdown of these datasets, including corpus splits, source platforms (Reddit, Facebook, Twitter), spoiler types, and average text lengths. The authors also mention using the Hugging Face datasets library to host their training data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two-Stage Approach is Crucial: Breaking down clickbait spoiling into classification and generation allows for specialized models to tackle each aspect effectively.
  • DistilBERT's Efficiency: The choice of DistilBERT for classification highlights the trade-off between model size/speed and performance, proving it can achieve competitive results.
  • BERT for QA as Spoiler: Framing spoiler generation as a question-answering task is an intuitive and powerful way to extract the core information from an article.
  • Abstractive QA for Better Spoilers: Focusing on abstractive QA, rather than purely extractive, promises more coherent and relevant spoilers that capture the essence of the article.
  • Importance of Context: The success of both DistilBERT and BERT underscores the critical role of understanding word context in NLP tasks, especially for nuanced problems like clickbait.

Key Results

  • Task 1 (Spoiler Type Classification): The classification model achieved 65.3% accuracy. The authors noted that the "multi" class was particularly challenging, likely due to a smaller data representation compared to "phrase" and "passage" types.
  • Task 2 (Spoiler Generation): The question-answering model successfully spoiled clickbait approximately 42.5% of the time. For evaluation, they used the F1 score, which provided a better measure of the overall message and meaning of the generated spoiler. On the test split, the model achieved an F1 score of 0.85.
  • Performance Ranking: The system performed in the top ten for precision in the "multi" class classification.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Misclassification in Task 1: The confusion matrix (Figure 7) indicates that "phrase" and "passage" classifications were sometimes misclassified as each other. The "multi" classification also showed lower accuracy, which the authors attribute to the smaller dataset size for this category.
  • Model Comparison: While BERT-based NER models were explored, the authors found they were not optimal for this specific task compared to standard BERT or DistilBERT.
  • Future Tuning: The authors suggest that further tuning of the model, particularly for the "multi" classification, could improve performance. They also imply that exploring different model architectures or further data augmentation might be beneficial. The overall goal remains to save users time and provide quick insights into article content.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{saravanan2023mr,
  author = {Vineet Saravanan and Steven Wilson},
  title = {{Mr-wallace at SemEval-2023 Task 5: Novel Clickbait Spoiling Algorithm Using Natural Language Processing}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure